ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

TiC-VC Abrasion-Resistant Hardfacing Electrodes: Microstructure and Properties

1. Literature Overview and Electrode Design Philosophy

This paper by Yang Shanglei and colleagues at Shanghai Jiao Tong University and Shandong University presents a classic example of consumable design driven by metallurgical principles. The goal is to produce a hardfacing electrode that deposits a metal with both high hardness and good crack resistance, which are usually in opposition. The approach is to use a H08A mild steel core wire with a coating containing graphite, ferrotitanium, ferrovanadium, and synthetic rutile. During the arc welding process, the coating components react in the arc to form TiC and VC carbides, which are then dispersed in the deposited metal.

The electrode design is elegant because it uses the arc itself as a metallurgical reactor. The graphite provides carbon, the ferrotitanium and ferrovanadium provide the carbide-forming elements, and the synthetic rutile provides titanium dioxide, which stabilises the arc and contributes to the slag system. The result is a deposit that contains TiC and VC carbides dispersed in a low-carbon martensite matrix.

2. Microstructure and Phase Analysis

The authors report that the carbides are irregularly shaped blocks, angular particles, or strips, and they are distributed both within the grains and along the grain boundaries. The majority are located at the grain boundaries, which is a result of the solidification sequence: the carbides form during the later stages of solidification and are pushed to the interdendritic regions. The carbides are identified as dense aggregates of TiC and VC, and the matrix is typical low-carbon martensite.

The phase composition of the deposit is α-Fe + γ-Fe + VC + TiC + Fe3C. The presence of retained austenite (γ-Fe) is interesting and is likely a result of the carbon and alloying element content, which lowers the martensite start temperature. The retained austenite can be beneficial for toughness, but it also reduces the hardness. The authors note that the combination of low-carbon martensite and dispersed carbides is the microstructural basis for good crack resistance and high wear resistance.

This is a critical point. Low-carbon martensite is tough because it has a high dislocation density and a fine lath structure, but it is not as hard as high-carbon martensite. The hardness in this deposit comes primarily from the carbides, not from the matrix. This means that the deposit can achieve high hardness without the brittleness that comes with high-carbon martensite.

3. Effect of Coating Composition on Properties

The authors report that increasing the amount of ferrotitanium, ferrovanadium, and graphite in the coating increases the hardness of the deposit, but also degrades the processability and crack resistance. This is a classic trade-off. More carbide-forming elements and more carbon mean more carbides, which means higher hardness and better wear resistance, but it also means a higher tendency for the deposit to crack during cooling.

The hardness can reach HRC 60 or above, and the relative wear resistance is higher than that of D667, which is a standard chromium carbide hardfacing electrode. This is a significant result because D667 is a well-established product, and any new electrode that outperforms it in wear resistance while maintaining acceptable crack resistance is worth evaluating.

The degradation of processability with increasing coating additions is a practical concern. A coating that is too rich in graphite or ferroalloys can produce a rough, irregular bead, excessive spatter, or slag that is difficult to remove. The arc stability can also be affected. The authors do not quantify these effects, but they note that the processability and crack resistance deteriorate, which is enough to guide the electrode design.

4. Practical Implications for Wear-Resistant Hardfacing

For applications such as pipe mill rolls, crusher hammers, or excavator teeth, where abrasive wear is the dominant failure mode, this electrode offers a viable alternative to the conventional chromium carbide electrodes. The key advantage is the combination of high hardness and good crack resistance, which means the deposit can be applied in thicker layers without cracking, and it can tolerate more impact loading.

The use of TiC and VC rather than chromium carbide is also significant. Chromium carbides are hard but can be brittle, and they tend to form large, blocky particles that can act as crack initiation sites. TiC and VC are harder and can be distributed more finely, which provides better wear resistance and a more uniform microstructure.

The electrode design is also cost-effective. The coating uses relatively inexpensive raw materials, and the H08A core wire is a standard product. This is important for a consumable that is used in large quantities in a hardfacing shop.

5. Critical Assessment and Future Directions

The paper is a solid piece of consumable development, but it would benefit from more detailed wear testing under different abrasive conditions. The authors report relative wear resistance against D667, but they do not specify the abrasive material or the test conditions. In practice, the wear resistance of a hardfacing deposit depends on the type of abrasive, the impact angle, and the velocity. A deposit that is excellent against a hard, angular abrasive may perform poorly against a soft, round abrasive.

The retained austenite in the deposit is also a point of concern. Retained austenite can transform to martensite under stress, which can cause dimensional changes and, in some cases, cracking. The authors do not discuss the stability of the retained austenite or its effect on the service performance. This is a question that a practical engineer would want answered before specifying this electrode for a critical application.

6. Concluding Remarks

The TiC-VC hardfacing electrode, with a H08A core wire and a coating containing graphite, ferrotitanium, ferrovanadium, and synthetic rutile, produces a deposit with low-carbon martensite and dispersed TiC and VC carbides. The deposit can achieve HRC 60 or above with good crack resistance, and it outperforms D667 in relative wear resistance. The key design principle is to use the arc as a metallurgical reactor to form hard carbides in situ, while maintaining a tough, low-carbon martensite matrix. The trade-off between hardness and crack resistance is controlled by the coating composition, and the optimum must be determined by balancing the wear resistance against the risk of cracking. For any application where abrasive wear is the primary failure mode and the component must also tolerate some impact, this electrode design is worth serious evaluation.