ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Annealing on the Microstructure and Properties of 2209 Duplex Stainless Steel Surfacing Layers

Overview and Industrial Context

The paper by E Xin et al. investigates the effect of annealing at 690°C on the microstructure and properties of 2209 duplex stainless steel surfacing layers. This is a highly relevant topic for the pressure vessel and heat exchanger industry, where duplex stainless steels are widely used for their excellent combination of high strength and corrosion resistance.

The 2209 duplex stainless steel, which is the filler metal designation corresponding to UNS S32205, is commonly used for surfacing of carbon steel pressure vessels to provide corrosion resistance. The surfacing layer is typically applied by submerged arc welding or electroslag welding, and the resulting deposit has a duplex microstructure consisting of approximately equal proportions of austenite and ferrite.

The annealing treatment at 690°C is of particular interest because this temperature falls within the range where sigma phase precipitation occurs in duplex stainless steels. Sigma phase is a hard, brittle intermetallic compound that precipitates at the ferrite-austenite interfaces and within the ferrite grains. The presence of sigma phase can significantly degrade the toughness and corrosion resistance of the material.

Technical Analysis of the Sigma Phase Precipitation Mechanism

The paper provides a detailed analysis of the sigma phase precipitation mechanism in the 2209 duplex stainless steel surfacing layer. The authors report that after annealing at 690°C, sigma phase precipitates along the gamma/delta and delta/delta grain boundaries. With increasing annealing time, the sigma phase grows into the ferrite grains, and the amount of sigma phase increases until it reaches a plateau.

The precipitation of sigma phase in duplex stainless steel is a diffusion-controlled process that is strongly dependent on the temperature and the chemical composition. The temperature of 690°C is within the nose of the time-temperature-precipitation (TTP) curve for sigma phase in 2209 duplex stainless steel, which means that the precipitation kinetics are relatively fast at this temperature. The paper reports that the sigma phase content increases with annealing time, reaching a plateau after approximately 10 hours.

The mechanism of sigma phase precipitation involves the decomposition of ferrite into sigma phase and secondary austenite. The ferrite phase is enriched in chromium and molybdenum, which are the primary elements that promote sigma phase formation. As the sigma phase nucleates at the ferrite-austenite interfaces, it grows by consuming the adjacent ferrite, which is depleted in chromium and molybdenum. This leads to the formation of secondary austenite, which is depleted in these elements and has reduced corrosion resistance.

The paper also reports that the hardness of the deposit increases with the amount of sigma phase, while the impact toughness decreases. This is consistent with the known properties of sigma phase, which is a hard and brittle phase. The fracture mechanism changes from ductile fracture in the as-welded condition to quasi-cleavage fracture after annealing at 690°C, which is a clear indication of embrittlement.

Practical Implications and Lessons Learned

From a practical standpoint, the findings of this paper have significant implications for the manufacturing and service of duplex stainless steel surfaced components. The annealing temperature of 690°C is within the range of typical post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) temperatures for carbon steel pressure vessels. If a duplex stainless steel surfaced vessel is subjected to PWHT at this temperature, the sigma phase precipitation will occur, leading to embrittlement of the surfacing layer.

In my experience, the PWHT of duplex stainless steel clad pressure vessels is a critical issue that must be carefully managed. The standard practice is to avoid PWHT altogether, or to use a lower temperature, such as 550-600°C, where sigma phase precipitation is slower. However, if PWHT is required for the carbon steel base material, the temperature and time must be carefully controlled to minimise the risk of sigma phase formation.

The paper's finding that the sigma phase precipitation reaches a plateau after a certain time is important for process design. This suggests that the extent of sigma phase formation is limited by the available ferrite, and that the kinetics are not linear with time. However, the plateau value of sigma phase content is still significant, and the resulting embrittlement is unacceptable for most applications.

One of the key challenges in the manufacturing of duplex stainless steel surfaced components is the control of the ferrite-austenite balance in the deposit. The presence of excessive ferrite increases the susceptibility to sigma phase precipitation, while excessive austenite reduces the strength and corrosion resistance. The ferrite number (FN) is typically controlled in the range of 30-60 for duplex stainless steel deposits, and this should be verified by chemical analysis and metallographic examination.

Study Insights and Recommendations

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of sigma phase precipitation in duplex stainless steel surfacing layers. The finding that the precipitation occurs at the grain boundaries and grows into the ferrite grains is consistent with the known mechanism, and the paper provides a clear correlation between the sigma phase content and the mechanical properties.

However, the paper does not address the effect of sigma phase on the corrosion resistance in detail. The authors mention that the corrosion resistance decreases, but they do not provide quantitative data on the pitting corrosion potential or the critical pitting temperature. This is a significant omission, as the primary reason for using duplex stainless steel is its corrosion resistance.

From a quality control perspective, the detection of sigma phase in duplex stainless steel surfacing layers is challenging. The use of metallographic examination with a suitable etchant, such as a modified Murakami's reagent, is the standard method for revealing sigma phase. However, the preparation of the sample is critical, as sigma phase can be confused with other phases, such as chi phase or secondary austenite.

The paper also does not address the effect of the welding process on the sigma phase precipitation kinetics. The microstructure of the as-welded deposit is influenced by the heat input and the cooling rate, which in turn affect the ferrite-austenite balance and the susceptibility to sigma phase formation. A study of the effect of welding parameters on the sigma phase precipitation would be valuable for process optimisation.

In conclusion, the paper provides a comprehensive analysis of the sigma phase precipitation in 2209 duplex stainless steel surfacing layers. The results demonstrate that annealing at 690°C leads to significant embrittlement, which is unacceptable for most applications. The findings highlight the importance of controlling the PWHT temperature and time for duplex stainless steel clad components. The lessons learned from this study can be applied to the manufacturing of pressure vessels and heat exchangers, where the prevention of sigma phase formation is critical for the long-term reliability of the equipment.