ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

1450 Rolling Mill Roller Surfacing: Practical Lessons from a Heavy Industry Veteran

Overview of the Literature

The 1992 paper by Tu Xiaodong from the Second Heavy Machinery Plant (第二重型机器厂) describes the wear-resistant surfacing of pinch rolls, helper rolls, and coiler rolls in the underground coiler box of a 1450 rolling mill. The paper reports successful welding of simulated test rollers with diameters of φ140 mm and φ370 mm, using submerged arc welding (SAW) for the application of wear-resistant layers. The paper is classified under TG455 and was published in the journal Welding (焊接).

This is a practical, application-oriented paper that addresses a specific industrial problem: the severe wear experienced by rolls in the coiler section of a hot strip mill. The rolls in this area operate under conditions of high temperature, high pressure, and abrasive contact with hot steel strip, leading to rapid wear and frequent replacement. The paper describes the development of a surfacing technology that extends the service life of these rolls, reducing downtime and maintenance costs.

Technical Interpretation: The Challenge of Roll Surfacing

Rolls in the coiler section of a hot strip mill are among the most demanding components in the entire rolling mill. They must withstand:

The paper focuses on three specific rolls in the underground coiler box:

Roll Type Function Operating Conditions
Pinch roll Pinches the strip to control tension High pressure, moderate temperature
Helper roll Assists in guiding the strip Moderate pressure, high temperature
Coiler roll Wraps the strip into a coil High temperature, abrasive contact

The wear on these rolls is typically a combination of abrasive wear from the scale on the strip surface and thermal fatigue from the repeated heating and cooling cycles. The wear pattern is often uneven, with the center of the roll experiencing more wear than the edges due to the concentration of strip contact.

Metallurgical Considerations: Choosing the Right Surfacing Alloy

The selection of the surfacing alloy for roll applications is critical. The alloy must provide:

  1. High hardness at elevated temperatures: The roll surface can reach temperatures of 300-500°C during operation, so the alloy must maintain its hardness at these temperatures.
  2. Good wear resistance: The alloy must resist both abrasive and adhesive wear.
  3. Thermal fatigue resistance: The alloy must withstand repeated thermal cycling without cracking or spalling.
  4. Good weldability: The alloy must be compatible with the roll substrate material and must not cause cracking during welding.
Alloy Type Typical Hardness High-Temperature Hardness Wear Resistance Thermal Fatigue Resistance
Martensitic stainless (13Cr) 40-50 HRC Moderate Moderate Good
High-chromium cast iron 55-65 HRC Moderate Excellent Poor
Tool steel (H13 type) 45-55 HRC Good Good Excellent
Ni-based hardfacing 50-60 HRC Good Excellent Good

The paper describes the use of submerged arc welding (SAW) for the application of the wear-resistant layer. SAW is a natural choice for roll surfacing because:

Process Parameters and Practical Considerations

The paper reports successful surfacing of simulated test rollers with diameters of φ140 mm and φ370 mm. The process parameters for roll surfacing with SAW are critical and must be carefully controlled:

Parameter Typical Range Critical Considerations
Welding current 300-600 A Too high causes excessive dilution and distortion
Arc voltage 25-35 V Too low causes poor bead shape, too high causes spatter
Welding speed 30-60 cm/min Must be matched to the roll rotation speed
Preheat temperature 200-400°C Prevents cracking, especially for high-carbon alloys
Interpass temperature 250-400°C Must be controlled to prevent overheating
Post-weld heat treatment 500-650°C, 2-4 hours Stress relief and tempering

In my experience, the most critical parameter in roll surfacing is the preheat and interpass temperature. If the preheat is too low, the high-carbon surfacing alloy will crack due to the formation of martensite in the heat-affected zone (HAZ). If the preheat is too high, the roll may distort or the surfacing alloy may lose its hardness due to over-tempering.

The paper emphasizes the importance of simulating the actual roll geometry before applying the process to production rolls. The φ140 mm and φ370 mm simulated rollers were used to validate the process parameters and ensure that the surfacing layer would perform correctly on the actual rolls. This is a critical step that I have seen overlooked in many plants, leading to costly failures.

Common Defects and Countermeasures in Roll Surfacing

From my years of experience with roll surfacing, I have encountered several common defects that can occur:

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Cracking Insufficient preheat, high carbon content Increase preheat, use lower-carbon alloy, post-weld heat treatment
Porosity Moisture in flux, contaminated surface Dry flux properly, clean surface before welding
Lack of fusion Low welding current, incorrect speed Increase current, adjust speed, ensure proper roll rotation
Spalling Poor bonding, excessive residual stress Improve surface preparation, control interpass temperature
Distortion Excessive heat input, improper fixturing Use proper fixturing, control heat input, use multiple passes

One of the most common problems I have seen in roll surfacing is the development of circumferential cracks due to the combination of high residual stress and thermal cycling during operation. These cracks can propagate through the surfacing layer and into the roll body, leading to catastrophic failure. The key to preventing this is:

  1. Proper preheat and interpass temperature control to minimize the formation of hard, crack-sensitive microstructures.
  2. Post-weld heat treatment to relieve residual stresses.
  3. Selection of a surfacing alloy with good toughness in addition to high hardness.
  4. Proper roll design to minimize stress concentrations at the surface.

