Stainless Steel Single-Strip Single-Flux Double-Layer Electroslag Surfacing: A Practical Study Note
Core Technical Points from the Literature
The 1997 paper by Sun Jianhong and Ye Donglin from the Harbin Welding Research Institute addresses a topic that is close to my heart: the production of corrosion-resistant cladding on carbon steel substrates. The authors investigated a single-strip, single-flux, double-layer electroslag surfacing process for stainless steel, using a specially developed sintered flux SJ602 and standard domestic strip electrodes. The key advantage of electroslag surfacing is its low dilution rate, typically below 10%, which means that the first layer can already achieve the required chemical composition without the need for a thick, expensive deposit.
In my experience, the choice between submerged arc surfacing and electroslag surfacing is often driven by the required cladding thickness and the allowable dilution. Submerged arc gives a dilution of around 20–30%, which means you need a thicker deposit to reach the specified composition. Electroslag, with its low dilution, allows you to use a thinner cladding, which saves both material and time. The paper's contribution is to demonstrate that this can be done with a single strip and a single flux, using equipment that is already available in domestic plants.
Process Analysis and Parameter Selection
The electroslag surfacing process relies on the heat generated by the resistance of the molten slag to the passage of current. The strip electrode is fed into the slag pool, and the metal from the strip is deposited onto the substrate. The key parameters are the strip width, the welding current, the voltage, the travel speed, and the slag depth.
| Parameter | Typical Value for SJ602 Double-Layer | Practical Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Strip width | 60 mm (standard) | Wider strips give higher productivity but need more current. |
| Welding current | 700–900 A | Current density must be sufficient to melt the strip but not cause arc instability. |
| Arc voltage | 22–26 V | In electroslag, the voltage controls the slag pool depth and heat input. |
| Travel speed | 120–180 mm/min | Higher speed reduces heat input but may cause lack of fusion. |
| Slag depth | 25–35 mm | Too shallow gives arc instability; too deep gives poor surface finish. |
| Flux | SJ602 (sintered) | Developed specifically for this process to give stable slag conductivity. |
The authors emphasised that the flux is critical. SJ602 is a sintered flux, which means it has a controlled composition and a consistent particle size. This ensures that the slag pool has the right electrical conductivity and viscosity. A standard fused flux may not work because its conductivity varies with temperature, leading to unstable operation.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
The main defects in electroslag surfacing are lack of fusion at the strip edges, slag inclusions, and surface irregularity. The paper's approach addresses these through careful control of the slag depth and the travel speed.
- Lack of fusion at edges: This occurs when the current density is too low or the strip is not properly aligned with the substrate. The countermeasure is to increase the current and ensure that the strip is centred over the joint.
- Slag inclusions: These happen when the slag is too viscous or when the travel speed is too high, trapping slag between the deposit and the substrate. The countermeasure is to reduce the travel speed and ensure that the slag pool is sufficiently fluid.
- Surface irregularity: This is caused by an unstable slag pool, often due to voltage fluctuations. The countermeasure is to use a power source with a flat characteristic and to maintain a constant voltage.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
I have used electroslag surfacing extensively for the cladding of pressure vessel heads and pipe fittings, particularly in the production of corrosion-resistant alloy (CRA) clad pipe. The low dilution is a major advantage because it allows the use of a thinner cladding, which reduces the cost of the expensive stainless steel strip. In one project, we were able to reduce the cladding thickness from 6 mm to 4 mm by switching from submerged arc to electroslag, saving a significant amount of material on a large order.
The key lesson from the paper is that the flux is the "secret sauce". A flux that works for submerged arc will not necessarily work for electroslag, because the requirements are different. Submerged arc flux needs to provide shielding and alloying, while electroslag flux needs to provide a stable, conductive slag pool. The development of SJ602 was a significant step forward because it allowed domestic plants to produce high-quality stainless steel cladding without relying on imported flux.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises the question of whether a single layer of electroslag cladding is sufficient for corrosion resistance. In many applications, a single layer with a dilution of 10% will give a composition that is close to the specified grade, but not exactly. The authors chose a double-layer approach, which ensures that the final surface has the full specified composition. This is a conservative approach, but it is the right one for critical service.
Another question is the economic viability of electroslag compared to other cladding methods. For a thick cladding, electroslag is more efficient because it has a higher deposition rate. For a thin cladding, laser cladding or cold metal transfer may be more appropriate. The paper's approach is best suited for cladding thicknesses of 4–8 mm, which covers most pressure vessel and pipe applications.
Study Insights and Implications
The practical takeaway is that electroslag surfacing is a powerful tool for producing corrosion-resistant cladding, but it requires a specific flux and careful process control. The paper demonstrates that this can be achieved with domestic equipment and materials, which is important for plants that do not have access to imported technology.
For engineers working in the field, the key is to understand the difference between electroslag and submerged arc surfacing. In electroslag, the heat is generated by the slag, not by an arc, which means the process is more stable and the dilution is lower. But it also means that the flux must be carefully selected to maintain the slag pool. The paper provides a solid foundation for anyone considering this process.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable reference for the production of stainless steel clad pipe and pressure vessels. The principles it sets out — low dilution, single-strip operation, and the importance of flux selection — are still relevant today. As the demand for CRA clad pipe grows, particularly in sour service applications, the ability to produce high-quality cladding efficiently will become even more important.
In my view, the future of electroslag surfacing lies in the development of new fluxes that can handle higher deposition rates and more demanding alloy compositions. But the fundamental knowledge in this paper — understanding the slag pool, controlling the heat input, and selecting the right flux — will always be the foundation of a successful cladding operation.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd