Intermetallic Compound Composite Surfacing: WC-NiAl-NiB-Ni System on Stainless Steel
Study Overview and Processing Route
The study by Suo Jinping et al. (2003) presents a novel approach to producing wear-resistant intermetallic compound composites using a surfacing process. The authors prepared a composite electrode by ball milling and sintering a mixture of WC, NiAl, NiB, and Ni powders. During ball milling, the WC particles were crushed, and the NiAl, NiB, and Ni reacted to form the intermetallic compound Ni3Al. The resulting composite electrode was then used for tungsten inert gas (TIG) surfacing on 1Cr25Ni20Si2 stainless steel, producing a 5 mm thick wear-resistant intermetallic composite layer.
This is a sophisticated study that combines powder metallurgy, reaction synthesis, and welding metallurgy. The approach is innovative because it uses the welding process itself to drive the reactions that form the composite, rather than relying on pre-formed composite materials.
Microstructural Evolution During Surfacing
| Stage | Process | Microstructural Change |
|---|---|---|
| Ball milling | Mechanical alloying | WC particles crushed; NiAl + NiB + Ni react to form Ni3Al |
| Sintering | Heat treatment | Consolidation of composite electrode |
| Surfacing | TIG welding | Partial dissolution of WC; precipitation of W2C; Ni3Al transforms to Ni3(AlTi)C |
The microstructural evolution during surfacing is the most interesting aspect of this study. During welding, the high temperatures cause partial dissolution of the WC particles. This leads to the precipitation of new W2C carbides, which are finer and more uniformly distributed than the original WC. Simultaneously, the Ni3Al intermetallic transforms to a new phase, Ni3(AlTi)C, which is a carbon-containing variant of the Ni3Al structure.
The formation of W2C is significant because it is a very hard phase, with a hardness of approximately 2000-3000 HV. The presence of fine W2C precipitates in the composite provides excellent wear resistance. The transformation of Ni3Al to Ni3(AlTi)C is also important because it may improve the toughness of the matrix, making the composite more resistant to cracking and spalling.
The wear resistance of the composite was reported to be more than 3 times that of 45 steel. This is a substantial improvement and demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach.
Wear Performance and Application Potential
The wear resistance of the composite is attributed to the combination of hard carbides (W2C) and an intermetallic matrix (Ni3Al or Ni3(AlTi)C). The intermetallic matrix provides toughness and high-temperature stability, while the carbides provide hardness and wear resistance. This is a classic composite structure, but the use of intermetallic compounds as the matrix is relatively novel.
The application potential for this composite is significant. It could be used for components that operate in high-temperature, abrasive environments, such as hot rolling mill guides, extrusion dies, and high-temperature valves. The ability to deposit the composite using TIG welding makes it practical for repair and maintenance applications, as well as for new component fabrication.
One practical consideration is the cost of the raw materials. WC, NiAl, NiB, and Ni powders are relatively expensive, and the ball milling and sintering processes add to the cost. However, for high-value components where wear resistance is critical, the cost may be justified by the extended service life.
Another consideration is the weldability of the composite electrode. The study reports that the electrode was used for TIG surfacing, which is a relatively low-energy process. The authors do not report on issues such as cracking or porosity, but these are potential concerns with intermetallic-based deposits. The Ni3Al matrix is known to be somewhat brittle, and the presence of hard carbides may exacerbate this.
Practical Considerations and Outlook
- The composite electrode approach is innovative and effective, but it is more complex than conventional hardfacing. The ball milling and sintering steps add cost and require specialized equipment.
- The microstructural evolution during welding is critical. The dissolution of WC and precipitation of W2C must be controlled to achieve the desired properties.
- The wear resistance of the composite is excellent, but the toughness may be a concern. Further research is needed to optimize the matrix composition and improve impact resistance.
- The application potential is significant for high-temperature, abrasive environments, but the cost must be justified by the performance.
- TIG surfacing is a suitable process for this composite, but other processes such as laser cladding or plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing may offer advantages in terms of deposition rate and control.
In summary, this is a well-executed study that demonstrates a novel approach to producing wear-resistant composites. The combination of powder metallurgy and welding is clever, and the resulting composite has excellent wear resistance. The main challenges are cost and toughness, but these may be addressed with further development. This is a good example of how research can lead to practical solutions for challenging wear problems.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd