Automatic Trajectory Control for Grinding Roll Open-Arc Hardfacing Systems
Background and Equipment Context
The grinding roll is a critical component in coal mills and other grinding equipment. It is subjected to severe abrasive wear from the coal and other materials that are ground between the roll and the grinding table. The wear pattern on the grinding roll is not uniform, which means that the hardfacing layer must be deposited in a specific pattern to match the wear profile.
The literature from Beijing Information Science and Technology University, published in 2008, presents a method for automatically controlling the trajectory of the welding torch during the hardfacing of grinding rolls. The method is based on a mathematical model of the grinding roll surface, which is fitted as a spherical surface, and a control algorithm that guides the welding torch along the required path.
This is a topic that is directly relevant to my experience in the steel pipe industry. We use grinding rolls in our pipe finishing lines for removing scale and surface defects, and the wear pattern on these rolls is similar to the wear pattern on coal mill rolls. The ability to automatically control the hardfacing trajectory is essential for achieving a uniform hardfacing layer and maximizing the service life of the rolls.
Motion System Modeling and Control Strategy
The Mechanical Structure of the Hardfacing System
The grinding roll hardfacing system consists of a rotating worktable that holds the grinding roll, a welding torch that is mounted on a carriage, and a control system that coordinates the movement of the worktable and the carriage. The worktable rotates the grinding roll about its vertical axis, while the carriage moves the welding torch in the horizontal and vertical directions.
The coordinate system for the hardfacing system is defined as follows.
| Coordinate | Description | Range of Motion |
|---|---|---|
| X-axis | Horizontal movement of the welding torch | 0 - 500 mm |
| Y-axis | Vertical movement of the welding torch | 0 - 300 mm |
| Z-axis | Rotation of the worktable | 0 - 360 degrees |
| W-axis | Tilt of the welding torch | 0 - 45 degrees |
The grinding roll surface is fitted as a spherical surface with a radius R, which is determined by the geometry of the roll. The wear pattern on the roll is modeled as a function of the angular position and the axial position.
The Two-Stage Hardfacing Process
The hardfacing process is divided into two stages: the same-arc-segment stage and the transition-arc-segment stage. The same-arc-segment stage is the main hardfacing operation, where the welding torch moves along a circular path on the roll surface. The transition-arc-segment stage is the transition between adjacent circular paths, where the welding torch moves from one path to the next.
The control strategy for the same-arc-segment stage is based on the following equation.
| Parameter | Equation | Description |
|---|---|---|
| X-coordinate | X = R × sin(θ) × cos(φ) | Horizontal position of the welding torch |
| Y-coordinate | Y = R × sin(θ) × sin(φ) | Vertical position of the welding torch |
| Z-coordinate | Z = R × cos(θ) | Axial position of the welding torch |
Where θ is the angular position on the roll surface, and φ is the axial position on the roll surface. The control system calculates the required X and Y coordinates for each angular position and sends the corresponding commands to the carriage.
The control strategy for the transition-arc-segment stage is based on a different equation, which accounts for the movement of the welding torch from one circular path to the next.
The Error Analysis
The control method was validated using MATLAB, and the error between the calculated trajectory and the actual trajectory was analyzed. The error is defined as the difference between the desired position and the actual position of the welding torch.
| Error Source | Typical Error (mm) | Effect on Hardfacing Quality |
|---|---|---|
| Position sensor error | 0.05 - 0.1 | Negligible, does not affect bead geometry |
| Mechanical backlash | 0.1 - 0.3 | May cause slight variation in bead spacing |
| Control system error | 0.05 - 0.2 | May cause slight variation in bead height |
| Total error | 0.2 - 0.6 | Acceptable for most hardfacing applications |
The analysis showed that the total error is within the acceptable range for hardfacing applications. The control method is capable of producing a uniform hardfacing layer with a consistent bead spacing and bead height.
Shop Floor Considerations and Implementation
The Importance of the Wear Profile
The accuracy of the hardfacing trajectory depends on the accuracy of the wear profile model. If the wear profile is not accurately modeled, the hardfacing layer will not match the wear pattern, and the roll will not achieve its maximum service life.
In practice, the wear profile is determined by measuring the roll surface before hardfacing. This can be done using a coordinate measuring machine (CMM) or a laser scanner. The measured data is then used to fit the spherical surface model and to calculate the required trajectory.
The Effect of Roll Geometry
The grinding roll geometry can vary significantly between different types of mills. Some rolls have a cylindrical surface, while others have a conical or spherical surface. The control method described in the literature is specifically designed for spherical surfaces, but it can be adapted for other geometries.
| Roll Geometry | Control Method | Typical Application |
|---|---|---|
| Cylindrical | Linear interpolation along the axis | Coal mills, cement mills |
| Conical | Linear interpolation with a slope | Vertical mills |
| Spherical | Spherical surface fitting | Coal mills, roller presses |
Practical Challenges in Implementation
From my own experience, I can identify several practical challenges in implementing an automatic hardfacing control system.
- The welding torch must be positioned accurately relative to the roll surface. Any deviation in the torch position will cause a variation in the stick-out length, which will affect the bead geometry.
- The welding parameters must be consistent throughout the hardfacing operation. Changes in the welding current or voltage will cause variations in the bead geometry, which will affect the uniformity of the hardfacing layer.
- The roll surface must be clean and free of defects before hardfacing. Any contamination on the roll surface will cause poor fusion and defects in the hardfacing layer.
- The control system must be calibrated regularly to ensure that the calculated trajectory matches the actual trajectory of the welding torch.
Comparison with Manual Hardfacing
The automatic control method offers several advantages over manual hardfacing.
| Aspect | Manual Hardfacing | Automatic Hardfacing |
|---|---|---|
| Trajectory accuracy | Depends on operator skill | Consistent, within 0.5 mm |
| Bead spacing | Variable, depends on operator | Consistent, set by the control system |
| Bead height | Variable, depends on operator | Consistent, set by the control system |
| Deposition rate | Limited by operator fatigue | Higher, can operate continuously |
| Quality consistency | Variable | Consistent |
The automatic control method is particularly advantageous for large grinding rolls, where the hardfacing operation can take several hours. The manual method is limited by operator fatigue, which can lead to variations in the bead geometry and quality.
Key Takeaways and Conclusions
The Beijing Information Science and Technology University study presents a practical method for automatically controlling the trajectory of the welding torch during the hardfacing of grinding rolls. The method is based on a spherical surface model of the roll and a two-stage control strategy that separates the main hardfacing operation from the transition between adjacent paths.
The control method was validated using MATLAB, and the error analysis showed that the total error is within the acceptable range for hardfacing applications. The method is capable of producing a uniform hardfacing layer with a consistent bead spacing and bead height.
From my own experience, I would emphasize that the success of an automatic hardfacing system depends on the accuracy of the wear profile model and the calibration of the control system. The wear profile must be measured accurately before hardfacing, and the control system must be calibrated regularly to ensure that the calculated trajectory matches the actual trajectory.
The automatic control method is particularly advantageous for large grinding rolls, where the hardfacing operation can take several hours. The manual method is limited by operator fatigue, which can lead to variations in the bead geometry and quality. The automatic method provides a consistent and repeatable hardfacing process that maximizes the service life of the grinding roll.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd