ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Study on Surfacing Process of Urea-Grade Stainless Steel Welding Materials

Literature Overview and Practical Context

This paper by Jiang Zedong and Zhu Zhicheng from Changzhou Vocational Institute of Engineering addresses the surfacing of urea-grade stainless steel on carbon steel substrates. The application is for equipment used in urea production, where the process medium is highly corrosive and the equipment must meet stringent material requirements.

Urea-grade stainless steel is a special grade of austenitic stainless steel that has been specifically developed for use in urea synthesis equipment. The material must resist corrosion by ammonium carbamate, which is highly aggressive and can cause severe corrosion of conventional stainless steels. The standard grades used for urea service are typically 316L (urea grade) or 25-22-2 type alloys, which have a controlled ferrite content and a low carbon content to prevent sensitisation.

In this study, the authors used E310Mo-15 stainless steel electrodes to deposit a surfacing layer on Q345R carbon steel plates. The E310Mo-15 electrode is a 25-20 type austenitic stainless steel with molybdenum addition, which provides good corrosion resistance and high-temperature strength. The surfacing was done by shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) on 50 mm thick Q345R plates.

Welding Procedure and Qualification Testing

The welding procedure used in this study is summarised in the table below.

Parameter Value Notes
Base metal Q345R, 50 mm thick Pressure vessel steel
Welding process SMAW (shielded metal arc welding) Manual, DC reverse polarity
Electrode E310Mo-15 Urea-grade stainless steel, 3.2-4.0 mm diameter
Preheating Not specified Likely not required for austenitic stainless steel
Interpass temperature Max 150 °C To prevent sensitisation and distortion
Welding current 90-130 A Depending on electrode diameter
Arc voltage 22-26 V Normal range for SMAW
Welding speed 10-15 cm/min Controlled to achieve the required bead size
Number of layers 2-3 layers To achieve the required thickness and dilution control

The qualification testing included tensile testing, bending testing and intergranular corrosion testing. The results showed that all properties were within the acceptable range, and the welding procedure was qualified for production use.

The intergranular corrosion test is particularly important for urea-grade stainless steel. The standard test for this application is the Strauss test (ASTM A262 Practice E), which involves boiling the specimen in a copper sulfate-sulfuric acid solution for a specified time and then bending it to check for cracks. The test is designed to detect sensitisation, which is the precipitation of chromium carbides at grain boundaries, leading to chromium depletion and loss of corrosion resistance.

Metallurgical Analysis and Defect Assessment

The metallographic examination revealed a few minor defects, but all were within the acceptable range of the relevant standards. This is an important point. In surfacing applications, some porosity and slag inclusions are inevitable, and the standards allow a certain level of defects. The key is to ensure that the defects are not in critical locations and that they are within the acceptance criteria.

The microstructure of the E310Mo-15 surfacing layer is typically fully austenitic with a small amount of ferrite. The ferrite content is important for two reasons: it improves the resistance to hot cracking during welding, and it provides a two-phase structure that can be beneficial for corrosion resistance. However, too much ferrite can reduce the corrosion resistance in certain media, so the ferrite content must be controlled within a narrow range.

The dilution between the surfacing layer and the base metal is a critical factor. If the dilution is too high, the carbon from the Q345R base metal will be picked up by the stainless steel layer, increasing the carbon content and reducing the corrosion resistance. The first layer typically has the highest dilution, and it is common practice to deposit a second or third layer to achieve the required chemical composition in the final surface.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Urea-grade stainless steel surfacing is a demanding application that requires strict quality control. In my experience, the most common problems are:

  1. Sensitisation - caused by excessive heat input or high interpass temperature. The carbon in the stainless steel precipitates at grain boundaries, leading to intergranular corrosion. The solution is to keep the interpass temperature below 150 °C and to use low heat input.
  2. Dilution - caused by excessive penetration into the base metal. The solution is to use a low current and a high welding speed, and to deposit multiple layers to achieve the required composition in the final surface.
  3. Cracking - caused by the high thermal expansion coefficient of austenitic stainless steel. The solution is to use a low heat input and to control the welding sequence to minimise residual stress.
  4. Ferrite content control - the ferrite content must be controlled within the range specified by the material standard. Too much ferrite can reduce the corrosion resistance, while too little ferrite increases the risk of hot cracking.

The qualification testing described in this paper is essential for ensuring the quality of the surfacing layer. The tensile and bending tests confirm that the surfacing layer has adequate strength and ductility, while the intergranular corrosion test confirms that the material is not sensitised and will resist the corrosive medium.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper demonstrates that urea-grade stainless steel surfacing on carbon steel is a viable approach for manufacturing equipment that must resist highly corrosive media. The use of E310Mo-15 electrodes provides a cost-effective alternative to solid urea-grade stainless steel construction, while still meeting the required corrosion resistance and mechanical properties.

The key insight for engineers is that the welding procedure qualification is essential before production. The qualification test must include all the required tests, including tensile, bending and intergranular corrosion, and the results must be documented and reviewed. In practice, I have seen many cases where a welding procedure was qualified on a small coupon but failed when applied to a large production component, because the heat input and interpass temperature were not properly controlled.

For anyone planning a urea-grade stainless steel surfacing job, I would recommend the following:

  1. Use a qualified welding procedure with documented parameters.
  2. Control the interpass temperature strictly, using a contact pyrometer or infrared thermometer.
  3. Monitor the ferrite content of the deposited metal using a ferrite scope.
  4. Conduct intergranular corrosion testing on production coupons, not just on the qualification coupon.
  5. Inspect the final surface with dye penetrant testing (PT) to detect any cracks or porosity.

Concluding Remarks

The study confirms that urea-grade stainless steel surfacing using E310Mo-15 electrodes on Q345R base metal is a technically sound approach. The welding procedure qualification demonstrated that the surfacing layer meets the required mechanical properties and corrosion resistance. The metallographic examination showed that the defects were within the acceptable range. This approach offers a cost-effective solution for equipment in urea production, provided that the welding parameters are strictly controlled and the quality assurance plan is followed. The lessons from this study are directly applicable to other corrosion-resistant surfacing applications, and I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the design or fabrication of urea-grade equipment.