High-Chromium Cast Iron Hardfacing with D938 Electrode: Practical Lessons from the Welding Booth
The Challenge of Welding High-Chromium Cast Iron
I have spent more hours than I care to count watching welders struggle with high-chromium cast iron. It is a material that promises outstanding wear resistance but delivers cracking and spalling if you do not treat it with respect. The paper by Wang Yan and Dai Haijun from Xihua University and Chenggong Engineering Machinery is a short but valuable experimental study on the D938 electrode, a strengthened high-chromium cast iron hardfacing electrode that has notoriously poor weldability. The authors tested it on Q235 base metal and came to some practical conclusions that I have verified in my own plants.
The fundamental problem with high-chromium cast iron is its microstructure. It consists of hard chromium carbides dispersed in a martensitic or austenitic matrix. The carbides give it wear resistance, but they also make it brittle and prone to cracking. When you deposit it on a steel base, the thermal expansion mismatch and the rapid cooling of the hardfacing layer create high tensile stresses that can crack the deposit or cause it to spall off the base. The paper's key contribution is identifying the process window that avoids these problems.
The Process Window That Works
The paper identifies three critical parameters: welding current, interpass temperature, and arc length. Let me translate these into practical shop floor terms.
| Parameter | Recommended Range | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| Welding current | 150-180 A for 4 mm electrode | Too low gives poor fusion and porosity; too high increases dilution and cracking risk |
| Interpass temperature | 300-350°C | Maintains the deposit in a ductile state and prevents hard cracking |
| Arc length | Short arc, 2-3 mm | Reduces oxidation and nitrogen pickup, improves deposit quality |
| Preheat | 200-300°C | Slows cooling rate and reduces thermal gradient |
| Cooling | Slow cooling in dry lime or sand | Prevents martensite formation in the HAZ and reduces residual stress |
The authors emphasize that the interpass temperature must be strictly controlled at 300-350°C. In my experience, this is the single most important parameter. If the interpass temperature drops below 250°C, the deposit will crack. If it rises above 400°C, the deposit will be too soft and lose its wear resistance. I have seen welders try to speed up the job by welding continuous beads without letting the temperature stabilize, and the result is always the same: a cracked deposit that has to be ground out and redone.
The short arc technique is also critical. With a long arc, the chromium and carbon in the electrode oxidize, and you get porosity and a degraded deposit. A short arc keeps the metal transfer stable and minimizes atmospheric contamination. The authors also recommend preheating and slow cooling, which I fully endorse. For a Q235 base, preheat at 200-300°C is sufficient. For a higher carbon steel or a cast iron base, you would need to go higher, up to 350-400°C.
Metallographic Analysis and What It Tells Us
The paper reports the hardness and microstructure of the deposited layer. The hardness values, which I recall being in the range of 55-62 HRC, are consistent with what I have measured on similar high-chromium cast iron deposits. The microstructure shows primary chromium carbides in a martensitic matrix, which is exactly what you want for abrasive wear resistance.
What I find most useful in the paper is the correlation between the process parameters and the resulting microstructure. When the interpass temperature is too low, the deposit cools quickly, and the matrix transforms to untempered martensite, which is hard but brittle. When the interpass temperature is too high, the carbides coarsen, and the matrix becomes austenitic, which is soft and has poor wear resistance. The 300-350°C window is the sweet spot where the matrix transforms to a fine martensite with a small amount of retained austenite, giving the best combination of hardness and toughness.
I want to add one observation from my own experience. The paper tests on Q235, which is a low carbon steel. In real applications, you often hardface high-chromium cast iron onto medium carbon steels or cast iron bases, which have higher carbon equivalents. This increases the risk of cold cracking in the HAZ. If you are hardfacing onto a cast iron base, you need to preheat to 350-400°C and use a nickel-based or austenitic stainless buffer layer to absorb the stresses. I have seen many failures where a welder skipped the buffer layer and the deposit spalled off within days.
Practical Applications and Lessons Learned
The paper is aimed at abrasive wear conditions, such as those found in mining, cement, and crushing equipment. In my career, I have applied high-chromium cast iron hardfacing to fan blades, crusher hammers, and chute liners, and the D938 electrode has served me well when the process is followed correctly.
The key lesson I want to pass on to fellow engineers is that the process is unforgiving. You cannot treat D938 like a mild steel electrode. You must preheat, you must control interpass temperature, you must use a short arc, and you must slow cool. If you do all four, you will get a deposit that outlasts the original part by a factor of two or three. If you skip any one of them, you will get cracking, and the repair will fail.
I also want to emphasize the importance of cleaning between passes. High-chromium cast iron deposits produce a tenacious slag that must be removed with a chipping hammer and wire brush. If you leave slag in the joint, you will get inclusions that act as crack initiation sites. This is basic practice, but I have seen it neglected more times than I care to admit.
My final thought is that the paper is short but valuable. It does not go into the depth of a full metallurgical study, but it gives the practical process window that a welder needs to know. For a shop floor engineer, that is worth more than a hundred pages of theory.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd