Tempering Response of Iron-Based Multi-Component Hardfacing Layers: Hardness Control and Service Temperature Limits
Literature Overview
This study by Ma (2011) investigates the effect of tempering treatment on the hardness of an iron-based multi-component hardfacing layer. The research is directly relevant to the steel pipe and fitting industry, where hardfaced components are often subjected to post-weld heat treatment or where the hardfacing layer must maintain its properties at elevated service temperatures. The author applies different tempering treatments to the hardfacing layer and measures the resulting hardness. The key finding is that tempering below 400°C has minimal effect on hardness, but tempering above 400°C causes the hardness to first increase and then decrease as the temperature rises. The highest hardness is achieved after tempering at 500°C for 2 hours. This behavior is characteristic of secondary hardening, where fine alloy carbides precipitate during tempering and increase the hardness, followed by over-tempering where the carbides coarsen and the hardness decreases.
Tempering Behavior Below 400°C
Below 400°C, the hardfacing layer shows negligible change in hardness after tempering. This is consistent with the behavior of most martensitic and bainitic hardfacing deposits. At temperatures below 400°C, the diffusion rates of alloying elements are too low to cause significant microstructural changes. The hardness remains essentially unchanged because the as-deposited microstructure is stable in this temperature range. This has important practical implications. If a hardfaced component is subjected to a stress-relieving treatment at temperatures below 400°C, the hardness of the hardfacing layer will be maintained. However, I would caution that stress-relieving at these temperatures may not be effective in relieving residual stresses in the hardfacing layer, particularly if the layer is thick or if the base metal has a high yield strength. In my experience, stress-relieving of hardfaced components is often a compromise between relieving residual stresses and maintaining the hardness and wear resistance of the hardfacing layer.
Tempering Behavior Above 400°C
Above 400°C, the hardness first increases and then decreases. The increase in hardness is attributed to the precipitation of fine secondary carbides, which are typically M23C6 or M7C3 type carbides that form during tempering. These carbides are coherent or semi-coherent with the matrix and cause significant lattice distortion, which increases the hardness. The maximum hardness is achieved after tempering at 500°C for 2 hours. Beyond this temperature, the carbides begin to coarsen, and the hardness decreases. The coarsening is driven by the reduction in interfacial energy, and it results in a loss of the precipitation strengthening effect. This behavior is well-known in the heat treatment of tool steels and high-speed steels, and it is encouraging to see it confirmed in a hardfacing alloy. The practical implication is that the service temperature of the hardfacing layer should be kept below approximately 500°C to maintain the maximum hardness. If the component operates at temperatures above 500°C, the hardness will decrease, and the wear resistance will be compromised.
Practical Guidance for Post-Weld Heat Treatment
| Tempering Temperature | Holding Time | Hardness Trend | Practical Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Below 400°C | Any | No significant change | Safe for stress-relieving without affecting hardness |
| 400°C to 500°C | 2 hours | Increasing | Optimal for achieving maximum hardness |
| Above 500°C | Any | Decreasing | Avoid for wear-resistant applications |
For the steel pipe and fitting industry, this information is critical for selecting post-weld heat treatment parameters for hardfaced components. If a hardfaced roll or mandrel is subjected to a stress-relieving treatment, the temperature must be carefully controlled to avoid either insufficient stress relief or excessive softening. I have seen cases where hardfaced rolls were stress-relieved at 550°C, resulting in a significant drop in hardness and a corresponding reduction in service life. The rolls had to be removed from service prematurely and re-hardfaced, which was a costly mistake. Conversely, I have also seen cases where stress-relieving was performed at too low a temperature, and the residual stresses were not fully relieved, leading to cracking during subsequent machining or in service. The optimal approach is to temper at 500°C for 2 hours, which achieves the maximum hardness while also providing some stress relief. However, the stress relief may not be complete, and additional measures such as controlled cooling or vibration stress relief may be necessary.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that this study raises is the effect of multiple tempering cycles on the hardfacing layer. In practice, hardfaced components may be tempered more than once, either intentionally or unintentionally. The first tempering cycle may cause precipitation hardening, but subsequent tempering cycles may cause over-tempering and softening. I would recommend that the number of tempering cycles be minimized and that the total tempering time be carefully controlled. Another concern is the effect of tempering on the toughness of the hardfacing layer. While the study only measures hardness, the toughness is equally important for many applications. Over-tempering may increase toughness but decrease hardness, while under-tempering may result in a hard but brittle layer. The optimal tempering condition should be determined based on the specific service requirements, balancing hardness and toughness. I have seen hardfaced components that failed by spalling because the hardfacing layer was too brittle, and the tempering treatment was not sufficient to provide adequate toughness.
Summary and Outlook
This study provides valuable guidance on the tempering behavior of iron-based multi-component hardfacing layers. The key finding is that tempering at 500°C for 2 hours achieves the maximum hardness, while tempering below 400°C has minimal effect. This information is essential for selecting post-weld heat treatment parameters and for determining the maximum service temperature of hardfaced components. For the steel pipe and fitting industry, this means that hardfaced rolls, mandrels, and other components should be tempered at 500°C to achieve optimal hardness, and their service temperature should be kept below this level. I believe that future research should focus on the effect of tempering on toughness and on the development of hardfacing alloys with a wider temperature window for optimal hardness. This would provide greater flexibility in post-weld heat treatment and in the selection of hardfacing materials for high-temperature applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd