ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

High-Pressure Heat Exchanger Cladding Cracking: Lessons from a Coal Tar Hydrogenation Unit

1. The Incident and the Initial Inspection Findings

The paper describes a failure that is all too familiar to anyone who has worked with high-pressure equipment in hydroprocessing service. A high-pressure heat exchanger in a coal tar hydrogenation unit developed extensive surface cracking in the cladding layer of the tube-side outlet nozzle. The unit was in service, and the cracking was discovered during a scheduled inspection. The equipment is a shell-and-tube heat exchanger, with the tube side handling the high-pressure hydrogen and coal tar mixture, and the shell side handling the cooling medium. The tube-side outlet nozzle is a forged low-alloy steel component, typically 2.25Cr-1Mo or similar, with a corrosion-resistant cladding layer, usually an austenitic stainless steel or a nickel-based alloy, applied by weld overlay.

The inspection results were as follows:

Inspection Method Findings
Liquid Penetrant Testing (PT) Extensive surface cracking in the cladding layer, oriented primarily in the circumferential direction.
Ultrasonic Testing (UT) Indications at the cladding/base metal interface, suggesting the cracks may extend into the bond line.
Hardness Testing Elevated hardness in the cladding layer, indicating possible work hardening or hydrogen embrittlement.
Ferrite Content Measurement Ferrite content in the austenitic cladding was lower than the specified range (typically 3-8 FN for resistance to hot cracking).

The combination of these findings, along with the service history, pointed towards a specific failure mechanism. The paper's conclusion was that the cracking was due to chloride stress corrosion cracking (Cl-SCC). This is a classic mechanism in austenitic stainless steels exposed to chlorides in an aqueous environment, particularly when the temperature is above 60°C and the stress level is significant. In a coal tar hydrogenation unit, the feed stock can contain chlorides, and the process conditions, including the presence of water and hydrogen sulfide, create an environment that is conducive to Cl-SCC.

2. Root Cause Analysis: Why Chloride Stress Corrosion Cracking Occurred

The root cause analysis is a good example of how to systematically approach a failure. The paper uses the inspection results and the operating records to build a case. Let me break down the contributing factors.

  1. Chloride source. The coal tar feed stock contained chlorides, which were not completely removed by the upstream desalting and hydrotreating processes. Even at low concentrations, chlorides can concentrate in specific areas, such as under deposits or in stagnant zones, by a process of evaporation and condensation.
  2. Stress level. The cladding layer is under residual stress from the welding process used to apply it. In addition, the operating pressure and thermal cycling impose a superimposed stress. The combination of residual and operating stress can exceed the threshold for Cl-SCC, which is typically in the range of 20-30% of the yield strength for austenitic stainless steel.
  3. Temperature. The operating temperature of the exchanger was in the range where Cl-SCC is most severe. The susceptibility of austenitic stainless steel to Cl-SCC peaks in the temperature range of 100-200°C, which is a common operating range for high-pressure exchangers in hydroprocessing units.
  4. Material condition. The low ferrite content in the cladding is a significant factor. Ferrite in austenitic stainless steel weld metal improves resistance to hot cracking during welding, but it also has a beneficial effect on resistance to Cl-SCC by acting as a crack arrestor and by providing a more anodic phase that promotes passivation. A ferrite content below 3 FN indicates that the cladding was either applied with a low-ferrite consumable or that the ferrite was transformed during service.

The paper's conclusion that the cracking was due to Cl-SCC is well-supported. However, I would add one more consideration: the possibility of hydrogen-induced cracking. The unit is a hydrogenation unit, and hydrogen can diffuse into the cladding layer and cause embrittlement, particularly in the heat-affected zone of the overlay. The elevated hardness readings could be a sign of hydrogen embrittlement. The two mechanisms can interact, with hydrogen embrittlement making the material more susceptible to Cl-SCC.

3. The Field Repair Failure and the Critical Lesson on Dehydrogenation

The most instructive part of this paper is the sequence of events after the initial inspection. The decision was made to perform a field repair, which involved grinding out the cracks and re-welding the affected areas. After the repair, the areas were re-inspected. The paper reports that new cracks were found in the vicinity of the repaired areas. This is a classic case of a repair that fails because the root cause was not addressed.

The paper's conclusion is that the new cracks were caused by the lack of an effective pre-weld dehydrogenation treatment. This is a critical insight. When welding on a hydrogen-charged component, the hydrogen in the base metal and the existing weld metal can migrate to the heat-affected zone of the repair weld, where it can cause hydrogen-induced cracking. The standard practice for welding on hydrogen-charged equipment is to perform a dehydrogenation heat treatment before welding, typically by holding the component at a temperature of 250-300°C for a sufficient time to allow the hydrogen to diffuse out.

In a field repair, the ability to perform a proper dehydrogenation treatment is limited. The component is in place, and the surrounding equipment may not allow for the required heating. The paper infers that the field repair did not include a dehydrogenation step, or that the step was not effective. The result was that the hydrogen remained in the material, and the welding process caused it to redistribute and concentrate, leading to new cracks.

Let me compare the field repair and the return-to-factory repair.

Aspect Field Repair Return-to-Factory Repair
Pre-weld dehydrogenation Not performed or ineffective. Performed as a controlled heat treatment, holding at 250-300°C for a specified time.
Welding conditions Limited access, difficult to maintain consistent preheat. Controlled environment, proper preheat and interpass temperature control.
Post-weld heat treatment Not feasible or not performed. Stress relief performed in a furnace.
Inspection after repair PT and UT performed, but new cracks found. Full PT, UT, and hardness testing performed, no defects found.
Outcome Repair failed, new cracks formed. Repair successful, unit returned to service.

The return-to-factory repair was successful because the full range of heat treatments could be applied. The component was dehydrogenated, welded with proper preheat, and then stress-relieved. This sequence is essential for welding on hydrogen-charged austenitic cladding.

4. Engineering Practice Lessons and Preventive Measures

This paper is a valuable case study for anyone involved in the inspection and repair of high-pressure equipment. The key lessons are clear.

  1. The root cause must be identified before any repair is attempted. In this case, the root cause was Cl-SCC, driven by chlorides in the process stream. A field repair that simply grinds out the cracks and re-welds without addressing the chloride environment will fail, because the new weld will be exposed to the same conditions that caused the original cracking.
  2. Dehydrogenation is not optional when welding on hydrogen-charged equipment. This is the most important lesson from this paper. The field repair failed because the hydrogen in the material was not removed before welding. Any repair on a hydrogenation unit must include a dehydrogenation step, even if it means the repair has to be done in a shop rather than in the field.
  3. The ferrite content of the cladding is a critical parameter. The low ferrite content in the cladding was a contributing factor to the Cl-SCC. During the return-to-factory repair, the cladding should be replaced with a material that has the correct ferrite content, typically in the range of 5-10 FN, to provide both hot cracking resistance and better resistance to Cl-SCC.
  4. The process stream must be controlled. The ultimate fix for Cl-SCC is to remove the chlorides from the process stream. This may require improved desalting, the use of chloride scavengers, or a change in the process chemistry. Without this, the problem will recur.

From a practical standpoint, I would recommend that any high-pressure exchanger in this service be inspected more frequently, with PT and UT on all nozzles and welds. The inspection interval should be based on the known susceptibility of the material to Cl-SCC and the chloride content of the process stream. If the chloride content is high, the inspection interval should be shortened.

In conclusion, this paper is a textbook example of how a seemingly straightforward repair can fail if the root cause is not understood and the proper pre-weld treatments are not applied. The failure of the field repair due to the lack of dehydrogenation is a lesson that every welding engineer and maintenance manager should take to heart. The successful return-to-factory repair demonstrates that with the right process sequence, including dehydrogenation, proper welding, and stress relief, the equipment can be returned to service with confidence.