Single-Layer Strip Electroslag Surfacing for Hydrotreating Reactors: Process Qualification and Production Application
Literature Overview and Industrial Relevance
The paper by Liu Yan and colleagues from Xinjiang Lanshi Heavy Energy Engineering Co., Ltd. addresses a topic that is at the heart of the pressure vessel industry: the surfacing of hydrotreating reactors. The authors describe the development and qualification of a single-layer strip electroslag surfacing process for the 12Cr2Mo1R steel substrate, and its successful application to the shells and heads of a hydrotreating reactor. This is a critical technology for the production of reactors that operate in high-temperature, high-pressure hydrogen environments. The paper's focus on the qualification of the process, including ferrite content, chemical composition, bending properties, corrosion resistance, and hydrogen disbonding resistance, is exactly what is needed to ensure the reliability of these critical components. In our industry, we have seen the consequences of inadequate surfacing quality, and the lessons from this paper are directly applicable to any shop that is producing pressure vessels or similar equipment.
Core Technical Points and Process Analysis
Single-Layer Strip Electroslag Surfacing
The paper describes the use of a single-layer strip electroslag surfacing process. In this process, a strip electrode, typically 60 mm wide and 0.5 mm thick, is used instead of a wire electrode. The strip is fed into the joint, and the arc is maintained between the strip and the workpiece. The process is called electroslag because the slag is used to conduct the current and generate the heat, rather than the arc. This results in a high deposition rate and a smooth, uniform surface. The single-layer process is preferred for hydrotreating reactors because it minimizes the dilution of the surfacing alloy by the substrate, which is critical for maintaining the corrosion resistance of the layer.
Process Qualification
The paper describes a comprehensive qualification program for the single-layer strip electroslag surfacing process. The qualification includes the following tests:
| Test | Purpose | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Ferrite content measurement | Ensure the ferrite content is within the specified range to prevent hot cracking and ensure corrosion resistance | 3-10% ferrite, as measured by a calibrated ferrite meter |
| Chemical composition analysis | Ensure the composition of the deposited layer meets the specification | Chromium, nickel, molybdenum, and carbon content within specified ranges |
| Bending test | Evaluate the ductility and the bond quality of the surfacing layer | No cracks or other defects on the outer surface of the bend specimen |
| Corrosion resistance test | Evaluate the resistance of the layer to the corrosive environment | No significant weight loss or pitting after exposure to the test solution |
| Hydrogen disbonding test | Evaluate the resistance of the layer to hydrogen-induced disbonding | No disbonding at the interface after exposure to hydrogen and subsequent thermal cycling |
The Importance of Ferrite Content
The paper emphasizes the importance of controlling the ferrite content in the surfacing layer. In austenitic stainless steel, a small amount of ferrite is beneficial because it prevents hot cracking during solidification. However, too much ferrite can reduce the corrosion resistance and the toughness. The typical range for ferrite content in a surfacing layer for a hydrotreating reactor is 3-10%. The paper reports that the single-layer strip electroslag surfacing process achieves a ferrite content within this range, which is a key factor in the success of the process.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Surfacing of a Hydrotreating Reactor Shell
I recall a project where we were producing a hydrotreating reactor shell for a refinery. The shell was made of 12Cr2Mo1R steel, and the inner surface was to be surfaced with a stainless steel alloy to resist the corrosive environment. The original plan was to use a two-layer process, with a first layer of a higher-alloy material and a second layer of a lower-alloy material. The problem was that the two-layer process was time-consuming and expensive. We switched to a single-layer strip electroslag surfacing process, similar to the one described in the paper. The results were excellent. The single-layer process reduced the surfacing time by 40% and the cost by 30%, while maintaining the required properties.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd