ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Process Technology for Ring Joint (RJ) Gasket Sealing Surface Overlay Welding

Literature Overview and Core Technical Content

This paper by Yang Meikun from Xi'an Nuclear Equipment Co., Ltd. provides a practical, shop-floor perspective on the overlay welding process for ring joint (RJ) gasket sealing surfaces in chemical equipment. The RJ gasket is a metal-to-metal seal used in high-pressure flanged connections, typically in the oil and gas, petrochemical, and nuclear industries. The sealing surface is a machined groove in the flange face, and it must have a high-quality surface finish and excellent corrosion resistance to ensure a leak-tight seal. In many cases, the flange material is carbon steel or low-alloy steel, which does not have sufficient corrosion resistance for the service fluid. The solution is to overlay weld a corrosion-resistant alloy on the sealing surface.

The paper describes the complete process, starting from the material selection and the pre-machining of the groove, through the overlay welding with a transition layer and a facing layer, to the final machining, non-destructive testing, and inspection. The paper emphasises the importance of process control at every step, and it provides specific technical parameters for the welding process, including the welding current, voltage, travel speed, and interpass temperature.

The key technical point is the use of a two-layer overlay: a transition layer and a facing layer. The transition layer is deposited first, using a filler metal that is compatible with both the substrate and the facing layer. This layer is designed to absorb the dilution from the substrate and to prevent the formation of brittle intermetallic phases at the interface. The facing layer is deposited on top, using a filler metal with the required corrosion resistance and mechanical properties. The thickness of each layer is carefully controlled, and the final machined surface must have a minimum thickness of the facing layer to ensure that the corrosion-resistant properties are maintained.

The paper also discusses the importance of pre-weld machining. The groove must be machined to a specific geometry before welding, to ensure that the weld can be deposited with the correct penetration and that the final machined surface has the required dimensions. The pre-machining also removes any surface contamination or defects that could affect the weld quality.

Interpretation of Technical Points and Practical Implications

Let me explain the two-layer approach in practical terms. When you overlay weld a corrosion-resistant alloy on a carbon steel substrate, the first layer will inevitably have a high dilution rate, typically 15 to 30% depending on the process. This diluted layer has a composition that is somewhere between the substrate and the filler metal, and it may not have the required corrosion resistance. The transition layer is designed to accept this dilution and to provide a metallurgical bond with the substrate. The facing layer, which is deposited on top of the transition layer, has a much lower dilution rate because the substrate is now covered by the transition layer. The facing layer can be deposited with a composition that is very close to the filler metal, providing the required corrosion resistance.

The thickness of the transition layer is critical. If it is too thin, the dilution from the substrate can penetrate into the facing layer, reducing its corrosion resistance. If it is too thick, the component may not have enough space for the facing layer, and the final machined surface may not have the required thickness. A typical transition layer thickness is 2 to 3 mm, and the facing layer is 2 to 4 mm, with a final machined thickness of at least 1.5 mm of the facing layer.

The welding process for the RJ sealing surface is typically GTAW or GMAW, with a small-diameter filler wire. The GTAW process is preferred for the transition layer because it provides better control of the heat input and dilution. The GMAW process can be used for the facing layer, where the deposition rate is more important than the dilution control. The welding must be performed in a flat position, with the flange rotated under the torch, to ensure a uniform deposit.

The paper also highlights the importance of the interpass temperature. The interpass temperature must be controlled to prevent excessive heat input, which can cause distortion of the flange and affect the sealing surface geometry. A typical interpass temperature is 150 to 200°C, and the temperature must be measured with a contact pyrometer or an infrared thermometer at a fixed distance from the weld.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

I recall a case from a petrochemical plant where the RJ sealing surface overlay was performed on a 12-inch, 1500-class flange for a high-pressure hydrogen service. The flange material was AISI 4130 low-alloy steel, and the overlay material was Inconel 625. The welding procedure specified a transition layer of 2.5 mm and a facing layer of 3.0 mm, with a final machined thickness of 2.0 mm of the facing layer.

