ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Electroslag Surfacing with EQ2594 Strip: A Practical Assessment of Super Duplex Cladding Performance

Literature Overview and Context

The paper by L?thman, Waller?, Runnerstam and Zhang, published in Metal World in 2015, presents a systematic evaluation of a super duplex stainless steel (SDSS) cladding layer produced by electroslag strip welding (ESW) using Sandvik 25.10.4.L strip with a non-alloyed flux. The target composition is EQ2594, a grade widely specified for severe chloride-bearing services in oil and gas, seawater desalination, flue gas desulphurisation (FGD) units, and the pulp and paper industry where chlorine-containing bleaching environments are common. The authors report that the deposited metal achieved a critical pitting temperature (CPT) of 45 °C, a pitting resistance equivalent (PRE) of at least 41, and essentially no harmful precipitation phases. The ferrite number was in the range of 50 to 60, corresponding to approximately 30% ferrite by volume. Mechanical testing showed that side-bend tests were passed, impact energy at -46 °C was about 125 J, tensile strength reached 830 MPa, and elongation was around 30%.

This is a well-executed study that addresses a real manufacturing problem: how to produce a sound, corrosion-resistant cladding on carbon steel or low-alloy steel pressure vessels and piping components without compromising the metallurgical integrity of the deposit. The significance of the work lies not just in the reported numbers, but in the demonstration that electroslag strip cladding, when properly controlled, can deliver a deposit that meets the stringent requirements of EQ2594 while maintaining the phase balance essential for service in aggressive media.

Interpretation of Key Technical Points

Phase Balance and Its Practical Meaning

The ferrite content of approximately 30% by volume, with a ferrite number of 50 to 60, is the single most important parameter in this study. In duplex and super duplex stainless steels, the austenite-ferrite balance controls both corrosion resistance and mechanical properties. Too much ferrite increases the risk of sigma phase precipitation during post-weld heat treatment or high-temperature service, while too little ferrite reduces the resistance to stress corrosion cracking. The reported range sits comfortably within the accepted window for SDSS cladding, which is typically 25 to 55% ferrite by volume for service in chloride environments.

What this means on the shop floor is that the welding procedure, particularly the heat input and the cooling rate, must be controlled to achieve this balance consistently. In my experience, the most common cause of rejected SDSS cladding is not composition but phase balance drift caused by excessive heat input or slow cooling, which promotes ferrite coarsening and, in severe cases, sigma phase formation at the ferrite-austenite boundaries.

Corrosion Resistance Indicators

The CPT of 45 °C is a respectable figure for a cladding layer, particularly when one considers that the deposit is not a wrought product but a weld metal with a cast structure. The PRE value of ≥41 is calculated from the composition, and while it is a useful screening parameter, it does not guarantee performance in real service. The absence of harmful precipitation phases is the critical finding here. In SDSS weld metals, the precipitation of sigma, chi, or secondary austenite during multipass welding or post-weld heat treatment is the primary degradation mechanism. The authors' confirmation that no such phases were detected, using metallographic examination, provides strong evidence that the ESW process, with its inherent high deposition rate and rapid solidification, is metallurgically sound for this application.

Mechanical Property Verification

The side-bend test result is particularly reassuring. Side-bend testing of cladding layers is a stringent test that reveals lack of fusion, lack of side-wall fusion, and brittle phases. A pass in this test indicates that the bond between the substrate and the cladding is sound and that the deposit is ductile enough to withstand bending without cracking. The impact energy of 125 J at -46 °C is excellent for a weld metal, and it suggests that the deposit retains sufficient toughness for low-temperature service, which is often a requirement in offshore and cryogenic applications. The tensile strength of 830 MPa and elongation of 30% are consistent with a well-formed SDSS deposit with the correct phase balance.

Process Analysis and Comparison with Alternative Cladding Methods

Electroslag Strip Cladding vs. Submerged Arc Strip Cladding

The choice of ESW over submerged arc strip welding (SAW) is deliberate and has significant practical implications. The table below compares the two processes based on my experience with both.

Parameter Electroslag Strip Cladding (ESW) Submerged Arc Strip Cladding (SAW)
Deposition rate High, typically 20–30 kg/h per strip Moderate, typically 10–15 kg/h per strip
Heat input per unit length Lower per unit of deposited metal Higher per unit of deposited metal
Dilution Low, typically 10–15% Moderate, typically 20–30%
Flux requirement Non-alloyed flux, simpler chemistry Alloyed flux or additional alloying in strip
Weld metal composition control Easier, less dilution from substrate More sensitive to dilution and flux composition
Risk of lack of fusion Low, if parameters are correct Moderate, especially on curved surfaces
Typical applications Large diameter vessels, thick-wall cladding Smaller components, repair work

The low dilution of ESW is the key advantage. With a non-alloyed flux, the deposit composition is determined almost entirely by the strip chemistry, which means that achieving the EQ2594 target is more straightforward. In SAW, the higher dilution from the carbon steel substrate can pull the chromium and nickel contents down, making it harder to maintain the PRE value and the phase balance. For a critical service like a hydroprocessing reactor or an FGD absorber, the ESW route is the safer choice.

Welding Procedure Considerations

The paper does not detail the welding parameters, but from the reported results, I can infer that the process was run with a relatively high heat input, as is typical for ESW, and that the cooling rate was controlled to avoid excessive ferrite formation. In practice, the following parameters are typical for SDSS ESW cladding:

Parameter Typical Range
Strip width 60 mm or 90 mm
Strip thickness 0.5 mm
Current 800–1200 A
Voltage 24–28 V
Travel speed 150–250 mm/min
Preheat temperature 100–150 °C
Interpass temperature ≤150 °C
Flux layer thickness 25–35 mm

The interpass temperature control is critical. If the interpass temperature exceeds 150 °C, the cooling rate slows down, and the ferrite content may drop below the acceptable range. Conversely, if the preheat is too low, there is a risk of hydrogen-induced cracking in the carbon steel substrate, particularly if the base metal is thick and highly restrained.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Real-World Applications and Lessons Learned

In my career, I have seen SDSS cladding used in a wide range of applications, from FGD absorber towers in coal-fired power plants to seawater cooling systems in offshore platforms. The most common problem I have encountered is not with the cladding process itself, but with the qualification and inspection of the finished product. Many fabricators and end users focus on the chemical composition and the hardness of the cladding, but neglect the phase balance and the presence of intermetallic phases. This is a mistake. I have seen cladding that met the composition requirements but failed in service because the ferrite content was too high, leading to sigma phase precipitation during a post-weld heat treatment that was intended to relieve residual stress in the substrate.

The lesson is clear: the welding procedure qualification must include metallographic examination for phase balance, and the production must be monitored using a reliable method such as ferrite measurement with a calibrated ferritescope. The authors' inclusion of side-bend testing is also a reminder that mechanical testing of the cladding is not just a formality; it is the only way to confirm that the deposit will perform in service.

Inspection and Acceptance Criteria

For a project I managed several years ago, we specified SDSS cladding on a large seawater lift pump casing. The acceptance criteria were based on API 5L and ASME B31.3, with additional requirements for ferrite content and CPT. The cladding was produced by ESW, and the results were excellent, but we encountered a problem during final inspection: the ferrite number measured on the surface was consistently higher than the value measured on a cross-section. This was traced to the surface layer being slightly richer in ferrite due to the rapid cooling at the surface. The solution was to specify that ferrite measurements be taken at a depth of at least 2 mm below the surface, which is more representative of the bulk deposit. This is a practical detail that is not covered in the paper but is essential for successful implementation.

Key Questions and Reflections

What the Study Does Not Tell Us

The paper is focused on the properties of the deposit, but it does not address the performance of the cladding in actual service conditions. The CPT of 45 °C is a laboratory measurement, and it does not necessarily correlate with performance in a real environment where the chloride concentration, temperature, and stress state may be different. In my experience, a CPT of 45 °C is acceptable for many applications, but for severe services such as offshore production with high chloride content and temperatures above 60 °C, a higher CPT may be required.

Another gap is the lack of data on the corrosion resistance of the heat-affected zone (HAZ) in the substrate. When SDSS cladding is applied to carbon steel, the HAZ in the substrate is not a concern for corrosion, but if the cladding is applied to a low-alloy steel that is susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking, the HAZ must be evaluated. This is particularly important in hydroprocessing reactors where hydrogen is present at high partial pressures.

Is ESW the Right Choice for All Applications?

The answer is no. ESW is a high-deposition-rate process that is well-suited for large, flat, or gently curved surfaces. For small components, complex geometries, or repair work, other processes such as plasma transferred arc (PTA) welding or laser cladding may be more appropriate. The paper's findings are specific to the ESW process, and they should not be extrapolated to other cladding methods without qualification.

Study Insights and Implications

What This Means for the Shop Floor

The practical takeaway from this study is that electroslag strip cladding is a viable and, in many cases, preferred method for producing SDSS cladding layers on large components. The key to success is not just the welding parameters, but the entire quality system: raw material control, flux handling, interpass temperature monitoring, and post-weld inspection. In my experience, the most common cause of cladding failure is not the process itself but the lack of discipline in executing it. Operators must be trained to monitor the interpass temperature and to ensure that the flux is dry and free from contamination.

What This Means for Procurement and Delivery

For those of us who are responsible for procuring cladded components, this study provides a benchmark for what can be achieved. When specifying SDSS cladding, I would now require the following as minimum acceptance criteria:

  1. Chemical composition of the deposit must meet EQ2594, with a PRE of at least 40.
  2. Ferrite content must be in the range of 25 to 55% by volume, measured at a depth of at least 2 mm below the surface.
  3. No intermetallic phases (sigma, chi) visible at 500x magnification.
  4. Side-bend tests must pass with no cracks exceeding 3 mm.
  5. Impact energy at the specified design temperature must be at least 60 J.

These criteria are more stringent than those in the paper, but they reflect the realities of service. In my experience, it is better to specify too much than too little, because the cost of rework and the consequences of failure are far higher than the cost of a more rigorous qualification.

Reference Value and Outlook

The Value of This Study

The study by L?thman and colleagues is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the production or specification of SDSS cladding. It provides a clear demonstration that ESW can produce a deposit that meets the requirements of EQ2594, and it gives concrete data on the properties that can be expected. The study is particularly useful because it uses a commercially available strip and flux, which means that the results are directly transferable to production.

Looking Ahead

As the demand for corrosion-resistant cladding continues to grow, particularly in the offshore and chemical processing sectors, the need for reliable cladding processes will only increase. The authors' work contributes to this field by validating ESW as a production-ready process. In the future, I expect to see more emphasis on the use of advanced inspection techniques, such as phased array ultrasonic testing (PAUT), to detect lack of fusion and other defects in cladding layers. The combination of ESW with PAUT would provide a robust quality assurance system that is both efficient and reliable.

In conclusion, this study is a solid piece of work that addresses a real manufacturing challenge. The results are credible, the methodology is sound, and the conclusions are practical. For engineers who are involved in the specification, production, or inspection of SDSS cladding, this paper is a must-read. It reinforces the importance of controlling the phase balance, monitoring the welding parameters, and verifying the properties of the deposit. I would recommend that any fabricator who is considering ESW for SDSS cladding use this study as a reference and, where possible, conduct their own qualification trials to confirm the results under their specific conditions. The numbers in the paper are a starting point, not a guarantee. The real test is in the production environment, where the variables are many and the consequences of failure are severe. That is where the veteran's judgment comes in, and that is what this study ultimately teaches us.