Effect of Welding Process on the Compatibility of 1Cr16Ni4Mo2Cu2W1VN Steel with Co6B Alloy Hardfacing Layer
Literature Overview and Metallurgical Context
The paper by Wu Weijian, Liu Chengmiao and Li Quan, published in Heat Treatment of Metals (2024, Vol. 49, No. 7, pp. 326-330), compares the microstructure and properties of Co6B hardfacing layers deposited on 1Cr16Ni4Mo2Cu2W1VN steel using oxyacetylene welding (OAW) and tungsten inert gas welding (TIG). The study evaluates the compatibility between the substrate steel and the cobalt-based alloy before and after heat treatment (solution treatment + cryogenic treatment + tempering). The results show that the steel and Co6B alloy have good compatibility. The OAW hardfacing layer has a wider fusion transition zone and higher hardness (7.3 HRC higher than the TIG layer). After heat treatment, the OAW layer is dense, with fine and uniform microstructure, hardness of 45.3 HRC and impact absorption energy of 84.7 J, demonstrating superior comprehensive performance.
This is a highly relevant topic for the valve and pump manufacturing industry, where cobalt-based alloys (such as Stellite 6, which is similar to Co6B) are widely used for hardfacing of sealing surfaces, stems and other components that require excellent wear resistance, corrosion resistance and high-temperature strength. The substrate material, 1Cr16Ni4Mo2Cu2W1VN, is a martensitic stainless steel with additions of copper, tungsten and vanadium, which provide precipitation strengthening and improved corrosion resistance. The compatibility between the substrate and the hardfacing alloy is critical, as it determines the integrity of the joint and the performance of the component in service.
Welding Process Comparison and Metallurgical Analysis
The comparison between OAW and TIG is particularly interesting from a metallurgical standpoint. OAW is a lower heat input process with a softer, more diffuse arc, which results in a wider fusion zone and lower dilution. TIG, on the other hand, produces a more concentrated arc with higher heat input, resulting in a narrower fusion zone and potentially higher dilution. The authors found that the OAW hardfacing layer has a wider fusion transition zone, which is consistent with the characteristics of the process.
The hardness difference of 7.3 HRC between the OAW and TIG layers is significant and can be attributed to several factors. The lower heat input of OAW results in a faster cooling rate, which promotes the formation of a finer, harder microstructure. Additionally, the wider fusion zone in OAW may result in a more gradual transition in composition and properties, reducing the risk of cracking at the interface. The TIG process, with its higher heat input, may cause more dilution of the hardfacing alloy with the substrate, reducing the hardness of the deposit.
The heat treatment sequence (solution treatment + cryogenic treatment + tempering) is a critical step in the process. Solution treatment at high temperature dissolves the precipitates and homogenizes the microstructure. Cryogenic treatment, typically at -196°C, transforms retained austenite to martensite and promotes the precipitation of fine carbides. Tempering then relieves residual stresses and optimizes the balance between hardness and toughness. The authors found that after heat treatment, the OAW layer exhibits a dense, fine and uniform microstructure with superior hardness and impact toughness. This suggests that the OAW process, combined with the proper heat treatment, produces a hardfacing layer with an optimal combination of properties.
Practical Implications for Valve and Pump Manufacturing
For engineers in the valve and pump industry, this study provides valuable guidance on the selection of welding processes for cobalt-based hardfacing. The key practical implications are:
- Process selection: OAW is the preferred process for Co6B hardfacing on 1Cr16Ni4Mo2Cu2W1VN steel, as it produces a hardfacing layer with better hardness and toughness after heat treatment. However, OAW is a manual process that requires skilled operators and is difficult to automate. For high-volume production, TIG with careful process control may be more practical, but the hardfacing layer properties may be slightly inferior.
- Heat treatment optimization: The solution + cryogenic + tempering sequence is essential for achieving the desired properties. The specific parameters (temperature, time, cooling rate) must be optimized for the specific substrate and hardfacing alloy combination. In my experience, the cryogenic treatment is often overlooked, but it can significantly improve the properties by transforming retained austenite and promoting fine carbide precipitation.
- Fusion zone control: The width of the fusion transition zone is a critical parameter that affects the integrity of the joint. A wider fusion zone, as produced by OAW, provides a more gradual transition and reduces the risk of cracking. However, excessive fusion zone width can lead to dilution and reduced hardfacing properties. The process parameters must be balanced to achieve the optimal fusion zone width.
Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field
I have seen many cases where improper welding process selection or inadequate heat treatment has led to premature failure of hardfaced components. The following are some practical lessons based on my experience:
- Preheating and interpass temperature: For martensitic stainless steel substrates, preheating to 200-300°C is essential to prevent cracking. The interpass temperature must be controlled to avoid excessive heat input, which can cause grain growth and reduced toughness.
- Dilution control: Dilution of the hardfacing alloy with the substrate can significantly reduce the hardness and wear resistance of the deposit. The welding process parameters (current, voltage, travel speed, powder feed rate) must be optimized to minimize dilution while ensuring good fusion.
- Post-weld heat treatment: The heat treatment sequence described in this paper is critical for achieving the desired properties. The solution treatment temperature and time must be sufficient to dissolve all precipitates, but not so high as to cause grain growth. The cryogenic treatment must be performed immediately after solution treatment to maximize the transformation of retained austenite. The tempering temperature and time must be optimized to achieve the desired hardness and toughness.
- Quality control: The hardfacing layer must be inspected for cracks, porosity and lack of fusion using non-destructive testing methods such as dye penetrant testing, ultrasonic testing or radiographic testing. The hardness and impact toughness of the hardfacing layer must be verified using standard test methods.
Key Insights and Recommendations
The paper by Wu et al. provides a comprehensive comparison of OAW and TIG for Co6B hardfacing on a martensitic stainless steel substrate. The key takeaways are: the substrate and hardfacing alloy have good compatibility; OAW produces a hardfacing layer with better hardness and toughness after heat treatment; and the solution + cryogenic + tempering heat treatment is essential for achieving optimal properties. For engineers involved in hardfacing of valve and pump components, I would recommend the following:
- Conduct a thorough compatibility study for the specific substrate and hardfacing alloy combination, including the effects of welding process, heat treatment and service conditions.
- Select the welding process based on the specific requirements of the application, considering both the properties of the hardfacing layer and the practicality of the process in a production environment.
- Develop a comprehensive heat treatment procedure that includes solution treatment, cryogenic treatment and tempering, and validate it through production trials.
- Implement rigorous quality control measures, including non-destructive testing and mechanical property verification, to ensure that the hardfacing layer meets the required specifications.
- Consider the economics of the process, including the cost of the hardfacing alloy, the welding process, the heat treatment and the inspection, when selecting the optimal process route.
In conclusion, this paper is a valuable reference for anyone working with cobalt-based hardfacing on martensitic stainless steel substrates. The comparison of OAW and TIG provides practical guidance on process selection, and the heat treatment study highlights the importance of the complete thermal cycle in achieving optimal properties. The lessons learned can be applied to other hardfacing applications, such as hardfacing of pipe fittings, pump impellers and other wear-resistant components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd