ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Failure Analysis and TIG Surfacing Process Optimisation for Co-Based Superalloy

Overview and Industrial Context

The paper by Guo Ying et al. presents a failure analysis of a Co-based superalloy component, specifically the outer spray head of an oxygen burner used in coal chemical plants, and the subsequent optimisation of the TIG surfacing process for its repair. This is a highly relevant topic for the petrochemical and energy industries, where high-temperature components are subjected to severe thermal and chemical environments.

The outer spray head of a pure oxygen burner operates at extremely high temperatures, typically in the range of 1200-1400°C, and is exposed to an oxidising atmosphere. The component is made of a Co-based superalloy, such as UMCo50, which is a cobalt-chromium alloy with high-temperature strength and oxidation resistance. However, the component is prone to surface cracking, known as "mud cracking" or "check cracking," which is caused by the thermal cycling and the oxidation of the surface.

The paper identifies the failure modes of the outer spray head and then optimises the TIG surfacing process for the repair of the damaged surface. The use of TIG surfacing is appropriate for this application because it offers precise control of the heat input, which is essential for minimising the distortion and the formation of cracks in the repair.

Technical Analysis of the Failure Modes and Process Optimisation

The failure analysis reveals that the outer spray head suffers from surface cracking, which is initiated at the grain boundaries of the Co-based superalloy. The cracks propagate along the grain boundaries, leading to the formation of a network of cracks on the surface. The cracking is attributed to the thermal cycling, which causes the formation of thermal stresses, and to the oxidation of the grain boundaries, which weakens the material.

The paper also identifies the presence of carbides, such as chromium carbide, at the grain boundaries, which are formed during the service life of the component. The carbides are hard and brittle, and they act as sites for crack initiation. The oxidation of the grain boundaries leads to the formation of chromium oxide, which is brittle and further weakens the material.

Based on the failure analysis, the authors propose a repair strategy using TIG surfacing with UMCo50 filler metal. The process parameters are optimised using a multi-factor orthogonal experimental design, with the welding current, surfacing speed, interpass temperature, and number of layers as the variables. The optimisation is based on the minimisation of the crack rate and the maximisation of the deposit quality.

The optimal process parameters are reported as follows: welding current of 120 A, surfacing speed of 10-11 cm/min, interpass temperature of 60±10°C, and 2-3 layers of surfacing. The low welding current is chosen to minimise the heat input, which reduces the thermal stresses and the risk of cracking. The low interpass temperature is chosen to prevent the accumulation of heat, which could lead to grain growth and the formation of cracks.

Practical Implications and Lessons Learned

From a practical standpoint, the repair of Co-based superalloy components using TIG surfacing is a delicate process that requires careful control of the heat input and the interpass temperature. The paper's finding that a low welding current and a low interpass temperature are optimal is consistent with the known behaviour of Co-based superalloys, which are susceptible to cracking when the heat input is too high.

In my experience, the repair of high-temperature components, such as burner nozzles and gas turbine blades, requires a thorough understanding of the failure mechanism and the material behaviour. The failure analysis is an essential first step, as it provides the information needed to select the appropriate repair method and process parameters.

One of the key challenges in the repair of Co-based superalloy components is the prevention of cracking during the surfacing process. The cracks can be caused by the thermal stresses generated during cooling, or by the formation of brittle phases, such as carbides, in the deposit. The paper's approach of using a low interpass temperature and a low welding current is effective in minimising the thermal stresses, but the formation of carbides cannot be completely avoided.

The paper also highlights the importance of the number of layers in the surfacing process. The use of 2-3 layers is recommended to achieve the required deposit thickness and to ensure a sound metallurgical bond. However, the number of layers must be balanced against the risk of cracking, which increases with the number of layers due to the accumulation of residual stresses.

The paper does not address the post-weld heat treatment of the repair. In practice, a post-weld heat treatment may be required to relieve residual stresses and to improve the ductility of the deposit. However, the heat treatment temperature must be carefully controlled to avoid the formation of additional carbides or other brittle phases.

Study Insights and Recommendations

The paper provides a comprehensive failure analysis and process optimisation for the repair of Co-based superalloy components. The finding that the optimal process parameters are a low welding current and a low interpass temperature is valuable for the practical application of TIG surfacing.

However, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the microstructure of the repaired surface. The formation of carbides and other phases in the deposit should be investigated using metallographic examination and X-ray diffraction. This would provide a better understanding of the relationship between the process parameters and the resulting microstructure.

The paper also does not address the long-term performance of the repaired component. The repair should be validated by testing the component under simulated service conditions, including thermal cycling and exposure to an oxidising atmosphere. This would provide confidence in the long-term reliability of the repair.

From a quality control perspective, the inspection of the repaired surface is essential. The use of penetrant testing is recommended for the detection of surface-breaking cracks, and the use of ultrasonic testing is recommended for the detection of internal defects. The inspection should be performed after the surfacing process and after any post-weld heat treatment.

In conclusion, the paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the failure and repair of Co-based superalloy components. The findings highlight the importance of failure analysis in the selection of the repair method and the optimisation of the process parameters. The lessons learned from this study can be applied to the repair of other high-temperature components, such as gas turbine blades and furnace rollers, where the prevention of cracking is critical for the long-term reliability of the component.