ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Application of Diamond and Cemented Carbide Composite Surfacing for Strengthening Steel Tooth Drill Bit Surfaces

Problem Statement and Material Selection

The paper by Liu Qingyou and Wang Longlong, published in China Mining in 2007, addresses a specific and persistent problem in the oil and gas drilling industry: the premature wear of steel tooth drill bits. The steel tooth bits, made from a low alloy steel such as 20Ni4Mo, are used in soft to medium formations where the rock is not hard enough to require tungsten carbide insert bits, but abrasive enough to cause significant wear on the steel teeth. The authors identified that the conventional approach of using domestic cemented carbide for surface strengthening was inadequate because of poor impact resistance and insufficient wear resistance. Their solution was to develop a composite surfacing layer that combines spherical cemented carbide particles with diamond, using an oxy-acetylene surfacing process. The diamond provides exceptional hardness and wear resistance, while the cemented carbide provides toughness and impact resistance. The substrate material was 20Ni4Mo, which is a case-hardening steel with good toughness and moderate hardenability, and the surfacing was evaluated using an impact-abrasive wear test that simulated the conditions encountered by a drill bit in the field.

Oxy-Acetylene Composite Surfacing Process

The oxy-acetylene surfacing process is a well-established technique that is particularly suitable for this application because it allows precise control of the heat input and the ability to deposit a relatively thick layer with minimal dilution. The process involves preheating the substrate, then using an oxy-acetylene flame to melt a thin layer of the substrate surface while simultaneously feeding the composite material, which consists of spherical cemented carbide particles and diamond, into the molten pool. The key challenge is to avoid overheating the diamond, because diamond begins to graphitise at temperatures above approximately 700 to 800 degrees Celsius in the presence of oxygen. The oxy-acetylene flame, with its reducing zone, provides a protective atmosphere that helps to prevent oxidation of the diamond, but the heat input must still be carefully controlled. The authors used a spherical carbide with a diameter in the range of 1 to 3 millimetres, and the diamond particles were of a similar size. The composite material was mixed with a binder and applied to the tooth surface, then the flame was used to fuse the composite to the substrate.

Parameter Typical Value Practical Significance
Substrate material 20Ni4Mo Good toughness, moderate hardenability, suitable for case hardening
Surfacing process Oxy-acetylene Precise heat control, low dilution, protective reducing flame
Carbide type Spherical cemented carbide Good impact resistance, uniform distribution
Diamond type Synthetic or natural diamond Exceptional hardness, high wear resistance
Carbide size 1 to 3 mm Large enough to resist pull-out, small enough for uniform distribution
Diamond size Similar to carbide Provides localised high hardness zones
Preheating temperature 200 to 300 degrees Celsius Reduces thermal shock and prevents cracking

Impact-Abrasive Wear Testing

The authors conducted an impact-abrasive wear test that simulated the working environment of a steel tooth drill bit. This is a critical aspect of the study, because laboratory wear tests that do not include impact loading often give misleading results. In real drilling, the bit teeth experience both abrasive wear from the rock and impact loading from the cyclic loading of the drill string. The composite surfacing layer was subjected to this combined loading, and the results showed that the wear resistance was significantly improved compared to the uncoated substrate and to the conventional cemented carbide surfacing. The improvement is attributed to the combination of hard diamond particles, which resist abrasive wear, and the tough carbide particles, which absorb impact energy and prevent crack propagation. The diamond particles are held in the matrix by the carbide, which provides a strong mechanical bond. The authors also noted that the composite layer exhibited good adhesion to the substrate, with no evidence of spalling or delamination.

Field Performance and Lessons

The practical significance of this work is substantial for the drilling industry. Steel tooth drill bits are used in millions of feet of hole every year, and the cost of a premature bit failure is not just the cost of the bit, but the cost of the trip out of the hole, the lost drilling time, and the potential for stuck pipe or other complications. The authors have demonstrated a viable approach to extending the life of steel tooth bits by using a composite surfacing layer that combines the best properties of diamond and cemented carbide. From my perspective, the key lesson is that the choice of surfacing material must be based on the specific service conditions. In this case, the combination of impact and abrasion required a composite approach rather than a single material. The diamond provides the hardness, but it is brittle and would crack under impact if used alone. The cemented carbide provides the toughness, but it is not hard enough to resist the most abrasive formations. By combining them, the authors have achieved a synergistic effect that neither material can provide on its own. The one caution I would add is that the oxy-acetylene process, while effective, is labor-intensive and requires skilled operators. For mass production, an automated process such as plasma transferred arc surfacing or laser cladding might be more suitable, but these processes generate higher heat inputs and may require additional protection for the diamond. The authors have laid the groundwork for a new approach, and the next step is to scale up the process and conduct field trials in actual drilling operations. This is the kind of research that has the potential to make a real difference in the field, and I would encourage any drilling contractor to follow this work closely.