ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing of Sintering Hot Ore Crusher Toothed Rolls: Practical Lessons from Handan Steel

Background and Context

The sintering plant is the first place where the steelmaking route starts to punish equipment, and the hot ore crusher toothed roll sits right in the middle of that punishment. The roll has to break up sinter cake that has just come off the strand at temperatures that can exceed 800°C, with abrasive fines and thermal cycling that would destroy a conventional carbon steel surface in a matter of weeks. The literature from Handan Steel, published in 2001, describes their efforts to extend the service life of these toothed rolls through improved hardfacing processes. The key achievement was a service life exceeding one year without water cooling of the roll, which is a significant improvement over the previous practice where water cooling was considered essential.

From my own time running pipe and fitting plants, I have seen the same battle in different forms. Whether it is a mandrel bar for seamless piercing, a forming roll for ERW pipe, or a die for hot bending, the problem is always the same: how to put a wear-resistant surface on a component that also has to survive thermal shock and mechanical impact. The Handan Steel work is a classic example of solving this problem through welding metallurgy rather than through expensive alloy substitution.

Technical Analysis of the Hardfacing Process

The Base Metal and Its Challenges

The toothed roll is typically made from a medium-carbon or low-alloy steel casting, with teeth that are machined or cast into the surface. The operating conditions are severe: the roll surface is in direct contact with sinter at temperatures that can locally exceed 700°C, and the abrasive fines from the sinter act as a grinding medium that rapidly removes any soft surface layer. The thermal cycling between hot sinter contact and ambient air creates a stress state that promotes spalling and cracking.

The critical issue identified by the Handan Steel team was that the hardfacing alloy needed to resist both abrasive wear and thermal fatigue. A simple high-hardness alloy would resist abrasion but would crack under thermal cycling. A tough alloy would survive thermal cycling but would wear out quickly. The solution was to use a high-chromium alloy hardfacing that provides a composite structure of hard chromium carbides in a tough martensitic matrix.

The Hardfacing Alloy System

The high-chromium alloy system used in this application is a well-established family of hardfacing consumables. The typical composition ranges are shown in the following table.

Element Composition Range (wt%) Role in the Hardfacing Layer
Carbon 3.0 - 5.0 Forms hard carbides, increases abrasion resistance
Chromium 20 - 30 Forms Cr7C3 and Cr23C6 carbides, provides oxidation resistance
Manganese 0.5 - 1.5 Deoxidizer, improves toughness of the matrix
Silicon 0.5 - 1.0 Deoxidizer, improves weldability
Nickel 0.5 - 2.0 Improves toughness, stabilizes the matrix
Molybdenum 0.5 - 1.5 Strengthens the matrix, improves hot hardness
Iron Balance Matrix material

The hardfacing layer produced from this alloy system has a hardness in the range of HRC 50 to HRC 60, which provides excellent abrasion resistance. The chromium carbides are distributed in a matrix that has sufficient toughness to resist cracking under thermal cycling. The key is to control the cooling rate after welding so that the carbides form in the correct size and distribution.

The Welding Process and Crack Control

The Handan Steel team faced a specific problem: the toothed roll had to be hardfaced without water cooling, which meant that the heat input from welding could not be dissipated quickly. This created a risk of excessive heat buildup, which could lead to distortion, cracking, and degradation of the base metal properties.

The solution was to use a controlled welding sequence that minimized heat input while ensuring good fusion between the hardfacing layer and the base metal. The following process parameters were found to be effective.

Parameter Value Practical Notes
Welding process Submerged arc welding (SAW) or open-arc welding SAW provides better shielding for high-alloy consumables
Welding current 300 - 450 A Higher current increases deposition rate but also heat input
Arc voltage 28 - 35 V Must be balanced with current to maintain stable arc
Welding speed 20 - 40 cm/min Slower speed increases deposition per pass but also heat input
Preheating temperature 150 - 250°C Reduces the temperature gradient and prevents cold cracking
Interpass temperature 250 - 350°C Must be controlled to prevent overheating of the base metal
Post-weld heat treatment Stress relief at 250 - 350°C for 2 - 4 hours Reduces residual stress and prevents delayed cracking

The crack control strategy was based on three principles. First, the base metal was preheated to reduce the temperature gradient between the weld and the base metal. Second, the welding sequence was arranged so that the heat input was distributed evenly across the roll surface, preventing localized overheating. Third, the interpass temperature was carefully controlled to prevent the formation of a large heat-affected zone (HAZ) that would be susceptible to cracking.

Metallurgical Considerations and Defect Analysis

The Heat-Affected Zone Problem

The HAZ in the base metal is the most critical area for cracking in hardfacing applications. When the hardfacing layer is deposited, the base metal immediately adjacent to the weld is heated to temperatures above the transformation range, which causes the formation of a coarse-grained zone. This zone has lower toughness than the base metal and is susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking if the welding consumable contains moisture.

The Handan Steel team addressed this problem by using low-hydrogen consumables and by baking the flux before use. They also controlled the welding parameters to minimize the width of the HAZ. The following table shows the typical HAZ width for different welding processes.

Welding Process Typical HAZ Width (mm) Risk of Cracking
Submerged arc welding 3 - 5 Low, if preheating is applied
Open-arc welding with flux-cored wire 2 - 4 Moderate, requires careful control
Gas metal arc welding 1 - 3 Low, but lower deposition rate
Electroslag welding 8 - 15 High, not recommended for this application

The HAZ width is directly related to the heat input and the thermal conductivity of the base metal. For the toothed roll application, the submerged arc welding process was preferred because it provides a good balance between deposition rate and HAZ control.

Spalling and Delamination

Spalling is a common failure mode in hardfaced components that are subjected to thermal cycling. The hardfacing layer has a different coefficient of thermal expansion than the base metal, which creates a shear stress at the interface during heating and cooling. If the interface is not properly fused, or if there are inclusions or porosity at the interface, the hardfacing layer can separate from the base metal.

The Handan Steel team found that the key to preventing spalling was to ensure complete fusion between the hardfacing layer and the base metal. This required careful control of the welding current and arc voltage to ensure that the base metal was melted sufficiently to achieve a metallurgical bond. They also used a buttering layer of a more ductile alloy between the base metal and the hardfacing layer to reduce the stress concentration at the interface.

Engineering Practice and Results

The Production Implementation

The Handan Steel team implemented the improved hardfacing process on their hot ore crusher toothed rolls and achieved a service life of more than one year without water cooling. This was a significant improvement over the previous practice, where the rolls had to be replaced every three to six months.

The key to the success was the combination of a high-chromium hardfacing alloy with a controlled welding sequence that minimized heat input and prevented cracking. The preheating and interpass temperature control were critical in preventing the formation of cracks in the HAZ, which had been the main cause of premature failure in the previous attempts.

Practical Observations from the Shop Floor

From my own experience, I can add several practical observations that are not always captured in the literature. First, the condition of the base metal before hardfacing is critical. If the roll surface has been damaged by previous service, the damaged layer must be removed before hardfacing. Otherwise, the hardfacing layer will be deposited on a surface that contains cracks and inclusions, which will propagate into the hardfacing layer during service.

Second, the welding consumable must be stored and handled properly. High-chromium hardfacing consumables are sensitive to moisture, which can cause hydrogen-induced cracking. The consumable should be stored in a heated cabinet at a temperature of at least 50°C and should be baked before use if it has been exposed to the atmosphere.

Third, the welding operator must be trained to recognize the signs of poor fusion and inadequate penetration. The most common defect in hardfacing is lack of fusion, which occurs when the welding current is too low or the welding speed is too high. This defect is not always visible on the surface and may only be detected by ultrasonic testing.

Comparison with Alternative Approaches

The high-chromium hardfacing approach used by Handan Steel is not the only way to solve the problem of wear on toothed rolls. Other approaches include thermal spraying, laser cladding, and the use of composite wear plates. The following table compares these approaches.

Approach Advantages Disadvantages Typical Service Life
High-chromium hardfacing Good wear resistance, moderate cost, can be applied on site Requires careful crack control, limited to simple geometries 12 - 18 months
Thermal spraying Low heat input, minimal distortion Poor bond strength, limited thickness 3 - 6 months
Laser cladding Excellent metallurgical bond, minimal distortion High capital cost, limited deposition rate 18 - 24 months
Composite wear plates Excellent wear resistance, easy to install Limited to flat surfaces, high cost 24 - 36 months

The high-chromium hardfacing approach was chosen by Handan Steel because it provided the best balance of cost, performance, and practicality for their specific application.

Key Takeaways and Conclusions

The Handan Steel work on hardfacing hot ore crusher toothed rolls provides several important lessons for engineers working in the steel pipe and fitting industry. First, the selection of the hardfacing alloy must be based on a thorough understanding of the operating conditions, including temperature, abrasiveness, and thermal cycling. Second, the welding process must be designed to control heat input and prevent cracking in the HAZ. Third, the condition of the base metal before hardfacing is critical to the success of the operation.

From my own experience, I would add that the most important factor in the success of any hardfacing operation is the discipline of the welding operator. The welding parameters must be set correctly and maintained throughout the operation. Any deviation from the specified parameters can lead to defects that will cause premature failure of the hardfaced component.

The Handan Steel approach of using a high-chromium hardfacing alloy with controlled preheating and interpass temperature control has been proven in service to provide a service life of more than one year. This is a practical and cost-effective solution that can be applied to other components that are subjected to similar wear and thermal cycling conditions.