ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Full Overlay Welded Flue Duct for Converter Equipment under ASME Code

The Problem That Brought Us Here

Every steelmaker who has run a converter knows the pain of the flue duct. It sits right on top of the vessel, taking the full blast of off-gas at 1,400 to 1,600 °C, carrying dust that chews through steel like a grinding wheel, and cycling through thermal fatigue every single heat. The old design—plain carbon steel with a refractory lining—gave us maybe six months before the water jacket started weeping. Then we were down for a week, draining the system, cutting out the failed section, and welding in a patch that never quite matched the original. That is lost production, lost oxygen, lost heats, and a repair crew working in a hot, dusty, cramped space that nobody wants to be in. The paper by Zhao Yingchun and his colleagues at Yantai Guoye Metallurgical Water Cooling Equipment Co., Ltd. addresses exactly this. They took the flue duct and made it a fully overlaid welded structure, designed and built to ASME code, and the result is a duct that survives where the old one died.

What the ASME Overlay Design Actually Changes

The core insight is that you cannot fight the off-gas with a single material. You need a composite. The base shell provides pressure containment and structural rigidity; the overlay provides the resistance to erosion and thermal fatigue. The paper describes a full overlay—meaning the entire wetted surface, not just the hot spots, is clad with a corrosion- and wear-resistant alloy. This is the same logic we use on CRA line pipe for sour service: the carbon steel gives you the strength and the economy, the alloy gives you the fight against the environment. In the flue duct, the overlay is typically a nickel-based alloy or a high-chromium stainless, applied by weld overlay. The ASME code governs the design of the pressure-retaining shell, the weld joint details, and the inspection requirements. The overlay itself is not a pressure boundary in the code sense, but it is the reason the pressure boundary survives.

The key design parameters that matter on the shop floor are:

Parameter Typical Value Why It Matters
Base shell thickness 12–20 mm Pressure containment and stiffness under thermal cycling
Overlay thickness 3–6 mm Enough to resist erosion without adding excessive weight or thermal stress
Overlay alloy Ni-based or 22Cr duplex High-temperature oxidation resistance, erosion resistance, thermal fatigue resistance
Weld overlay process SAW or GTAW with strip cladding High deposition rate, low dilution, consistent chemistry
Post-weld heat treatment As required by ASME for the base material Relieves residual stress, prevents stress corrosion cracking in service

Manufacturing and QC: Where the Real Lessons Live

This is where I want to talk about what the paper implies but does not say outright, because I have seen what happens when the overlay is done wrong. The first rule of overlay welding is dilution control. If you burn too much of the base metal into the overlay, you get a diluted layer that looks like the right alloy on the chemistry sheet but behaves like a low-alloy steel in service. The solution is to run the first layer hot and fast, then the second layer cooler and slower, and to verify the chemistry of the finished surface with a PMI gun on every single panel before it goes into the assembly. I have rejected overlay panels in my own shop because the PMI showed the surface chemistry was 15% chromium when the spec called for 22%. That panel would have lasted a year at best. We stripped it and re-clad it.

The second rule is weld quality. The overlay must be 100% UT or PAUT tested for lack of fusion and lack of sidewall fusion. A lack of fusion in the overlay is a hidden crack starter. When the duct cycles through thermal fatigue, that unfused zone becomes a stress concentrator, and the crack propagates through the overlay and into the base shell. Then you have a water leak in the jacket, and you are back to the same six-month failure. The paper's contribution is that the ASME design basis forces you to think about the overlay as part of the pressure boundary system, not as an afterthought. That means the weld procedure qualification must cover the overlay process, the NDT must cover the overlay, and the hydrostatic test must be run with the overlay in place.

Lessons from the Field

I have walked through converter aisles where the flue duct was the bottleneck. I remember one plant where they ran a duct with a partial overlay—only the lower 40% was clad, the rest was bare carbon steel with a refractory coating. The bare section failed first, at the transition point where the refractory ended and the overlay began. That transition zone is the worst place to have a material change, because the thermal expansion mismatch creates a stress riser, and the dust erosion is worst right at the point where the surface changes from rough refractory to smooth metal. The full overlay design eliminates that transition. It is a single continuous surface from the mouth of the duct to the outlet, with no weak point.

Another lesson: the water jacket itself. The overlay does not help if the cooling water flow is wrong. I have seen ducts fail from the inside because the water side was fouled with scale, the flow was restricted, and the metal overheated to the point where the overlay spalled off. The ASME design must include a proper water velocity calculation, a filtration system, and a way to inspect the water side during a shutdown. The paper does not go into this, but I would tell any engineer who is designing a flue duct: the water side is the side that kills you. The gas side you can see. The water side you cannot.

What I Would Tell a Young Engineer

If you are taking this paper and applying it to a new converter project, here is my advice. First, do not underestimate the importance of the weld procedure qualification. The overlay is not a cosmetic coating; it is a structural element that carries thermal stress and resists erosion. Qualify the procedure on a test panel that represents the actual production geometry, including the corners and the transitions. Second, budget for the NDT. Full overlay means full inspection. If you try to save money by skipping the PAUT on the overlay, you will pay for it in downtime. Third, think about repairability. The overlay will eventually wear out. Design the duct so that the overlay can be re-applied in situ, with access for the welder and the inspector. That is the difference between a duct that lasts five years and a duct that lasts fifteen.

Closing Thoughts

This paper is a solid contribution to the practical literature on converter flue duct design. It moves the industry from a reactive repair mindset to a proactive design mindset, and it does so within the framework of a recognized international code. The real value is not in the novelty of the concept—overlay welding has been around for decades—but in the disciplined application of ASME design and QC principles to a component that has historically been treated as a consumable. If you are building a new converter or refurbishing an old one, take this paper seriously. The flue duct is the difference between a reliable steelmaking operation and a recurring maintenance nightmare.