Effect of Different Aging Treatments on Hardness and Wear Resistance of Hardfacing Layers
Core Findings and Technical Interpretation
This paper by Hong Yongchang addresses a topic that is often overlooked in hardfacing practice: the effect of post-weld heat treatment on the properties of the deposit. The author studied two different hardfacing materials and subjected them to various aging treatments at different temperatures and times. The key finding is that the as-welded state, which typically has the highest hardness, does not necessarily have the best wear resistance. In fact, the paper shows that the as-welded state has poorer wear resistance than the aged state.
This is a counterintuitive finding that many engineers struggle to accept. The common belief is that "harder is better" when it comes to wear resistance. However, the paper demonstrates that this is not always true. The wear resistance of a material is not determined solely by its hardness, but also by its microstructure, toughness, and the ability to resist crack initiation and propagation.
The following table summarizes the key findings from the paper, based on my interpretation of the data.
| Condition | Hardness | Wear Resistance | Microstructural Observation |
|---|---|---|---|
| As-welded | Highest | Lowest | Fine martensite with high residual stress |
| Aged at 560°C, short time | Moderate | Moderate | Tempered martensite, some carbide precipitation |
| Aged at 560°C, long time | Lower | Highest | Coarser carbides, more stable microstructure |
The explanation for this behavior lies in the residual stress and the stability of the microstructure. In the as-welded state, the deposit is martensitic and has high residual tensile stresses. These stresses cause the material to be brittle, and when subjected to wear, the surface layer tends to crack and spall off. The cracks then act as stress concentrators, accelerating the wear process.
When the deposit is aged, the residual stresses are relieved, and the martensite is tempered. This reduces the hardness but increases the toughness and ductility. The tempered martensite is more resistant to crack initiation and propagation, so the wear rate is lower. The longer aging time allows for further tempering and the precipitation of more stable carbides, which further improves the wear resistance.
Metallurgical Analysis and Practical Implications
The paper's use of SEM to observe the worn surfaces provides valuable insight into the wear mechanism. In the as-welded state, the worn surface shows evidence of brittle fracture and spalling. In the aged state, the worn surface shows evidence of plastic deformation and micro-cutting, which indicates a more ductile wear mechanism.
This has important implications for hardfacing practice. When you hardface a component and put it into service without any post-weld heat treatment, you are not getting the best performance from the deposit. The high residual stresses and the brittle microstructure will cause premature failure.
However, I must point out that the optimal aging treatment depends on the specific alloy system. The paper studied two different materials, and the optimal aging temperature and time may be different for each. In general, the following guidelines apply:
- Aging temperature: The aging temperature should be high enough to relieve residual stresses but not so high that it causes excessive softening or grain growth. For most hardfacing alloys, a temperature of 500-600°C is appropriate.
- Aging time: The aging time should be long enough to allow for complete stress relief and carbide precipitation, but not so long that it causes over-aging and coarsening of the carbides.
- Cooling rate: After aging, the component should be cooled slowly to prevent the formation of new residual stresses.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
In my experience, the failure to perform post-weld heat treatment is one of the most common causes of hardfacing failures. I have seen countless components that were hardfaced and put into service without any heat treatment, only to fail prematurely due to cracking and spalling. The paper provides a clear explanation for this behavior and offers a practical solution.
For the pipe and fitting industry, this has direct relevance to the hardfacing of components such as:
- Conveyor rolls and idlers
- Pipe mill entry and exit guides
- Mandrel bars and plug mills
- Slurry pump impellers and casings
In each of these applications, the hardfaced component is subjected to abrasive wear, and the deposit must be able to withstand the wear without cracking or spalling. A post-weld aging treatment can significantly improve the performance of the deposit, but it adds time and cost to the manufacturing process.
One practical consideration that the paper does not address is the effect of aging on the substrate material. When you age a hardfaced component, you are also aging the substrate. For a low-carbon steel substrate, this is usually not a problem. However, for a high-strength steel substrate, the aging treatment may cause softening or other undesirable changes in the substrate properties. This must be considered when selecting the aging temperature and time.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper is a valuable reminder that hardness is not the only factor that determines wear resistance. The microstructure and the residual stress state are equally important. A hardfacing deposit that is hard but brittle will not perform as well as a deposit that is slightly softer but tougher and more stable.
This is a lesson that I have learned the hard way over many years of practice. I have seen hardfacing deposits with a hardness of HRC 60 fail in a matter of weeks, while deposits with a hardness of HRC 50 have lasted for years. The difference is always in the microstructure and the residual stress state.
For the practicing engineer, the key takeaway is to always consider post-weld heat treatment as part of the hardfacing process. The additional time and cost are usually justified by the improved performance and longer service life of the component. In some cases, it may be possible to achieve the same effect by using a different hardfacing alloy that is less prone to residual stress and cracking. However, in most cases, a simple aging treatment is the most cost-effective solution.
In conclusion, this paper provides a clear and well-supported explanation of the relationship between aging treatment, hardness, and wear resistance in hardfacing deposits. The finding that the as-welded state has poorer wear resistance than the aged state is a valuable contribution to the field, and it should be incorporated into the design and manufacturing practices for hardfaced components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd