ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Iron-Based Multi-Component Alloy Surfacing Layers

Literature Overview

This paper by Li Shun (Qinhuangdao Vocational and Technical College, published in Hot Working Technology, 2010, Vol. 39, No. 7, pp. 113-114) presents a detailed analysis of the microstructure and mechanical properties of an iron-based multi-component alloy surfacing layer. The study uses optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and mechanical testing to characterize the deposit in the as-welded condition and after tempering at 500°C for 2 hours.

The key results are:

Property As-Welded After 500°C Tempering
Hardness 41.5 HRC Similar
Tensile strength 1278.56 MPa Slightly lower
Impact toughness 21.47 J/cm² Slightly lower
Elongation 7.58% Slightly higher
Reduction of area 42.13% Slightly higher

This is a useful data set for anyone specifying iron-based hardfacing alloys. The deposit is a typical martensitic or bainitic type, with moderate hardness and good toughness for a hardfacing material.

Core Technical Points

The Alloy System

Iron-based multi-component alloys for surfacing typically contain:

The specific composition in this paper is not given in the abstract, but the mechanical properties suggest a low-alloy, high-strength type rather than a high-chromium carbide type. The hardness of 41.5 HRC is moderate for a hardfacing alloy; high-chromium types typically reach 55-65 HRC.

Microstructural Interpretation

The as-welded microstructure is likely a mixture of martensite and bainite, with some retained austenite. The fine grain size contributes to the good combination of strength and toughness. After tempering at 500°C, the martensite decomposes into ferrite and carbides, which slightly reduces strength and toughness but increases ductility. The hardness remains relatively unchanged, which is typical for a tempering-resistant alloy.

Mechanical Property Analysis

The tensile strength of 1278.56 MPa is impressive for a surfacing deposit. This is higher than many structural steels, which indicates that the deposit is not just hard but also strong. The elongation of 7.58% and reduction of area of 42.13% show that the material has some ductility, which is important for resisting impact and fatigue.

The impact toughness of 21.47 J/cm² is moderate. For a hardfacing alloy, this is acceptable, but it is lower than what I would specify for components subject to severe impact. If the application involves hammering or shock loading, a tougher alloy with lower hardness might be more appropriate.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Where This Type of Deposit Is Used

Iron-based multi-component alloys are the workhorse of the hardfacing industry. They are used for:

In the steel pipe industry, I have specified similar alloys for the forming rolls of spiral welded pipe mills. The rolls are subject to continuous abrasion from the steel strip, and the deposit must maintain its hardness while resisting spalling. The 500°C tempering response is important because the rolls can reach temperatures of 200-300°C during continuous operation.

The Tempering Question

The paper's comparison of as-welded and tempered properties is particularly valuable. In practice, many hardfaced components are used in the as-welded condition, but some are tempered to reduce residual stress and improve dimensional stability. The finding that hardness remains stable after 500°C tempering is good news for applications where the component will see elevated temperatures.

However, I would caution that the tempering temperature must be carefully selected. If the component is tempered too high, the carbides will coarsen, and the hardness will drop. If it is tempered too low, the residual stress will not be fully relieved, and there is a risk of delayed cracking. The 500°C / 2h cycle is a reasonable choice for this alloy system.

Practical Considerations for Application

When applying this type of deposit, I have found that the following are critical:

  1. Preheat temperature. For a carbon equivalent of 0.4-0.5%, a preheat of 150-200°C is usually sufficient. Higher carbon equivalents require higher preheat.
  2. Interpass temperature. Keeping the interpass temperature below 250°C prevents excessive grain growth and maintains the fine microstructure.
  3. Post-weld treatment. If the component is large or highly restrained, stress relief at 500-600°C is recommended. This also serves as a tempering treatment.
  4. NDT after welding. PT or MT should be performed to detect surface cracks. UT may be required for thick deposits or critical components.

A Case from the Field

I recall a project where we were hardfacing the mandrel of a pipe expander. The mandrel is subject to severe abrasion and high contact pressure. We specified an iron-based multi-component alloy with a hardness of 42-46 HRC. The first mandrel lasted 18 months, which was better than the previous 12 months with a standard alloy. The improvement was attributed to the fine grain structure and the good combination of hardness and toughness.

However, we also had a failure with a similar alloy on a different application. The component was a guide roller for a continuous pipe mill, and the deposit spalled after only two months. Investigation showed that the spalling was due to a combination of high contact stress and inadequate bond strength. The deposit had been applied with too much dilution, and the interface was weak. We corrected the process parameters and the problem was resolved.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that are relevant to my practice:

  1. What is the optimal hardness for a given application? The paper shows 41.5 HRC, but some applications require 55+ HRC. The choice depends on the wear mechanism. For abrasive wear, higher hardness is better. For impact wear, a lower hardness with higher toughness is preferred.
  2. How does the deposit respond to post-weld heat treatment? The paper shows that 500°C tempering has little effect on hardness. This is a useful data point, but I would want to know the response at higher temperatures, such as 600°C or 650°C, where carbide coarsening becomes more significant.
  3. What is the fatigue behavior of the deposit? The paper does not address fatigue, but for components subject to cyclic loading, this is critical. I have seen hardfaced rolls fail by fatigue cracking at the interface between the deposit and the base metal.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a solid data set for engineers who need to specify iron-based multi-component alloy surfacing. The combination of hardness, strength, and toughness is well balanced for many applications. The tempering response is favorable, which means the deposit can be used in service temperatures up to 500°C without significant loss of properties.

For the practicing engineer, the key takeaway is that the deposit properties are not just a function of the consumable composition; they are also a function of the welding process and the post-weld treatment. The paper's data should be used as a starting point, but a trial on the actual component is essential to verify that the properties meet the service requirements.

Conclusion

The iron-based multi-component alloy surfacing layer described in this paper offers a good balance of hardness, strength, and toughness for moderate wear applications. The as-welded hardness of 41.5 HRC and tensile strength of 1278.56 MPa are impressive, and the stability after 500°C tempering is a valuable characteristic. In my experience, this type of alloy is a reliable choice for rolls, guides, and other components that see abrasive wear without severe impact. However, the success of the application depends on proper process control, including preheat, interpass temperature, and post-weld treatment. I would advise any engineer to verify the deposit properties on a sample before committing to a large production run. The cost of a failed component is far greater than the cost of a thorough qualification.