Cladding 347 Stainless Steel with Alloy 690: A Practical Study of Electrochemical Corrosion in the Fusion Zone
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Chen Feng and colleagues from Lanzhou University of Technology and AT&M investigates the electrochemical corrosion behaviour of Alloy 690 (nickel-based) weld overlay on 347 stainless steel substrate. Using TIG (GTAW) surfacing, they prepared samples of the 347 base metal, the 690 overlay, and the dissimilar joint, then tested them in 3.5% NaCl solution at room temperature using electrochemical techniques. The results are stark and directly relevant to anyone who has ever specified a corrosion-resistant overlay for a pressure vessel, a reactor nozzle, or a pipe fitting that must survive a chloride-laden service environment.
The headline numbers deserve attention. The corrosion rate of the 347 substrate was approximately 8.4 times that of the 690 overlay. The weld joint region, however, was the worst performer of all, with a corrosion rate roughly 11.8 times that of the overlay itself. This is a critical finding. The overlay is doing its job, but the transition zone is undoing it.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The Dilution Problem
The authors attribute the accelerated corrosion at the joint to dilution of chromium in the substrate near the fusion boundary. When the 690 filler metal melts and mixes with the 347 base metal, the chromium content in the dilution zone is pulled down from the high levels in both parent materials to an intermediate value. In a chloride environment, this chromium-depleted zone becomes the weak link. The passive film that normally protects stainless steel and nickel alloys cannot form as effectively in this transition band.
From my years on the plant floor, this is the classic problem with dissimilar metal overlays. The weld procedure qualification might pass on bend tests and hardness surveys, but the real question is whether the dilution zone can hold up in service. I have seen vessel nozzles fail after two years of service because the overlay was applied with excessive heat input, producing a dilution zone that was wide enough to become a preferential corrosion path.
Microstructural Evidence
The SEM and EDS analysis in the paper shows the fusion zone microstructure and composition gradients. The authors clearly document the chromium dilution effect. The optical microscopy of corroded surfaces shows the attack concentrated at the fusion boundary, confirming the electrochemical measurements. This is a textbook example of galvanic coupling between dissimilar alloys, compounded by compositional gradients that destroy the protective passive layer.
Process and Standards Analysis
What the Standards Do and Do Not Say
ASME B31.3 and the various vessel codes (ASME Section VIII, for instance) require corrosion testing for overlay applications in many services, but they do not always mandate a specific minimum dilution limit. The practical guidance is often left to the fabricator. API 5LD, which covers CRA clad or lined pipe, is more explicit about chemical composition limits in the clad layer, but even there, the transition zone is not always given the attention it deserves.
The table below summarises the typical composition requirements for the overlay and the practical implications of dilution.
| Parameter | Alloy 690 Overlay (Typical) | Dilution Zone (Measured in Study) | Practical Implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chromium (Cr) | 27-31% | Reduced by 5-15% relative to nominal | Passive film formation compromised |
| Nickel (Ni) | 58% min | Reduced, Fe content increases | Galvanic potential shifts |
| Iron (Fe) | 7-11% | Increases significantly | Corrosion resistance drops |
| Corrosion Rate (3.5% NaCl) | Baseline (1x) | 11.8x overlay | Premature failure risk in service |
Controlling Dilution in Practice
The paper does not discuss process parameters in detail, but the lesson is clear. To minimise dilution, the welder must use the lowest practical heat input that still achieves good fusion and bonding. This means:
- Use the smallest electrode diameter that can carry the required current.
- Use stringer beads rather than weave beads where possible.
- Limit interpass temperature to prevent excessive heat build-up.
- Consider multiple thin layers rather than one thick pass, so that each subsequent layer remelts only a thin band of the previous one.
- For critical applications, the first layer should be applied with a higher-nickel filler to compensate for dilution.
In my experience, a two-layer or three-layer overlay is often the answer. The first layer takes the dilution hit, and the second and third layers are essentially pure overlay chemistry. The problem is that many fabricators try to save money by applying a single layer, and that is where the trouble starts.
Integration with Engineering Practice
A Case from the Field
I recall a job where a client specified Alloy 690 overlay on 347 stainless steel pipe fittings for a high-temperature, chloride-containing process stream. The overlay was applied in a single layer by a subcontractor who claimed it met the chemical composition requirements. The corrosion test on a sample coupon passed, but the actual fitting failed after eighteen months of service. The failure was at the fusion boundary, exactly as this paper predicts.
When we investigated, we found that the subcontractor had used a high-current, high-deposition process to speed up production. The dilution zone was over 1.5 mm wide, and the chromium content in that zone had dropped below the threshold needed for stable passivation. The client had to replace all the fittings and re-specify a two-layer overlay with strict heat input control. The lesson cost them a significant amount of money and several weeks of downtime.