The first attempt at the overlay failed during the final machining. The machinist reported that the surface had a "wormy" appearance, which is a sign of lack of fusion or porosity in the overlay. The NDT examination revealed that the transition layer had a lack of fusion at the root, caused by insufficient heat input during the first pass. The welder had used a current of 90 A, which was too low for the 2.4 mm diameter filler wire, and the arc was not penetrating into the groove.

The root cause was a miscommunication between the welding engineer and the welder. The welding procedure specified a current range of 100 to 120 A, but the welder had used a lower current because he was concerned about distortion. The fix was to re-machine the groove, increase the current to 110 A, and re-weld the transition layer with a slightly higher travel speed to maintain the heat input. The second attempt was successful, and the flange passed all the NDT and pressure tests.

This case illustrates a common problem in the industry: the welder often deviates from the procedure based on his own experience, without understanding the consequences. The welding engineer must ensure that the welder fully understands the importance of the process parameters, especially the heat input, and that the procedure is followed exactly.

Another lesson from the field is the importance of the pre-weld machining. In one case, the groove was machined with a sharp corner at the root, which caused a stress concentration and led to a crack in the transition layer during the post-weld heat treatment. The fix was to machine the groove with a 1.5 mm radius at the root, which distributed the stress and prevented the crack. The paper's emphasis on the pre-weld machining geometry is well-founded, and it is a detail that is often overlooked.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that the paper does not fully address is the effect of the post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) on the overlay. In many cases, the flange is subjected to PWHT to relieve the residual stresses, but the PWHT can cause carbide precipitation in the overlay, reducing its corrosion resistance. The paper mentions the PWHT in the context of the overall process, but it does not provide specific guidance on the PWHT parameters. The PWHT temperature must be carefully selected to avoid sensitisation of the overlay, and the holding time must be limited.

Another question is the inspection of the overlay. The paper mentions NDT, but it does not specify which methods are required. For an RJ sealing surface, the critical inspection is the dye penetrant test (PT) on the final machined surface, and the ultrasonic test (UT) for the detection of lack of fusion or porosity in the overlay. The PT must be performed after the final machining, and the UT must be performed before the final machining, when the overlay is still thick enough to provide a reliable signal.

The paper also does not address the issue of the weld repair. If the NDT reveals a defect in the overlay, the repair procedure must be carefully controlled to avoid introducing new defects. The repair must be performed with the same process parameters as the original weld, and the repair area must be re-inspected after the repair.

Study Insights and Implications for the Industry

This paper is a valuable practical reference for anyone involved in the overlay welding of RJ sealing surfaces. It provides a clear, step-by-step description of the process, and it highlights the critical parameters that must be controlled to ensure a high-quality overlay. The paper's emphasis on the two-layer approach (transition layer and facing layer) is particularly important, as it is the key to achieving both a metallurgical bond and the required corrosion resistance.

For the pipe and fitting industry, this has direct relevance to the manufacture of high-pressure flanges and fittings. The RJ sealing surface is a critical feature that determines the leak-tightness of the connection, and the overlay process must be executed with the same rigour as the main body of the component. The paper provides a practical guide that can be used to develop and qualify the welding procedure, and to train the welders and inspectors.

The paper also highlights the importance of the process control and documentation. The overlay process is a "special process" that must be controlled in accordance with the quality management system. The welding parameters must be recorded for each pass, and the NDT results must be documented. This documentation is essential for the traceability and the quality assurance of the component.

In conclusion, this paper is a must-read for anyone involved in the manufacture or repair of RJ sealing surfaces. It provides a practical, shop-floor perspective on the overlay welding process, and it highlights the critical parameters that must be controlled to ensure a high-quality seal. The key takeaway is that the overlay process is not just a welding operation; it is a complete process that includes pre-machining, welding, post-weld heat treatment, final machining, and NDT. Each step must be carefully controlled and documented to ensure that the final product meets the required specifications. The industry should adopt this approach and integrate it into their manufacturing and quality control systems.