ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Single-Layer Strip Electroslag Cladding for Hydrotreating Reactors: Qualification and Application

Literature Overview and Core Finding

This paper by Liu Yan, Ma Xiaobing, Wang Junjie and colleagues from Xinjiang Lanshi Heavy Energy Engineering Co., Ltd. addresses a critical manufacturing challenge: the cladding of hydrotreating reactors. The authors used single-layer strip electroslag cladding to apply a stainless steel layer onto 12Cr2Mo1R steel, based on a qualified welding procedure. The cladding was evaluated for ferrite content, chemical composition, bending properties, corrosion resistance, and hydrogen-induced disbonding. The technology was successfully applied to the shell and head of a hydrotreating reactor.

This is a practical paper from a real manufacturer, and it reflects the realities of heavy vessel fabrication. The key insight is that single-layer strip electroslag cladding can achieve the required properties, provided the parameters are properly qualified and controlled.

Process Principles and Advantages

Strip Electroslag Cladding

Strip electroslag cladding is a variant of submerged arc cladding that uses a strip electrode instead of a wire. The process is characterized by:

  1. High deposition rate: The strip provides a large melting area, resulting in high deposition rates.
  2. Low dilution: The electroslag process has a lower dilution than submerged arc, typically 10-15% compared to 20-30%.
  3. Smooth surface: The strip produces a smooth, uniform surface that requires minimal grinding.
  4. Single-layer capability: With low dilution, a single layer can achieve the required composition, eliminating the need for a second layer.
Process Dilution (%) Deposition Rate (kg/h) Surface Quality
Strip electroslag 10-15 20-30 Excellent
Strip submerged arc 20-30 15-25 Good
Wire submerged arc 20-30 5-10 Fair

Why Single-Layer Matters

For a hydrotreating reactor, the cladding must provide corrosion resistance against hydrogen sulfide and other corrosive species. The cladding composition must meet the requirements of the applicable standard, typically with a nickel content of at least a certain value. With single-layer cladding, the dilution from the base metal is the critical factor. If the dilution is too high, the nickel content will be too low, and the corrosion resistance will be compromised.

Qualification Testing and Standards

The Qualification Program

The authors conducted a comprehensive qualification program, including:

  1. Ferrite content: The ferrite content of the cladding must be controlled to prevent hot cracking and ensure corrosion resistance.
  2. Chemical composition: The cladding composition must meet the requirements of the applicable standard.
  3. Bending properties: The cladding must withstand bending without cracking, demonstrating good ductility and bond quality.
  4. Corrosion resistance: The cladding must resist the corrosive environment of the hydrotreating process.
  5. Hydrogen-induced disbonding: This is a critical test for hydrotreating reactors, where hydrogen can accumulate at the cladding-base metal interface and cause disbonding.

Ferrite Content Control

The ferrite content is a critical parameter. Too much ferrite can lead to selective corrosion, while too little can lead to hot cracking. The typical range for this application is 3-8% ferrite, measured by the Ferrite Number (FN) method.

Test Requirement Result
Ferrite content 3-8 FN Within range
Chemical composition Per standard Meets requirements
Bending properties No cracks after 180° bend Passed
Corrosion resistance Per standard Passed
Hydrogen disbonding No disbonding after test Passed

Shop Floor Practice and Application

The Hydrotreating Reactor

Hydrotreating reactors are among the most critical components in a refinery. They operate at high pressure and temperature, with hydrogen and hydrogen sulfide present. The cladding must provide corrosion resistance while the base metal provides the structural strength.

Practical Considerations

  1. Preheat: The 12Cr2Mo1R base metal requires preheating to prevent cold cracking. The preheat temperature should be determined by the thickness and the carbon equivalent.
  2. Interpass temperature: The interpass temperature must be controlled to prevent excessive heat buildup, which could affect the mechanical properties of the base metal.
  3. Post-weld heat treatment: After cladding, the vessel typically undergoes PWHT to relieve residual stresses. The PWHT temperature and time must be carefully controlled to avoid affecting the cladding properties.
  4. NDT: After cladding, the surface is typically inspected by UT and PT to detect any disbonding or cracking.

Key Questions and Reflections

What the Paper Does Not Tell Us

The paper does not provide specific values for the welding parameters used. I would need to know the strip width, current, voltage, and travel speed to reproduce the results. The paper also does not discuss the economic benefits of single-layer cladding compared to multi-layer cladding.

My Practical Judgment

The successful application of single-layer strip electroslag cladding to a hydrotreating reactor is a significant achievement. The qualification program is comprehensive, and the results demonstrate that the process can meet the required properties. However, I would want to see more details on the welding parameters and the specific test results. The paper is a good example of the practical application of a well-established technology, but it does not provide enough detail for someone to reproduce the process without additional information.

Summary

This paper demonstrates the successful application of single-layer strip electroslag cladding to a hydrotreating reactor. The qualification program, including ferrite content, chemical composition, bending properties, corrosion resistance, and hydrogen disbonding testing, was completed successfully. The technology was applied to both the shell and head of the reactor. This is a practical example of how a well-qualified process can be applied to a critical component. The key to success is the low dilution of the strip electroslag process, which allows a single layer to achieve the required composition. For a hydrotreating reactor, where the cladding must provide reliable corrosion resistance over a long service life, this is a sound approach. I would recommend this process for similar applications, provided that the qualification program is followed rigorously and the welding parameters are controlled within the qualified range.