ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Temperature Effects on Microstructure and Properties of Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 Hardfacing Layers

Literature Overview and Study Context

This recent 2024 paper from Hot Working Technology addresses a question that is directly relevant to high-temperature service applications: what happens to Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 hardfacing layers when they are exposed to elevated temperatures? The authors, Yu Shiqing, Tian Yun, Zheng Bowen, Lin Xuejian, Yuan Xiaoguang, and Huang Hongjun, from Shenyang University of Technology and Shenyang Blower Works Group Nuclear Pump Co., Ltd., used plasma transfer arc (PTA) welding to deposit both alloys on 304H stainless steel, then exposed them to temperatures of 550-650°C and evaluated the resulting microstructure and properties.

The study is funded by the Liaoning Provincial Education Department (LJKZ0122), which suggests it is part of a broader research program on high-temperature materials. The choice of 304H stainless steel as the substrate is significant because it is a common material for high-temperature service, and the temperature range of 550-650°C is typical of many industrial applications, including power generation and chemical processing.

Core Technical Findings and Interpretation

The microstructural analysis reveals that both Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 hardfacing layers have a similar structure: planar crystals at the fusion line, columnar crystals in the middle, and equiaxed crystals at the top. This is the typical solidification structure of a PTA weld overlay, and it reflects the heat flow direction during solidification.

As the temperature increases from room temperature to 650°C, the dendrite spacing in both alloys increases slightly, but there is no significant elemental diffusion at the fusion line. This indicates that both alloys have good microstructural stability at these temperatures. The absence of diffusion is important because it means the hardfacing layer will not degrade by interdiffusion with the substrate, which could cause the formation of brittle intermetallic phases.

The hardness measurements show that as-deposited Stellite 6 has a microhardness of 463 HV0.3, while as-deposited Stellite 21 has a microhardness of 365 HV0.3. After exposure to elevated temperatures, both alloys show a slight decrease in hardness. This is expected, as high temperatures can cause recovery and recrystallization of the microstructure, reducing the dislocation density and softening the material.

The corrosion test results are particularly interesting. The as-deposited Stellite 6 has a corrosion current density of 1.312 μA/cm², while Stellite 21 has a much higher value of 10.848 μA/cm². This indicates that Stellite 6 has significantly better corrosion resistance than Stellite 21 in the test environment. After exposure to elevated temperatures, both alloys show a slight increase in corrosion current density, indicating a small decrease in corrosion resistance.

Alloy As-Deposited Hardness (HV0.3) Hardness After 650°C As-Deposited Corrosion Current Density (μA/cm²) Corrosion Current Density After 650°C
Stellite 6 463 Slightly lower 1.312 Slightly higher
Stellite 21 365 Slightly lower 10.848 Slightly higher

Engineering Practice Implications

The difference in hardness between Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 is significant. Stellite 6 is a carbon-rich alloy with a high volume fraction of hard carbides, which gives it excellent wear resistance. Stellite 21 is a lower-carbon alloy with more molybdenum, which gives it better toughness and resistance to thermal fatigue, but at the cost of lower hardness.

In high-temperature service, the choice between these two alloys depends on the specific application. If wear resistance is the primary concern, Stellite 6 is the better choice. If thermal fatigue or impact resistance is more important, Stellite 21 may be preferred. The corrosion data suggest that Stellite 6 also has better corrosion resistance, which gives it an additional advantage in corrosive environments.

The stability of the microstructure at 550-650°C is a key finding. It means that both alloys can be used in high-temperature service without significant degradation of the hardfacing layer. The slight decrease in hardness and increase in corrosion current density are not alarming, and both alloys maintain their integrity at these temperatures.

For the welding engineer, the practical implication is that PTA welding is a suitable process for applying these alloys to 304H stainless steel. The fusion line is sound, the microstructure is consistent, and the properties are acceptable for high-temperature service. The process parameters must be carefully controlled to avoid defects such as porosity, lack of fusion, or excessive dilution.

Study Insights and Reflections

This paper provides valuable data on the high-temperature behavior of two commonly used Co-based hardfacing alloys. The comparison between Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 is particularly useful, as it allows engineers to make an informed choice based on the specific service requirements.

I would note, however, that the study only evaluates temperatures up to 650°C. Many high-temperature applications, such as gas turbine components or furnace parts, operate at much higher temperatures. The behavior of these alloys at 800°C or 1000°C may be quite different, and the microstructural stability observed at 650°C may not hold at higher temperatures.

The corrosion testing was done in a specific electrolyte, and the results may not be directly applicable to all service environments. The corrosion current density is a useful comparative measure, but it does not provide information about the corrosion mechanism or the long-term corrosion behavior.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study is a valuable contribution to the understanding of Co-based hardfacing alloys for high-temperature service. It provides quantitative data on the microstructure, hardness, and corrosion resistance of Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 after exposure to 550-650°C, and it confirms that both alloys have good stability in this temperature range.

For future work, it would be valuable to extend the study to higher temperatures, to evaluate the wear resistance of the alloys after high-temperature exposure, and to investigate the long-term microstructural evolution. The combination of hardness, corrosion, and wear data would provide a more complete picture of the alloys' performance in high-temperature service.

The practical takeaway for the engineer is that Stellite 6 and Stellite 21 are both viable choices for high-temperature hardfacing applications up to 650°C, but the choice between them should be based on the specific service requirements, including wear, corrosion, and thermal fatigue.