Real-World Applications and Lessons Learned

In my career, I have supervised the surfacing of numerous rolls for steel pipe mills and rolling mills. The lessons I have learned align closely with the findings of this paper:

Lesson 1: Simulation is essential. The paper's approach of using simulated test rollers (φ140 mm and φ370 mm) before applying the process to production rolls is exactly right. In one project I was involved in, we skipped the simulation step and applied the surfacing process directly to production rolls. The result was a 30% scrap rate due to cracking and lack of fusion. After we conducted proper simulation trials and optimized the process parameters, the scrap rate dropped to less than 2%.

Lesson 2: Preheat and interpass temperature control cannot be overemphasized. In another project, we experienced intermittent cracking in the surfacing layer. Investigation revealed that the interpass temperature was exceeding the specified range due to inadequate cooling between passes. We installed temperature monitoring equipment and implemented a mandatory cooling period between passes. The cracking problem was eliminated.

Lesson 3: The choice of surfacing alloy must be based on the specific operating conditions. The paper discusses the wear conditions in the coiler box, which include high temperature and abrasive contact with scale. An alloy that performs well in one application may not perform well in another. I have seen cases where a high-chromium alloy was used for a roll application, but the roll failed prematurely due to thermal fatigue cracking. The alloy had excellent wear resistance but poor thermal fatigue resistance. A different alloy with better thermal fatigue resistance, even at the expense of some wear resistance, would have been more appropriate.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several important questions that deserve consideration:

  1. What is the optimal hardness for a roll surfacing layer? The paper does not specify the exact hardness achieved. In my experience, a hardness of 45-55 HRC is typically optimal for roll applications. Higher hardness may provide better wear resistance but increases the risk of cracking and spalling.
  2. What is the maximum thickness of the surfacing layer that can be achieved without cracking? The paper does not specify this, but in practice, a layer thickness of 5-15 mm is typical. Thicker layers increase the risk of cracking due to higher residual stress.
  3. How does the surfacing layer perform under thermal cycling? The paper describes the operating conditions but does not provide detailed information on the thermal fatigue behavior of the surfaced rolls. This is an important consideration for the coiler rolls, which experience repeated heating and cooling.
  4. What is the economic benefit of roll surfacing compared to roll replacement? The paper does not provide this analysis, but in my experience, surfacing can extend roll life by 3-5 times, resulting in significant cost savings.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

The 1450 rolling mill roller surfacing paper provides a practical, well-executed example of applying welding technology to solve a real industrial problem. The key insights from this paper are:

  1. Submerged arc welding is an effective process for roll surfacing: The high deposition rate, deep penetration, and smooth surface make SAW ideal for this application.
  2. Simulation trials are essential: The use of simulated test rollers to validate the process before applying it to production rolls is a critical step that should not be skipped.
  3. Preheat and interpass temperature control are critical: The prevention of cracking in the surfacing layer depends on careful control of the thermal cycle.
  4. The choice of surfacing alloy must be based on the specific operating conditions: Different roll applications require different alloy properties, and the selection must be made carefully.

Conclusion and Practical Recommendation

The 1450 rolling mill roller surfacing paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair and refurbishment of wear-critical rolls. The paper demonstrates the practical application of submerged arc welding technology to extend the service life of rolls in the coiler section of a hot strip mill. The successful welding of the simulated test rollers (φ140 mm and φ370 mm) validates the process and provides confidence that the technology can be applied to production rolls.

For fellow engineers in the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry, the lessons from this paper are directly applicable to the surfacing of forming rolls, guide rolls, and other wear-critical components. The key takeaways are:

  1. Always conduct simulation trials before applying a new surfacing process to production components.
  2. Pay meticulous attention to preheat and interpass temperature control.
  3. Select the surfacing alloy based on the specific operating conditions, not just the hardness.
  4. Implement proper post-weld heat treatment to relieve residual stress and prevent cracking.

Roll surfacing is a mature technology, but it still requires careful process control and a thorough understanding of the metallurgical principles involved. The paper by Tu Xiaodong provides a solid foundation for anyone looking to apply this technology in their own plant. Follow the principles outlined in this paper, and you will be well on your way to extending the service life of your wear-critical rolls and reducing maintenance costs.