What This Means for Procurement and Inspection
If you are specifying an overlay for a chloride service, do not rely solely on the chemical composition of the weld metal. You must specify:
- Maximum heat input.
- Maximum interpass temperature.
- Minimum number of layers (typically two, sometimes three).
- A requirement for corrosion testing on a mock-up that includes the fusion zone, not just the overlay surface.
- A requirement for dilution measurement, either by EDS line scan across the fusion boundary or by chemical analysis of a cross-section.
The paper's finding that the joint is 11.8 times worse than the overlay is a wake-up call. If your specification only tests the overlay surface, you are not testing the weakest link.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Does the Dilution Zone Corrode Faster Than the Base Metal?
This is the counterintuitive result that deserves attention. The 347 base metal corrodes at 8.4 times the overlay rate, but the joint corrodes at 11.8 times. If dilution simply produced a material intermediate between the two, one would expect a corrosion rate between 1x and 8.4x. The fact that it is worse than both suggests a different mechanism.
The likely explanation is that the dilution zone has a composition that falls in a "valley" of corrosion resistance. For Fe-Cr-Ni alloys, there is a well-known minimum in pitting resistance when the chromium and nickel contents are in a certain intermediate range. The dilution zone may also have a microstructure that is more susceptible to attack, such as a partially recrystallised region or a zone with carbide precipitation.
The Role of Carbide Precipitation
In the 347 alloy, niobium is added to stabilise carbon and prevent chromium carbide precipitation. However, in the dilution zone, the niobium content may be insufficient to fully stabilise the carbon, leading to chromium carbide formation at the grain boundaries. This would create a sensitised zone that is highly susceptible to intergranular corrosion in chloride environments.
This is a hypothesis that the paper does not fully explore, but it is consistent with the observed behaviour. The practical implication is that post-weld heat treatment may be necessary in some cases to redistribute chromium, although this is not always feasible for large or complex components.
Study Insights and Implications
The Overlay Is Not the Weak Link; the Transition Is
The most important insight from this paper is that the corrosion performance of an overlay system is not determined by the overlay itself, but by the transition zone. This is a lesson that many engineers learn the hard way. You can have the best overlay material in the world, but if the dilution zone is not controlled, the component will fail prematurely.
Design for Corrosion, Not Just for Strength
In my experience, too many designs focus on mechanical properties and overlook corrosion. The weld procedure qualification might test tensile strength, impact toughness, and hardness, but if the service environment is corrosive, these tests are not sufficient. You need to test the actual corrosion behaviour of the joint, including the fusion zone.
The Economics of Dilution Control
There is a cost to controlling dilution. Multiple layers mean more weld metal, more time, and more expense. But the cost of failure is far higher. A single fitting that fails in service can cost more than the entire batch of fittings that were properly overlaid. The paper provides the technical justification for spending the extra money.
Reference Value and Outlook
What This Paper Adds to the Literature
This paper is a valuable contribution because it quantifies the corrosion behaviour of the dissimilar joint, not just the individual materials. Many studies look at the overlay or the substrate in isolation, but the joint is where the real action happens. The authors have done the industry a service by highlighting this gap.
Where Further Work Is Needed
Future research should focus on:
- The effect of different welding processes (e.g., laser cladding, plasma transferred arc) on dilution and corrosion resistance.
- The role of post-weld heat treatment in restoring corrosion resistance in the dilution zone.
- The long-term behaviour of these joints in real service environments, including temperature effects and cyclic loading.
- The development of predictive models that can estimate dilution and corrosion performance from process parameters.
Practical Recommendations
Based on this study and my own experience, I would recommend the following for any overlay application in chloride service:
- Specify a minimum of two layers of overlay.
- Limit heat input to the minimum required for sound fusion.
- Use EDS or equivalent to measure dilution on a qualification coupon.
- Perform corrosion testing that includes the fusion zone.
- Consider the use of a buttering layer with a higher-nickel filler for the first pass.
Concluding Summary
This paper from the Lanzhou University of Technology team is a practical reminder that in corrosion-resistant overlay applications, the transition zone is the critical region. The finding that the joint corrodes at 11.8 times the rate of the overlay should be a wake-up call for every engineer who specifies dissimilar metal overlays. The dilution of chromium at the fusion boundary is the root cause, and the only effective countermeasure is strict control of heat input and the use of multiple layers. In my thirty years in this industry, I have seen too many failures caused by exactly this problem. The paper gives us the data to justify the extra cost of doing it right. If you are specifying an overlay for a chloride service, take this study seriously and design for the transition zone, not just the overlay surface. The cost of failure is far higher than the cost of proper dilution control. This is a lesson I have learned the hard way, and I am glad to see it documented in the literature.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd