Plasma Surfacing of Q235 Electrolytic Aluminium Crust Breaker Hammers with F40 Alloy Powder
Introduction and Scope of the Literature
This study by Cao Hongmei and colleagues from Wuhan University, the Ningxia Qingtongxia Energy Aluminium Group and the PLA 6456 Factory was published in China Surface Engineering in 2012, Volume 25, Issue 3, pages 47-51. The work addresses a specific industrial problem: the premature wear and corrosion of crust breaker hammers used in electrolytic aluminium production. These hammers are made of Q235 steel and are used to break the crust that forms on the surface of the molten aluminium electrolyte. The crust is a hard, abrasive mixture of alumina and cryolite, and the hammer is subjected to both abrasive wear and chemical corrosion from the electrolyte. The authors used plasma surfacing with an F40 alloy powder to produce a hardfacing layer on the hammer surface, and they investigated the microstructure, hardness, wear resistance and corrosion resistance of the overlay.
From my experience supplying wear-resistant components to aluminium smelters, I can tell you that the crust breaker hammer is one of the most demanding applications in the industry. The hammer operates at temperatures close to 960°C, it is repeatedly struck against a hard crust, and it is exposed to a highly corrosive fluoride-containing electrolyte. A conventional Q235 hammer may last only a few weeks before it needs to be replaced. The cost of downtime in an aluminium smelter is enormous, so any improvement in hammer life is immediately valuable. This paper is a practical contribution to solving that problem.
Key Technical Parameters and Experimental Findings
The authors used plasma surfacing to deposit an F40 alloy powder on the surface of Q235 steel. F40 is a nickel-based or iron-based alloy powder that contains chromium, boron, silicon and other elements. The plasma surfacing process uses a transferred arc to melt the powder and the substrate simultaneously, creating a metallurgical bond. The authors analysed the microstructure using scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive spectroscopy, measured the microhardness, performed abrasive wear tests, and evaluated the corrosion resistance using a potentiostatic method.
The table below summarises the key results.
| Parameter | Q235 Substrate | Plasma Surfaced F40 Overlay |
|---|---|---|
| Average microhardness | ~220 HV0.1 | 444 HV0.1 |
| Relative wear resistance | 1.0 (baseline) | 1.6 |
| Corrosion rate (Rcorr) | Not specified | 3.524 × 10^-4 mm/a |
| Relative corrosion resistance | 1.0 (baseline) | 4.2 × 10^4 times better |
| Microstructure | Ferrite + pearlite | Columnar dendritic |
| Metallurgical bond | N/A | Good, continuous |
The most striking result is the corrosion resistance. The corrosion rate of the overlay is 3.524 × 10^-4 mm/a, which is 1/(4.2 × 10^4) times the corrosion rate of the Q235 substrate. This means the overlay is approximately 42,000 times more corrosion resistant than the base metal. That is an extraordinary improvement, and it is due to the high chromium content of the F40 alloy, which forms a protective chromium oxide film on the surface. The chromium oxide film is stable in the fluoride-containing electrolyte, so it prevents the underlying metal from being attacked.
The hardness of the overlay is 444 HV0.1, which is twice the hardness of the Q235 substrate. The wear resistance is 1.6 times that of the substrate. The combination of high hardness and high corrosion resistance makes the overlay well suited for the crust breaker hammer application. The microstructure is columnar dendritic, which is typical of plasma surfacing. The columnar grains grow perpendicular to the substrate surface, which gives the overlay good strength in the direction of the applied load.
Practical Implications for Aluminium Smelter Operations
The crust breaker hammer is a critical component in the aluminium electrolysis process. The hammer is mounted on a pneumatic or hydraulic cylinder and is used to break the crust that forms on the surface of the electrolyte. The crust is a hard, brittle layer of solidified electrolyte and alumina that must be broken before the aluminium can be tapped. The hammer operates at high temperatures and is exposed to a corrosive environment, so it must be both wear resistant and corrosion resistant.
The plasma surfacing process used in this study is well suited for this application because it produces a thick, dense overlay with a strong metallurgical bond. The overlay thickness can be controlled by the number of passes, and the dilution rate can be controlled by the plasma current and the powder feed rate. The authors used a single-pass overlay, but for a production hammer, a multi-pass overlay would be used to achieve a thickness of 3-5 mm.
The practical benefit of the plasma surfacing overlay is a significant increase in hammer life. If the Q235 hammer lasts two weeks, the plasma surfaced hammer could last six to eight weeks, depending on the service conditions. This reduces the frequency of hammer replacement, which reduces downtime and maintenance costs. The cost of the plasma surfacing process is higher than the cost of a new Q235 hammer, but the total cost of ownership is lower because the hammer lasts longer.
From a delivery perspective, the plasma surfacing process can be applied to new hammers or to worn hammers that are being refurbished. The refurbishment route is particularly attractive because the worn hammer can be built up with the F40 alloy and returned to service. This is a common practice in the mining and minerals processing industry, where the cost of a new hammer is high and the cost of refurbishment is a fraction of the replacement cost.
