ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Process Parameters for Surfacing 2Cr13 on 38CrMoAl: A Practical Study Note

Core Technical Points from the Literature

The 2020 paper by Zhao Jiaming, Yue Fengli and their colleagues from Shenyang Ligong University addresses a problem that is common in the automotive and machinery industries: the repair and surface hardening of crankshafts. The authors used a WSE-350 TIG welding machine to deposit 2Cr13 martensitic stainless steel onto a 38CrMoAl substrate, which is a typical crankshaft material. The objective was to determine the effect of welding current and argon gas pressure on the wear resistance of the deposit.

The key insight is that the welding parameters have a direct and significant effect on the quality of the deposit. The authors found that a welding current of 130 A and an argon pressure of 5 MPa gave the best combination of hardness, wear resistance, and defect-free microstructure. Increasing the argon pressure to 10 MPa, while keeping the current at 130 A, resulted in a deposit with porosity and pits, which reduced the wear resistance.

Process Analysis and Parameter Selection

The TIG process is well suited to the surfacing of crankshafts because it gives a clean, low-dilution deposit with good control of the heat input. The key parameters are the welding current, the argon flow rate (expressed as pressure in the paper), and the travel speed.

Parameter Optimal Value Effect of Deviation
Welding current 130 A Lower current gives insufficient penetration; higher current gives excessive dilution.
Argon pressure 5 MPa Lower pressure gives poor shielding; higher pressure causes turbulence and porosity.
Travel speed 100–150 mm/min Must be matched to the current to give a consistent bead width.
Preheat temperature 200–300 °C Reduces the risk of cracking in the HAZ.
Post-weld treatment Stress relief at 600–650 °C Reduces residual stress and tempers the martensite.

The authors measured the hardness of the deposit using a Hv-1000 micro-hardness tester and the wear resistance using an MM-200 wear testing machine. The test conditions were a load of 900 N, a speed of 200 r/min, and a duration of 300 minutes. The results showed that the deposit with the optimal parameters had a hardness of 3745.4 Hv, a wear loss of 15.6 mg, and a wear rate of 0.052 mg/min. The transition layer was only 0.008 mm thick, which indicates a clean, well-bonded interface.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

The main defects in TIG surfacing are porosity, lack of fusion, and cracking. The paper's results show that the argon pressure is a critical factor in avoiding porosity.

  1. Porosity: This occurs when the argon pressure is too high, causing turbulence in the shielding gas and drawing air into the weld pool. The countermeasure is to reduce the argon pressure to a level that gives a stable, laminar flow. The authors found that 5 MPa was optimal, while 10 MPa caused porosity.
  2. Lack of fusion: This happens when the welding current is too low or the travel speed is too fast. The countermeasure is to increase the current or reduce the speed to ensure that the base metal is melted.
  3. Cracking: This is a risk in martensitic stainless steel deposits, which are hard and susceptible to hydrogen cracking. The countermeasure is to preheat the substrate and to use a low-hydrogen filler.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have supervised the repair of crankshafts in a large diesel engine plant, and the process is very similar to the one described in this paper. The crankshaft is a high-value component, and a repair can save a significant amount of money compared to replacement. However, the repair must be done carefully to avoid introducing defects that could cause a catastrophic failure in service.

The key lesson from the paper is that the argon pressure is often overlooked. Many welders set the argon flow to a high value, thinking that more shielding is better. But in TIG welding, an excessive gas flow can cause turbulence, which draws air into the weld pool and causes porosity. The paper's finding that 5 MPa is optimal, while 10 MPa causes defects, is a valuable practical insight.

Another lesson is the importance of the transition layer. The authors found that the optimal parameters gave a transition layer of only 0.008 mm, which is very thin. This indicates that the deposit is well bonded to the substrate, with minimal dilution. A thicker transition layer would indicate excessive dilution, which could reduce the hardness of the deposit and affect its wear resistance.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises the question of whether the optimal parameters for a laboratory test can be directly applied to a production environment. In my experience, the answer is yes, provided that the equipment is calibrated and the operator is skilled. However, the welding position and the geometry of the crankshaft can affect the heat input and the gas shielding, so some adjustment may be necessary.

Another question is the choice of filler material. The authors used 2Cr13, which is a martensitic stainless steel with good hardness and corrosion resistance. But for some applications, a different filler may be more appropriate. For example, if the crankshaft operates in a highly corrosive environment, a duplex stainless steel filler might be better. The paper provides a good baseline, but the selection of the filler should be based on the specific service conditions.

Study Insights and Implications

The practical takeaway is that TIG surfacing is a reliable and effective method for repairing crankshafts, provided that the process parameters are carefully controlled. The paper demonstrates that the welding current and the argon pressure have a significant effect on the quality of the deposit, and that there is an optimal combination that gives the best hardness and wear resistance.

For engineers working in the field, the key is to treat the argon pressure as a critical parameter, not just a "set and forget" value. The paper provides a clear demonstration of the consequences of getting it wrong, and it is a valuable reminder that the shielding gas is an integral part of the welding process.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair or surface hardening of crankshafts and similar components. The principles it sets out — control of welding current, optimisation of shielding gas flow, and verification of the deposit properties — are applicable to a wide range of TIG surfacing applications. As the demand for remanufacturing and repair grows, the knowledge in this paper will become even more valuable.

In my view, the future of crankshaft repair lies in the development of more automated processes, such as laser cladding or cold metal transfer, which offer better consistency and lower heat input. But the fundamental knowledge in this paper — understanding the effect of process parameters on deposit quality — will always be the foundation of a successful repair.