ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Axial Pressure on Microstructure and Wear Properties of Friction Surfaced X65 Steel

Overview and Industrial Context

The paper by Zhang et al. investigates the effect of axial pressure on the microstructure and wear properties of friction surfacing deposits on X65 steel. This is a particularly relevant topic for the steel pipe industry, as X65 is a widely used grade for oil and gas transmission pipelines. The application of friction surfacing to X65 steel is of interest for the repair of pipeline components, such as girth welds and fittings, where the original surface may have been damaged during installation or service.

Friction surfacing is a solid-state process that utilises the heat generated by friction between a rotating consumable rod and a substrate to create a metallurgical bond. Unlike fusion welding processes, friction surfacing does not involve melting of the substrate, which means that the heat-affected zone is minimal and the risk of distortion is low. This makes it an attractive option for the repair of thin-walled components and for applications where the original microstructure must be preserved.

The paper focuses on the effect of axial pressure, which is one of the most critical process parameters in friction surfacing. The axial pressure determines the contact area between the consumable rod and the substrate, which in turn affects the heat generation, the material flow, and the geometry of the deposit. The authors have conducted a systematic study over a pressure range of 59.7 to 104.4 MPa, which is a relatively narrow but practically relevant window.

Technical Analysis of the Friction Surfacing Process

The friction surfacing process involves a rotating consumable rod that is pressed against a substrate. The rotation speed is typically in the range of 2000-5000 rpm, and the traverse speed is in the range of 100-300 mm/min. The heat generated by friction causes the tip of the consumable rod to plasticise, and the material is transferred to the substrate, forming a deposit layer.

The paper reports that at a rotation speed of 4000 rpm and a traverse speed of 200 mm/min, a sound metallurgical bond can be achieved over the axial pressure range of 59.7-104.4 MPa. The deposit width increases with increasing axial pressure, while the deposit thickness decreases. This is an important observation, as it indicates that the axial pressure has a direct influence on the geometry of the deposit. In practice, this means that the axial pressure must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired deposit dimensions.

The microstructure of the friction surfaced layer is described as a mixture of coarse lath and granular bainite, which is different from the fine-grained microstructure typically observed in friction welding. This is attributed to the different thermal cycles experienced during friction surfacing, where the cooling rate is lower than in friction welding due to the larger volume of material being processed. The heat-affected zone (HAZ) consists of an overheated zone with bainitic microstructure and a recrystallised zone with fine ferrite grains.

The paper also reports that the axial pressure has a significant effect on the grain coarsening tendency in the deposit and the size of the HAZ, but has little effect on the morphological characteristics of the HAZ. This suggests that the axial pressure primarily influences the thermal input, which in turn affects the grain growth kinetics.

The wear properties of the deposit are reported to be superior to those of the base material, with a maximum reduction in wear volume of 33.3%. This is a significant improvement and indicates that friction surfacing can be used to enhance the wear resistance of X65 steel components. The improved wear resistance is attributed to the higher hardness of the deposit, which is a result of the bainitic microstructure.

Practical Implications and Lessons Learned

From a practical standpoint, the application of friction surfacing to X65 steel components presents several challenges. First, the process requires a rigid machine tool with precise control of the axial pressure and the traverse speed. The consumable rod must be of high quality, with a uniform composition and a clean surface, as any contamination will be incorporated into the deposit.

Second, the process is inherently limited by the geometry of the consumable rod. For a rod of 20 mm diameter, the deposit width is typically in the range of 10-15 mm, which means that multiple passes are required to cover a large area. This can lead to overlapping of the deposit, which may result in defects such as lack of bonding at the overlap region.

In my experience with pipeline repair, the use of friction surfacing is most suitable for small, localised defects, such as gouges and corrosion pits, rather than for large-area repairs. For large-area repairs, the use of a fusion welding process, such as gas metal arc welding or submerged arc welding, is more practical, despite the higher heat input and the associated risk of distortion.

The paper's finding that the axial pressure has a significant effect on the deposit geometry is particularly relevant for process control. In a production environment, the axial pressure must be monitored and controlled in real time to ensure consistent deposit quality. This can be achieved through the use of a load cell and a closed-loop control system, which is standard practice in modern friction surfacing equipment.

One of the key limitations of the paper is that it does not address the effect of the substrate temperature on the deposit quality. In practice, the substrate temperature can increase significantly during the process, which may affect the cooling rate and the resulting microstructure. A thorough investigation of the thermal management of the process is needed before it can be reliably applied in an industrial setting.

Study Insights and Recommendations

The paper provides valuable insights into the effect of axial pressure on the friction surfacing of X65 steel. The finding that the deposit hardness and wear resistance are superior to those of the base material is encouraging, and it suggests that friction surfacing could be used to enhance the performance of pipeline components in service.

However, the paper does not address the corrosion resistance of the deposit, which is a critical parameter for pipeline applications. The bainitic microstructure of the deposit may have different corrosion characteristics compared to the ferritic-pearlitic microstructure of the base material. A comprehensive corrosion assessment, including electrochemical tests and stress corrosion cracking tests, should be conducted before the process is adopted for pipeline repair.

Another aspect that warrants further investigation is the fatigue performance of the friction surfaced layer. The presence of a hard, bainitic layer on the surface of a pipeline component may affect the fatigue crack initiation and propagation behaviour. In particular, the interface between the deposit and the substrate is a potential site for crack initiation under cyclic loading.

From a quality control perspective, the inspection of friction surfaced layers is challenging due to the lack of a distinct fusion line. The use of ultrasonic testing is recommended for the detection of lack of bonding, but the interpretation of the results requires careful calibration. Additionally, the use of eddy current testing may be beneficial for the detection of surface-breaking defects.

In conclusion, the paper presents a comprehensive study of the effect of axial pressure on the friction surfacing of X65 steel. The results demonstrate that the process can produce high-quality deposits with superior wear resistance. However, the practical application of the process requires careful consideration of the process parameters, the substrate temperature, and the inspection requirements. The lessons learned from this study can be applied to the repair of other pipeline grades, such as X70 and X80, and to the surfacing of components for the oil and gas industry.