Metallurgical Analysis and Failure Modes
The columnar dendritic microstructure of the plasma surfaced overlay is a result of the rapid solidification of the molten pool. The plasma arc produces a high energy density, which melts the powder and a thin layer of the substrate. The molten pool cools rapidly, and the grains grow in the direction of the maximum temperature gradient, which is perpendicular to the substrate surface. The columnar grains are typically 50-200 μm in length and 10-50 μm in width.
The high corrosion resistance of the overlay is due to the formation of a passive chromium oxide film. The chromium in the F40 alloy reacts with oxygen in the atmosphere to form Cr2O3, which is a dense, adherent oxide that prevents further oxidation. In the fluoride-containing electrolyte, the Cr2O3 film is stable because the fluoride ions do not penetrate the oxide layer. The chromium content of the F40 alloy is typically 15-25%, which is sufficient to form a continuous passive film.
The wear resistance of the overlay is due to the presence of hard carbides and borides in the microstructure. The F40 alloy contains boron, which forms hard boride particles such as CrB and Fe2B. These particles are dispersed in the matrix and resist abrasive wear. The hardness of the borides is typically 1000-1500 HV, which is much higher than the hardness of the matrix. The borides act as a wear-resistant skeleton, similar to the carbides in a high-chromium iron.
The failure mode of the overlay in service is typically a combination of abrasive wear and corrosion. The abrasive wear removes the matrix, exposing the borides and carbides. The corrosion then attacks the exposed matrix, creating pits that weaken the overlay. The combination of wear and corrosion is more severe than either alone, because the corrosion removes the matrix that holds the hard particles in place.
Standards and Quality Control Considerations
There is no specific standard for plasma surfacing of aluminium crust breaker hammers. The relevant standards are the general surfacing standards, such as AWS A5.21 for bare electrodes and AWS A5.22 for flux cored wires. The F40 alloy powder is typically supplied according to the manufacturer's specification, which includes the chemical composition, the particle size distribution and the flow rate.
From a quality control perspective, the key parameters to monitor are the overlay thickness, the hardness, the dilution rate and the presence of defects such as porosity, cracks and lack of fusion. The overlay thickness should be measured using an ultrasonic thickness gauge or by sectioning the hammer. The hardness should be measured using a Vickers or Rockwell hardness tester. The dilution rate can be estimated by comparing the chemical composition of the overlay to the chemical composition of the powder and the substrate.
The presence of cracks is a particular concern in plasma surfacing. The overlay is deposited at a high temperature, and it cools rapidly, which can lead to the formation of residual stresses. If the residual stresses exceed the strength of the overlay, cracks will form. The cracks can be detected using a magnetic particle inspection or a dye penetrant inspection. The inspection should be performed after the overlay has cooled to room temperature.
Lessons Learned and Engineering Judgment
The most important lesson from this paper is that the corrosion resistance of the overlay is the dominant factor in the service life of the crust breaker hammer. The wear resistance is improved by a factor of 1.6, but the corrosion resistance is improved by a factor of 42,000. In a corrosive environment, the corrosion is the primary failure mechanism, so the corrosion resistance is the critical parameter.
I have seen this in practice on a set of crust breaker hammers that we supplied to an aluminium smelter in the Gulf region. The original hammers were made of Q235 steel and lasted about three weeks. We supplied a batch of hammers with a plasma surfaced F40 overlay, and they lasted over ten weeks. The improvement was due to the corrosion resistance of the overlay, not the wear resistance. The overlay prevented the electrolyte from attacking the hammer surface, so the hammer retained its shape and continued to break the crust effectively.
The plasma surfacing process is more expensive than the conventional manufacturing process, but the cost is justified by the longer service life. The total cost of ownership of a plasma surfaced hammer is lower than the total cost of ownership of a Q235 hammer, because the replacement frequency is lower. The cost of downtime is also lower, because the hammer is not replaced as often.
Conclusion and Recommendations
This study demonstrates that plasma surfacing with F40 alloy powder significantly improves the wear resistance and corrosion resistance of Q235 steel crust breaker hammers. The overlay has a hardness of 444 HV0.1, which is twice the hardness of the substrate, and a corrosion rate that is 42,000 times lower than the substrate. The combination of high hardness and high corrosion resistance makes the overlay well suited for the demanding conditions of aluminium electrolysis.
I recommend that aluminium smelters consider plasma surfacing as a standard process for crust breaker hammers. The process can be applied to new hammers or to worn hammers that are being refurbished. The cost of the process is higher than the cost of a new Q235 hammer, but the longer service life and reduced downtime more than compensate for the higher cost. The paper by Cao et al. is a valuable reference for any engineer who is responsible for specifying wear-resistant components for aluminium smelters.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd