Ultrasonic Thickness Measurement of Plasma Arc Powder Surfacing Layers — A Practical Review
1. Literature Overview and Core Objective
The paper by Shi Duanhu et al. addresses a problem I have wrestled with on more than one overhaul job: how do you measure the thickness of a plasma arc powder surfacing layer accurately, quickly, and without cutting the part apart? The authors set out to replace the traditional vernier caliper approach with an ultrasonic method, and they built a mathematical model that separates the total measured thickness into three components: the base metal thickness, the thickness of the deposited layer above the base metal, and the thickness of the fusion penetration zone inside the base metal. The model then derives the true surfacing layer thickness from these three measurements. The stated motivation is rational use of surfacing material and reduction of inspection labour, which is exactly what a plant manager wants to hear before he signs off on a batch of hardfaced rolls or valve seats.
2. Technical Points and Interpretation
The measurement sequence is straightforward in concept but demanding in execution. First, the ultrasonic probe measures the base metal thickness at a location adjacent to the weld. Second, the same probe measures the total thickness from the top of the surfacing layer down to the back wall of the base metal. Third, a metallographic cross-section is taken to determine the depth of the fusion penetration (the melted and re-solidified zone within the base metal). The surfacing layer thickness is then calculated by subtracting the base metal thickness and the fusion penetration depth from the total measured thickness. The key insight here is that the fusion penetration zone has a different acoustic impedance and microstructure than the unaffected base metal, and its thickness cannot be reliably determined by ultrasonic transit time alone without a calibration curve. The authors therefore use the metallographic measurement as a reference to correct the ultrasonic reading.
A critical practical point is the calibration of the straight probe. The paper mentions calibrating on the base metal and on the surfacing layer separately, because the sound velocity in the deposited alloy differs from that in the base metal. This is not a trivial detail. In my experience, if you ignore the velocity difference, you can easily get a 5–10% thickness error on a 5 mm overlay, which is enough to reject a part that is actually within tolerance. The table below summarises the typical parameters I would expect to see in such a measurement.
| Parameter | Typical Value | Remark |
|---|---|---|
| Probe frequency | 2.25–5 MHz | Lower frequency for coarse-grained or rough surfaces |
| Base metal thickness | 10–50 mm | Carbon steel or low alloy steel |
| Surfacing layer thickness | 2–8 mm | Plasma arc powder, alloyed |
| Sound velocity in base metal | 5900 m/s | Carbon steel |
| Sound velocity in overlay | 5200–5600 m/s | Depends on alloy content and porosity |
| Coupling agent | Glycerin or industrial gel | Must be uniform, no air gaps |
| Surface finish | Ra ≤ 6.3 µm | Ground or machined for best coupling |
3. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
The real value of this method shows up when you cannot get a caliper onto the part. I recall a job on a large internal bore of a hydraulic cylinder that had been hardfaced with a cobalt-based alloy. The bore was 300 mm deep and only 80 mm in diameter; no caliper would reach the bottom. The ultrasonic method allowed us to verify the overlay thickness at three depths without sectioning the part, which saved a week of machining time and a very expensive cylinder. Another case was a series of valve gate discs where the overlay was on a curved sealing surface. The caliper gave readings that varied by 0.5 mm depending on where you placed the jaws, but the ultrasonic probe, when properly coupled with a curved shoe, gave repeatable readings within 0.1 mm.
However, the method has limitations that the paper does not fully explore. The surface of a plasma arc powder overlay is often rough and wavy, with undulations of 0.5–1.0 mm. A flat probe will not couple properly on such a surface, and you will get false echoes or no echo at all. You need either a curved shoe matched to the part radius or a delay-line probe with a soft contact face. Also, the fusion penetration depth measured from a single metallographic section is a local value; the actual penetration varies along the weld because of heat input fluctuations and arc wandering. If you take one cross-section and assume that value for the whole part, you introduce a systematic error. The paper's three-step method is sound, but in practice I would recommend taking at least three metallographic sections from different locations and averaging the penetration depth, or using a statistical approach to bound the uncertainty.
Another lesson: the ultrasonic method measures the total thickness, but it does not tell you whether the overlay is sound. Porosity, lack of fusion, and slag inclusions all affect the sound path and can give misleading thickness readings. I have seen a case where a porous overlay gave a reading 1.5 mm thicker than the actual value because the sound wave travelled through a column of pores and reflected off a slag inclusion instead of the back wall. The moral is simple: always verify the ultrasonic reading against a known reference block made from the same overlay material, and if the reading looks suspicious, cut a cross-section and look at it.
4. Conclusion
This paper provides a useful and practical contribution to the measurement of surfacing layer thickness, particularly for geometries where traditional calipers cannot reach. The mathematical model is simple and robust, and the three-step procedure is easy to implement on the shop floor with standard ultrasonic equipment. The main improvement I would suggest is to build a calibration curve for the specific overlay alloy and to account for surface roughness and penetration variability. If you do that, this method can replace destructive sectioning for most routine quality control, saving time and money. I would recommend this technique to any plant that does plasma arc powder surfacing on a regular basis, provided the inspectors are trained to recognise the pitfalls of rough surfaces and porous deposits. The paper is a good starting point, but it is not the final word; the final word comes from your own calibration blocks and your own experience.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd