Effect of Cr3C2 on Microstructure and Properties of Submerged Arc Surfacing Repair Layer for Automotive Molds
The Shop Floor Problem
Automotive molds take a beating. The die surfaces see millions of cycles, high contact pressures, and abrasive wear from the sheet metal sliding across the surface. When the wear exceeds the tolerance, the mold is either scrapped or repaired. Scrapping a large draw die is a six-figure decision. Repairing it is a four-figure decision. The economics are obvious, but the repair itself is the hard part. You are welding a hardfacing alloy onto a tool steel that has already been heat-treated, and you have to do it without cracking the base, without distorting the die, and without leaving the repaired surface softer than the original. The paper by Liu Haixiong and Tang Liping at Hunan Automotive Engineering Vocational College addresses one specific variable in this repair: the Cr3C2 content in the flux-cored wire. They used an open-arc self-shielding method, which is the workhorse of the repair shop because it does not require gas shielding and can be used in the field.
What the Cr3C2 Actually Does
The paper's key finding is that Cr3C2 content has a strong effect on both the microstructure and the performance of the overlay. At low Cr3C2 content, the alloying elements are burned off during the arc, and the base metal dilution dilutes the overlay chemistry. The result is a soft, coarse-grained layer that wears quickly. As Cr3C2 content increases, the carbide formers are protected from oxidation, and the M23C6 carbides nucleate and grow more readily. The optimum is at 8% Cr3C2, where the carbides are uniformly distributed and the wear resistance peaks. Above 8%, the wear resistance actually decreases, because the carbide particles become too large and too clustered, and they start to crack and spall under abrasive load.
The hardness data tells the same story. Hardness increases monotonically with Cr3C2 content, but wear resistance does not follow the same trend. This is a critical lesson for the repair shop. You cannot just chase hardness. A hard layer that is brittle will chip and flake under impact, and the wear rate will be worse than a slightly softer but tougher layer. The 8% Cr3C2 composition gives you the best balance of hardness and toughness, which is why the relative wear resistance peaks there.
Process Window and Practical Application
The open-arc self-shielding method is a double-edged sword. It is convenient, but it is also sensitive to arc length, travel speed, and the condition of the wire. The paper does not give the full process window, but from my experience with similar flux-cored wires, the key parameters are:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Effect on Overlay |
|---|---|---|
| Welding current | 250–350 A | Higher current increases dilution and burn-off |
| Arc voltage | 22–28 V | Higher voltage increases arc length and oxidation |
| Travel speed | 300–500 mm/min | Faster speed reduces deposition rate and dilution |
| Wire feed speed | 3–5 m/min | Controls deposition rate and layer thickness |
| Preheat | 150–250 °C | Prevents cracking in the HAZ of the tool steel |
| Interpass temperature | 200–300 °C | Prevents overheating and grain coarsening |
The preheat and interpass control are the most important for a tool steel substrate. If you weld cold, you get hydrogen cracking in the HAZ. If you weld hot, you temper the base metal and lose the hardness that the mold needs. The paper's contribution is the Cr3C2 optimization, but the practical success of the repair depends on the thermal management around the weld.
What I Have Learned in the Field
I have been involved in mold repair programs for automotive stamping plants, and I have seen both success and failure. The failures almost always trace back to one of three causes. First, insufficient preheat. The welder starts on a cold die, the first pass cracks the HAZ, and the crack propagates through the rest of the repair. Second, poor interpass control. The welder runs the passes too hot, the base metal tempers, and the repaired area is softer than the surrounding die. Third, wrong wire selection. The repair shop buys a generic hardfacing wire because it is cheap, and it does not have the Cr3C2 content that the application needs. The result is a repair that looks good on the surface but wears out in weeks.
The 8% Cr3C2 wire is not a universal solution. It works well for abrasive wear on a tool steel substrate, but if the mold is subject to impact or thermal cycling, you need a different composition. The paper is specific to the automotive mold application, and it is a good reference for that niche. If you are repairing a die that sees primarily abrasive wear, this is the wire to use.
Quality Control and Verification
After the repair, the verification is as important as the welding. I would insist on the following checks:
- Visual inspection of the repaired surface for cracks, porosity, and undercut.
- Magnetic particle or dye penetrant inspection of the repaired area and the HAZ.
- Hardness survey across the repair, including the base metal, the HAZ, and the overlay.
- Metallographic examination of a sample coupon if the repair is critical.
The hardness survey is the most telling. If the HAZ hardness drops below the base metal hardness by more than 10 HRC, the repair has tempered the substrate and the die will fail prematurely. The metallographic examination is the only way to verify the carbide distribution, and it should be done on the first repair of any new wire lot.
Closing Thoughts
This paper is a practical, well-executed study of a single variable in a complex repair process. The finding that 8% Cr3C2 gives the optimal wear resistance is directly applicable to the shop floor, and it saves the repair shop from the trial-and-error approach that wastes wire, time, and dies. The deeper lesson is that hardness is not the same as wear resistance. You have to match the overlay chemistry and microstructure to the specific wear mechanism. For abrasive wear on automotive molds, the 8% Cr3C2 composition is the sweet spot. For anything else, do your own testing before you commit.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd