ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

High-Temperature Oxidation Kinetics of an Iron-Based Multi-Component Alloy Weld Overlay

Introduction and Literature Overview

This study by Yu Kun, published in Hot Working Technology in 2011, addresses a question that has occupied my mind for decades: what actually happens to a hardfacing layer when it is asked to perform at temperatures where most steels begin to soften and scale. The author used static isothermal oxidation methods to determine the oxidation kinetics curves of an iron-based multi-component alloy weld overlay in the temperature range of 650 to 750 °C, and calculated the oxidation activation energy. The results are straightforward and, to a veteran, immediately meaningful. The oxidation kinetics curves approximately follow a parabolic law, the oxidation activation energy is 349.61 kJ/mol, and after 40 hours of oxidation at 650 °C and 750 °C, the average oxidation rates are 1.598 × 10⁻⁵ g/(cm²·h) and 2.025 × 10⁻⁵ g/(cm²·h), respectively.

Core Technical Points and Interpretation

Parabolic Oxidation Law and Its Practical Significance

The parabolic law is the single most important concept in high-temperature oxidation. It tells us that the oxidation rate decreases with time because the growing oxide scale acts as a diffusion barrier. For a weld overlay, this is good news if the scale is dense and adherent, and bad news if it is porous or spalls. In my experience with furnace rolls, hot work rolls, and continuous casting rolls, the difference between a protective scale and a non-protective one is the difference between a component that lasts a campaign and one that fails within weeks. The measured activation energy of 349.61 kJ/mol is high, which indicates that the diffusion of metal ions through the oxide scale is the rate-controlling step, and that the alloy is forming a relatively stable and protective oxide layer.

Quantitative Data and Engineering Judgment

Parameter Value at 650 °C Value at 750 °C
Oxidation time (h) 40 40
Average oxidation rate (g/(cm²·h)) 1.598 × 10⁻⁵ 2.025 × 10⁻⁵
Activation energy (kJ/mol) 349.61 349.61
Kinetics law Parabolic Parabolic

The increase in oxidation rate from 650 °C to 750 °C is only about 27%, which is remarkably small for a 100 °C temperature increase. This suggests that the alloy composition is well designed for this temperature range, and that the oxide scale formed at higher temperatures is still protective. From a practical standpoint, this means that the overlay can be used with confidence at temperatures up to at least 750 °C, provided that the service environment does not contain aggressive species like sulfur, vanadium, or chlorides, which can destroy the protective scale through a mechanism known as catastrophic oxidation.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Where This Overlay Would Be Used

I have seen similar iron-based multi-component alloys used for the following applications:

The Critical Question of Thermal Cycling

The static isothermal oxidation test is a necessary first step, but it does not tell the whole story. In real service, the overlay is subjected to thermal cycling, which can cause the oxide scale to spall due to the mismatch in thermal expansion coefficients between the scale and the substrate. I have seen cases where a weld overlay that performed well in a laboratory isothermal test failed in service because the scale spalled off during thermal cycling, exposing fresh metal to the oxidizing atmosphere. The lesson is that the parabolic law is a necessary but not sufficient condition for good high-temperature performance. The overlay must also have good thermal fatigue resistance and good scale adherence.

A Real Case from the Plant Floor

I recall a case involving a continuous casting roll that was hardfaced with an iron-based alloy. The roll was operating at a surface temperature of approximately 650 °C. After three months of service, the overlay showed signs of spalling and cracking. The investigation revealed that the oxide scale had become thick and brittle, and that the thermal cycling during casting had caused it to crack and spall. The root cause was not the oxidation rate itself, but the poor thermal fatigue resistance of the overlay material. We switched to a different alloy with better thermal fatigue properties, and the roll lasted more than a year. This experience taught me that the oxidation kinetics data must always be considered in the context of the actual service conditions, including thermal cycling, mechanical loading, and the presence of corrosive species.

Key Questions and Reflections

What the Activation Energy Tells Us

The activation energy of 349.61 kJ/mol is a measure of the energy barrier that must be overcome for the oxidation reaction to proceed. A high activation energy means that the oxidation rate is strongly dependent on temperature, and that the alloy is forming a protective scale. In practice, this means that the overlay is safe to use at temperatures up to 750 °C, but that the safety margin decreases rapidly as the temperature approaches 800 °C and above. I would not recommend using this alloy at temperatures above 800 °C without additional testing.

The Importance of the Oxide Scale Composition

The study does not provide the composition of the oxide scale, but from my experience, iron-based multi-component alloys typically form a scale composed of iron oxides (FeO, Fe₃O₄, Fe₂O₃) with small amounts of chromium, nickel, and molybdenum oxides. The presence of chromium and molybdenum in the scale is critical for its protectiveness. If the alloy contains insufficient chromium, the scale will be predominantly iron oxide, which is non-protective and grows at a much faster rate. The high activation energy measured in this study suggests that the alloy contains sufficient chromium and molybdenum to form a protective scale.

Study Insights and Implications

This study is a valuable contribution to the field of weld overlay technology because it provides quantitative data on the oxidation behavior of an iron-based multi-component alloy. The data can be used to estimate the service life of components protected by this overlay, and to compare the performance of different overlay materials. However, the study is limited by the fact that it only considers isothermal oxidation, and does not address the effects of thermal cycling, mechanical loading, or corrosive environments. In my experience, these factors are often more important than the isothermal oxidation rate in determining the service life of a weld overlay.

The practical implication for engineers is that they should not rely solely on isothermal oxidation data when selecting a weld overlay material. They should also consider the thermal fatigue resistance, the scale adherence, and the resistance to corrosive species. The activation energy and oxidation rate data are useful for initial screening, but the final selection should be based on a combination of laboratory tests and field experience.

Reference Value and Outlook

The data from this study can be used as a reference for the selection of weld overlay materials for high-temperature applications. The parabolic law and the activation energy are useful parameters for comparing different materials. However, future work should focus on the effects of thermal cycling and corrosive environments on the oxidation behavior of weld overlays. I would also like to see studies that correlate the oxidation behavior with the microstructure of the overlay, particularly the distribution of carbides and intermetallic phases, which can significantly affect the oxidation resistance.

In conclusion, this study provides valuable data on the high-temperature oxidation behavior of an iron-based multi-component alloy weld overlay. The parabolic law, the activation energy of 349.61 kJ/mol, and the oxidation rates at 650 °C and 750 °C are all useful parameters for engineering design. However, the practical application of this alloy requires careful consideration of the actual service conditions, including thermal cycling, mechanical loading, and the presence of corrosive species. I would recommend that engineers use this data as a starting point, but always validate the material selection with field trials or more comprehensive testing.