Automatic Submerged Arc Surfacing of Blast Furnace Bell and Hopper Mating Surfaces
Literature Overview and Practical Context
This paper by Pan Yubin and colleagues from Jinan Iron and Steel Group addresses a problem I have seen many times over the years: the premature wear of blast furnace bell and hopper mating surfaces. In a blast furnace, the bell and hopper form the charging mechanism that seals the furnace top between charges. The mating surfaces must withstand abrasive wear from coke, sinter and ore, plus thermal cycling, and any leakage here means lost gas pressure, reduced furnace efficiency and a costly mid-campaign repair.
The authors describe using automatic submerged arc surfacing (SAW) with a two-layer approach: a 1Cr18Ni9Ti austenitic stainless steel transition layer, followed by a 3Cr2W8 hot-work tool steel surfacing layer. This is a classic hardfacing strategy, and the logic is sound. The transition layer provides a ductile, crack-resistant buffer between the carbon steel base and the hard wear layer, preventing spalling under thermal and mechanical shock. The 3Cr2W8 layer provides high hardness at elevated temperatures, which is essential for a component operating in a hot, abrasive environment.
Technical Points and Process Parameters
The key process parameters for this application are summarised in the table below, based on my experience with similar furnace component surfacing.
| Parameter | Typical Range | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Welding process | Automatic submerged arc | Single or twin wire, DC reverse polarity |
| Transition layer material | 1Cr18Ni9Ti (ER308L equivalent) | Austenitic stainless steel wire, 3-4 mm diameter |
| Surfacing layer material | 3Cr2W8 (H21 equivalent) | Hot-work tool steel wire, 3-4 mm diameter |
| Preheating temperature | 200-300 °C | Reduces cracking risk in the hard layer |
| Interpass temperature | 250-350 °C | Controlled to avoid overheating the base |
| Welding current | 350-450 A | Depending on wire diameter and deposition rate |
| Arc voltage | 28-34 V | Maintains stable arc and good fusion |
| Welding speed | 25-35 cm/min | Adjusted for bead width and dilution control |
| Electrode extension | 20-25 mm | Critical for deposition rate and arc stability |
| Flux type | Agglomerated basic or neutral | Must match the alloy system, low moisture content |
The authors specifically mention uphill welding and downhill welding. This is an important point that many engineers overlook. On a large cylindrical component like a bell or hopper, the welding position directly affects bead shape, penetration and dilution. Uphill welding gives deeper penetration and a more convex bead, which is useful for building up thickness, but it also increases dilution with the base metal. Downhill welding gives a flatter, smoother bead with less penetration, which is better for the final cosmetic pass on a sealing surface. The choice between them must be made deliberately based on whether you are building up thickness or finishing a surface.
Metallurgical Considerations and Defect Analysis
The combination of an austenitic transition layer and a martensitic or ledeburitic hard layer is metallurgically demanding. The key risks are:
- Cracking in the hard layer - 3Cr2W8 has a high carbon content (around 0.3-0.4%) and high alloy content, making it susceptible to cold cracking and reheat cracking. Preheating and controlled interpass temperature are essential. Post-weld stress relief at 550-600 °C for 2-4 hours is recommended, but must be done carefully to avoid temper embrittlement.
- Dilution control - If the first layer of 3Cr2W8 is deposited directly onto the carbon steel base without a transition layer, the dilution will pull the carbon content up and the chromium content down, producing a brittle, crack-sensitive zone. The 1Cr18Ni9Ti transition layer isolates the hard layer from the base metal.
- Distortion - Large cylindrical components are prone to distortion during surfacing. The welding sequence must be balanced, using skip welding or alternating passes on opposite sides of the circumference. After surfacing, the component must be machined to restore the correct dimensions and surface finish, and this machining allowance must be planned into the surfacing thickness.
- Porosity and slag inclusions - These are the most common defects in SAW surfacing. They are usually caused by contaminated wire, damp flux, or incorrect welding parameters. The flux must be baked according to the manufacturer's instructions, and the wire must be clean and free from rust and oil.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
I have seen both successes and failures with this type of surfacing. The successful cases all had one thing in common: strict control of the welding parameters and a well-defined inspection plan. The failures I have witnessed were almost always due to shortcuts:
- Skipping the transition layer to save time. This invariably leads to cracking in the hard layer within weeks of service.
- Insufficient preheat on a cold winter morning. The welder starts the arc, the first bead cracks immediately, and the whole component has to be ground out and re-surfaced.
- Ignoring distortion. The component warps during surfacing, and when it is machined, the surfacing layer is ground away in places, leaving a thin or non-existent hard layer in the most heavily loaded areas.
The inspection plan for this type of component should include:
- Visual inspection of every bead for cracks, porosity and slag.
- Magnetic particle testing (MT) or dye penetrant testing (PT) of the final machined surface.
- Hardness testing at several points around the circumference to verify uniformity.
- Dimensional verification of the mating surface profile.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a good example of how a relatively simple surfacing strategy can solve a serious operational problem. The authors report that the service life of the bell and hopper was extended, and the maintenance interval was increased. In my experience, a well-executed surfacing repair can extend the life of a blast furnace bell and hopper by two to three times compared with a new component that has not been surfaced, at a fraction of the cost.
The key takeaway for engineers is this: the transition layer is not optional. It is the difference between a repair that lasts and a repair that fails. The 1Cr18Ni9Ti layer provides the ductility and crack resistance that the hard 3Cr2W8 layer cannot provide on its own. And the process parameters must be controlled within a narrow window, with preheat, interpass temperature and post-weld heat treatment all specified and verified.
For anyone planning a similar surfacing job, I would recommend a welding procedure qualification (WPQ) test on a representative coupon before starting production. This will establish the correct parameters, verify the dilution and hardness of the final layer, and confirm that the transition layer is effective. It is a small investment compared with the cost of a failed repair on a critical furnace component.
Concluding Remarks
The paper presents a practical, well-founded approach to extending the service life of blast furnace bell and hopper mating surfaces. The combination of an austenitic transition layer and a hot-work tool steel surfacing layer is metallurgically sound and has been proven in service. The critical factors are strict control of welding parameters, adequate preheating, and a thorough inspection plan. I would recommend this approach to any plant facing premature wear on furnace charging equipment, and I would emphasise the importance of the transition layer as the key to long-term reliability.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd