Effect of Hardfacing Time Interval on the Microstructure of Built-Up Parts
1. Literature Overview and Process Context
This paper by Xu Yan and colleagues at Xinjiang University addresses a parameter that is often ignored in the welding of multi-pass deposits: the time interval between passes. In any multi-pass welding or hardfacing operation, the interpass time controls the interpass temperature, which in turn controls the cooling rate of the deposited metal and the heat-affected zone. The authors used gas metal arc welding with ER50-6 wire on Q235B substrate, and they varied the time interval between passes from 30 seconds to 2 minutes.
The research question is straightforward: how does the time interval affect the microstructure of the final deposit? The answer, as the authors report, is that the time interval has a significant effect on the cooling rate, and therefore on the grain size and uniformity of the weld metal.
2. Thermal Cycle and Microstructural Evolution
The authors found that when the time interval is short, the weld metal does not have enough time to cool between passes. The result is that the interpass temperature is high, and the subsequent pass is deposited onto a hot surface. This means the cooling rate of the new weld metal is slow, and the grains have more time to grow. The result is a coarse, non-uniform grain structure.
When the time interval is longer, the weld metal cools to a lower temperature before the next pass is deposited. The interpass temperature is lower, the cooling rate of the new weld metal is faster, and the grain size is finer and more uniform.
The authors identified 2 minutes as the optimal interval in their test setup. At this interval, the weld metal is allowed to cool sufficiently, and the resulting microstructure is relatively uniform with fine grains. At intervals of 1 minute and 30 seconds, the weld metal does not cool enough, and the grains are coarse and non-uniform.
This is a classic example of the relationship between thermal input and microstructural outcome. In multi-pass welding, the heat from subsequent passes can anneal or temper the previously deposited metal, and it can also affect the cooling rate of the new metal. The interpass temperature is the key parameter, and it is controlled by the time interval, the heat input, and the part geometry.
3. Practical Implications for Multi-Pass Hardfacing and Additive Manufacturing
The practical implications of this paper extend far beyond the specific test setup. In any multi-pass hardfacing operation, whether it is a manual electrode, a semi-automatic wire process, or a fully automated robotic system, the interpass temperature must be controlled to achieve a consistent microstructure and properties.
In hardfacing of large components, such as pipe mill rolls or cement rollers, the interpass temperature is often specified in the welding procedure. A common rule is to keep the interpass temperature below a certain maximum, typically 150 to 250°C for low-alloy steels, to prevent excessive grain growth and to maintain the mechanical properties of the base metal. The time interval is the practical control variable: if the welder waits too long, the part cools below the minimum interpass temperature, which can cause cracking; if the welder does not wait long enough, the part overheats, and the grain size becomes coarse.
The paper also has relevance to additive manufacturing, where the layer-by-layer deposition is analogous to multi-pass welding. In wire arc additive manufacturing, the interpass time is a critical process parameter that affects the thermal history and the resulting microstructure. A short interpass time can lead to a coarse, columnar grain structure, while a longer interpass time can promote a finer, more equiaxed structure.
4. Critical Assessment and Process Control Considerations
The paper is a useful contribution, but it is limited by the specific test conditions. The authors used a single wire type, a single substrate, and a single heat input. The optimal time interval of 2 minutes is specific to these conditions. In practice, the optimal interval depends on the part size, the heat input, the ambient temperature, and the thermal conductivity of the material.
A more robust approach would be to control the interpass temperature directly, rather than the time interval. This is what is done in production welding: the welder or the automated system measures the interpass temperature with a contact pyrometer or an infrared thermometer, and the next pass is not started until the temperature falls within the specified range. The time interval is then a consequence of the cooling rate, not a controlled variable.
The paper's finding that a short time interval leads to a slow cooling rate is counterintuitive to some, but it is correct. When the part is hot, the temperature gradient between the weld metal and the surrounding material is small, so the heat dissipation is slow. When the part is cold, the temperature gradient is large, and the heat dissipation is fast. This is why a short interpass time can lead to a slower cooling rate for the subsequent pass, even though the total heat input is the same.
5. Concluding Remarks
The time interval between hardfacing passes has a significant effect on the cooling rate and the resulting microstructure. A short interval leads to a high interpass temperature, a slow cooling rate, and a coarse, non-uniform grain structure. A longer interval, in this study 2 minutes, allows the weld metal to cool sufficiently, resulting in a fine, uniform grain structure. The practical lesson is that interpass temperature control is essential for consistent quality in multi-pass hardfacing and welding. The time interval is a useful proxy, but the direct measurement and control of interpass temperature is the more reliable approach. In production, the welding procedure should specify a maximum interpass temperature, and the operator should be trained to measure it and to wait if necessary. The cost of not doing so is a deposit with inconsistent properties, which can lead to premature failure in service.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd