ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Wear Resistance of Tungsten Carbide Particle-Reinforced Nickel-Based PTA Hardfacing Layers

What the Paper Really Says

This 2022 study from Zigong Great Wall Surface Engineering Technology Co., Ltd. compares three types of tungsten carbide particles used as hard phases in a nickel-based matrix, deposited by plasma transferred arc (PTA) powder hardfacing. The authors used metallographic microscopy and scanning electron microscopy to analyze the microstructure, and abrasive wear testing to evaluate the wear performance. The key findings are that spherical cast tungsten carbide suffered the most severe burn-out during deposition, coarse crystalline tungsten carbide suffered the least, and under the tested abrasive wear conditions, the spherical cast tungsten carbide deposit exhibited the best wear resistance.

This is a very practical piece of work. I have specified tungsten carbide-reinforced hardfacing for rock drill bits, excavator teeth, and crusher hammers, and the choice of carbide type is one of the most critical decisions you will make. The paper gives you a clear comparison of the three most common options.

Interpreting the Technical Points

The Three Carbide Types and Their Behavior

Carbide Type Typical Particle Size Burn-out Behavior Wear Performance
Spherical cast tungsten carbide 45-150 µm Severe burn-out, dissolution into matrix Best wear resistance despite burn-out
Coarse crystalline tungsten carbide 50-200 µm Minimal burn-out, retains angular shape Good wear resistance, but lower than spherical
Fused tungsten carbide 45-150 µm Moderate burn-out, partial dissolution Intermediate wear resistance

Why Spherical Cast Carbide Wins on Wear

The counterintuitive finding is that the carbide type with the most severe burn-out still gives the best wear resistance. The reason lies in the dissolution and reprecipitation mechanism. When spherical cast tungsten carbide partially dissolves in the nickel-based matrix, the dissolved tungsten and carbon reprecipitate as fine secondary carbides during cooling. This creates a composite microstructure with a high volume fraction of hard phases distributed uniformly throughout the matrix.

In contrast, the coarse crystalline carbide retains its original shape but has less interaction with the matrix. The interface between the carbide and the matrix is weaker, and under abrasive wear, the carbides can be pulled out of the matrix, leaving the softer matrix exposed.

Typical PTA Hardfacing Parameters for WC-Reinforced Nickel-Based Deposits

Parameter Typical Range Notes
Welding current 120-200 A Lower than for Fe-based alloys to reduce carbide burn-out
Arc voltage 22-28 V Keep stable to ensure uniform carbide distribution
Powder feed rate 30-60 g/min Higher feed rate increases carbide content
Travel speed 100-200 mm/min Faster travel reduces heat input and burn-out
Shielding gas Argon, 10-20 L/min Must be dry and clean
Carbide volume fraction 30-50% Too high leads to cracking and poor bonding

Integration with Engineering Practice

Where I Have Used This Knowledge

I have specified WC-reinforced nickel-based PTA hardfacing for:

In every case, the selection of carbide type was a commercial as well as a technical decision. Spherical cast carbide is more expensive, but if it delivers twice the service life, the total cost of ownership is lower. I have seen projects where a cheap carbide was used to save money on the initial purchase, and the customer ended up paying three times as much in downtime and replacement.

Practical Considerations for Carbide Selection

Consideration Spherical Cast Coarse Crystalline Fused
Cost per kg High Medium Low
Hardness 2000-3000 HV 1800-2200 HV 1600-2000 HV
Impact resistance Low High Medium
Burn-out resistance Low High Medium
Best suited for Abrasive wear, low impact Impact and abrasion General purpose

Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Carbide segregation Poor powder mixing, low travel speed Improve powder blending, increase travel speed
Carbide burn-out Excessive heat input Reduce current, increase travel speed
Cracking High carbide content, residual stress Preheat, reduce carbide content, post-weld heat treatment
Porosity Gas entrapment, moisture in powder Dry powder, increase shielding gas flow
Poor bonding Low heat input, contamination Clean substrate, increase current

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises an important question about the trade-off between carbide burn-out and wear resistance. If spherical cast carbide burns out severely but still gives the best wear, what happens if we can reduce the burn-out? The answer is that we would get even better wear resistance. This is why process control is so critical: the goal is not to eliminate burn-out entirely, but to control it to a level that maximizes the reprecipitation of fine secondary carbides while retaining enough primary carbides to provide the initial wear resistance.

Another point worth reflecting on: the wear test used in this study was an abrasive wear test, which simulates conditions like rock drilling or earth moving. But in many applications, the wear mechanism is a combination of abrasion and impact, and the optimal carbide type may be different. I have seen cases where coarse crystalline carbide outperformed spherical cast carbide in applications with high impact loads, because the spherical carbide fractured and spalled under impact.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a clear and practical comparison of the three main carbide types used in PTA hardfacing. The finding that spherical cast carbide gives the best wear resistance despite severe burn-out is a valuable insight that challenges the simplistic assumption that less burn-out is always better.

The implication for our industry is that carbide selection must be based on the actual service conditions, not just on the hardness or cost of the carbide. You need to know whether the dominant wear mechanism is abrasion, impact, or a combination of both, and you need to test the deposit under conditions that simulate the real service environment.

Reference Value and Outlook

For engineers working on wear-resistant hardfacing, this paper is an excellent reference. It gives you a clear comparison of the three carbide types, and it explains the mechanism behind the differences in wear performance. The next step would be to extend the study to include impact wear testing and to evaluate the effect of carbide volume fraction on the performance.

In my view, the future of WC-reinforced hardfacing lies in optimizing the carbide morphology and distribution. We need to develop carbides with a controlled dissolution rate, so that we can achieve the best combination of primary carbide retention and secondary carbide reprecipitation. This paper provides a solid foundation for that work.