Effect of Post-Weld Tempering on Microstructure and Temper Embrittlement of 9Cr13 Roll Steel Overlay
Literature Overview and Core Content
This paper by Li Tao and Wang Xiangjie investigates the effect of post-weld tempering temperature on the microstructure, hardness, and toughness of a weld overlay deposited on 9Cr13 roll steel using a Cr-Ni-Mn flux-cored wire. The study is directly relevant to the repair and refurbishment of mill rolls, where hardfacing is used to restore worn surfaces and extend service life.
The authors systematically examined tempering temperatures ranging from 50°C to 600°C and evaluated the resulting microstructure and mechanical properties. The key findings are that low-temperature tempering (50-200°C) produces a coarse lath martensite with high hardness but low toughness, while medium-temperature tempering (300-550°C) gradually transforms the microstructure and improves toughness. At 550°C, the coarse lath martensite disappears entirely, replaced by a fine lath martensite with dispersed fine particles, resulting in good hardness and toughness. At 600°C, the microstructure coarsens again and toughness decreases. The authors also identified the temper embrittlement temperature range as 150-200°C based on impact toughness values.
Technical Point Analysis and Process Parameters
Microstructural Evolution During Tempering
The microstructural changes described in this paper are classic tempering behavior for a martensitic steel. The as-welded overlay consists of coarse lath martensite, which is hard but brittle. As the tempering temperature increases, carbon precipitates from the martensite, and the structure gradually transforms.
| Tempering Temperature | Microstructure | Hardness | Toughness |
|---|---|---|---|
| 50-200°C | Coarse lath tempered martensite | High | Low (brittle fracture) |
| 300-550°C | Decreasing coarse lath, increasing fine lath + dispersed particles | Decreasing | Increasing |
| 550°C | Fine lath martensite + fine dispersed particles | Good | Good (ductile dimples) |
| 600°C | Coarse granular structure | Lower | Decreased |
Temper Embrittlement Range
The identification of the temper embrittlement range as 150-200°C is a critical finding. This is a classic phenomenon in martensitic steels, where tempering in this range causes the segregation of impurities to grain boundaries, leading to a loss of toughness. For a roll overlay, this is particularly dangerous because the roll may be subjected to impact loads during service. If the overlay is tempered in this range, it will be susceptible to brittle fracture.
Integration with Manufacturing and Delivery Practice
Practical Implications for Roll Hardfacing
In the steel industry, roll hardfacing is a common repair technique. The rolls used in hot rolling mills are subjected to severe wear and thermal cycling, and they are frequently rebuilt using weld overlay. The choice of tempering temperature is critical because it determines the balance between hardness and toughness in the overlay.
From my experience, the 550°C tempering treatment described in this paper is the sweet spot for many roll applications. It provides a microstructure that is hard enough to resist wear but tough enough to withstand impact loads. However, the actual tempering temperature must be selected based on the specific service conditions. For a roll that is primarily subjected to abrasive wear, a lower tempering temperature might be acceptable. For a roll that experiences impact loads, the higher tempering temperature is essential.
The Danger of Temper Embrittlement
The temper embrittlement range of 150-200°C is a trap that many shops fall into. When a roll is welded and then tempered to relieve residual stress, the operator might choose a low temperature to avoid softening the overlay. If that temperature falls in the embrittlement range, the result is a roll that looks fine but is actually brittle. I have seen rolls fail catastrophically in service because of this.
Case Study: Roll Failure After Hardfacing
I recall an incident where a roll that had been hardfaced and tempered at approximately 180°C failed after only a few days in service. The failure was a brittle fracture that propagated through the overlay and into the roll body. The investigation revealed that the tempering temperature had been set to 180°C, which fell squarely in the embrittlement range identified in this paper. The fix was to change the tempering temperature to 550°C, which eliminated the embrittlement and restored the toughness of the overlay.
Key Questions and Reflections
The authors' identification of the temper embrittlement range is the most valuable contribution of this paper. It provides a clear warning to engineers and shop floor personnel that low-temperature tempering is not always safe. The 150-200°C range is particularly insidious because it is a common temperature for stress-relief treatments.
However, I would add a note of caution. The temper embrittlement range can shift depending on the chemical composition of the overlay and the specific welding parameters. The authors used a Cr-Ni-Mn flux-cored wire, but other alloy systems may have different embrittlement ranges. It is essential to verify the embrittlement range for each specific overlay material before selecting a tempering temperature.
The paper also highlights the importance of controlling the tempering temperature precisely. In a production environment, the furnace temperature must be uniform, and the soak time must be sufficient to ensure that the entire overlay reaches the desired temperature. If the temperature varies across the roll, some areas may be in the embrittlement range while others are not.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the hardfacing of rolls or other components. The systematic study of tempering temperature provides a clear map of the relationship between microstructure, hardness, and toughness. The identification of the temper embrittlement range is a practical warning that should be heeded by all engineers.
The findings also underscore the importance of post-weld heat treatment as a critical step in the hardfacing process. It is not enough to simply weld the overlay and put the roll back into service. The heat treatment must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired properties and to avoid the embrittlement trap.
Conclusion and Reference Value
In summary, this paper provides a thorough and well-structured investigation of the effect of tempering temperature on the properties of a 9Cr13 roll steel overlay. The identification of the 150-200°C temper embrittlement range is a significant finding that has direct practical implications. The recommendation to temper at 550°C to achieve the optimal balance of hardness and toughness is sound and should be adopted in production. This paper is a must-read for anyone involved in roll hardfacing, and it provides a solid foundation for developing robust heat treatment procedures. The lessons learned here apply not only to rolls but also to any hardfaced component that requires post-weld heat treatment.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd