ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

A New Step-Swing-Step Cladding Process for Continuous Casting Rolls

Background and Significance

This paper by Zhao Chunyan and colleagues from Harbin Welding Research Institute introduces a new cladding process for continuous casting rolls that addresses several long-standing problems with conventional single-pass spiral cladding. The new process is called step-swing-step cladding, and it involves asynchronous program control of the roll stepping motion, the welding wire oscillation, and the cross-stepping motion. The authors claim that this approach delivers stable arc, automatic slag removal, no slag inclusion, smooth cladding surface, reasonable residual stress distribution, low dilution, narrow heat-affected zone, and fewer layers to achieve the required properties. These are bold claims, but based on my experience with roll cladding, they are not exaggerated.

Continuous casting rolls are among the most demanding components in a steel plant. They operate in an environment of high temperature, cyclic thermal loading, mechanical wear from the casting strand, and corrosive attack from the mold flux and cooling water. The surface of the roll must resist thermal fatigue cracking, abrasive wear, and corrosion simultaneously. The conventional approach is to clad the roll surface with a martensitic stainless steel or a nickel-based alloy, using submerged arc welding or flux-cored wire welding in a spiral pattern. This approach works, but it has known limitations: the spiral pattern creates a continuous seam that can be a preferential path for crack propagation, the heat input is often high, and the residual stress distribution can be unfavorable.

Technical Analysis of the New Cladding Process

The step-swing-step process changes the fundamental deposition strategy. Instead of a continuous spiral, the roll is stepped forward in discrete increments, while the welding head swings across the roll surface and then steps over to the next band. The three motions — roll stepping, wire oscillation, and cross-stepping — are controlled asynchronously by a programmable logic controller. This allows the operator to precisely control the overlap between adjacent passes, the dwell time at the edges of the swing, and the step distance between bands.

The key advantages of this approach, as described in the paper, are worth examining in detail.

Parameter Conventional Spiral Cladding Step-Swing-Step Cladding
Deposition pattern Continuous spiral Discrete bands with controlled overlap
Arc stability Dependent on spiral continuity Independent of roll rotation, more stable
Slag removal Manual or mechanical, often incomplete Automatic, due to controlled swing and step
Slag inclusion risk Moderate to high Low
Surface finish Ribbed, requires machining Smooth, minimal machining required
Dilution Moderate to high Low, due to controlled heat input
HAZ width Wide Narrow
Residual stress Unfavorable, often tensile at surface More favorable, compressive at surface possible
Number of layers More layers required Fewer layers achieve required properties
Energy and material consumption Higher Lower
Roll service life Baseline Improved, due to better surface integrity

The most significant improvement, in my view, is the automatic slag removal. In conventional spiral cladding, slag removal is a manual operation that is often incomplete. Residual slag becomes trapped between passes, leading to slag inclusions that act as stress raisers and crack initiation sites. The step-swing-step process eliminates this problem by controlling the swing and step so that the slag from the previous pass is pushed aside and falls away naturally. This is a major quality improvement, because slag inclusions are one of the most common defects found in roll cladding.

The second major improvement is the residual stress distribution. The paper states that the new process produces a more reasonable residual stress distribution. In my experience, the ideal residual stress state for a cladded roll is compressive at the surface, which resists crack initiation and propagation. Conventional spiral cladding often leaves tensile residual stress at the surface, which promotes cracking. The step-swing-step process, by controlling the deposition sequence and heat input, can achieve a more favorable stress state.

The third improvement is the reduction in dilution and HAZ width. Low dilution means the cladding composition is closer to the intended alloy, which improves corrosion and wear resistance. A narrow HAZ means less degradation of the base metal properties, which is important for a roll that is subjected to thermal cycling.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have seen continuous casting rolls fail in service, and the failure modes are instructive. The most common failure is thermal fatigue cracking, which initiates at the surface and propagates inward. The cracks are often associated with slag inclusions or other surface defects. The second most common failure is abrasive wear, which reduces the roll diameter and affects the quality of the cast strand. The third is corrosion, which can accelerate both of the other failure modes.

The step-swing-step process addresses all three failure modes. By eliminating slag inclusions, it removes the crack initiation sites. By producing a smoother surface, it reduces the wear rate. By achieving a more favorable residual stress state, it resists crack propagation. The result, as the paper claims, is an increased roll service life.

In practical terms, the implementation of this process requires a few things that are not always obvious from the paper.

First, the control system must be robust. The asynchronous control of the three motions requires a programmable logic controller with precise positioning and repeatability. In my experience, the most common cause of problems with automated cladding systems is not the welding equipment but the motion control. If the roll stepping is not accurate, the overlap between bands will be inconsistent, leading to poor surface quality and potential defects.

Second, the welding parameters must be carefully matched to the roll material and the cladding alloy. The paper does not provide specific parameters, but the principles are clear: low heat input, short arc, and controlled deposition. For a martensitic stainless steel cladding on a cast steel roll, the preheat and interpass temperature are critical to avoid cracking. For a nickel-based alloy cladding, the heat input must be controlled to avoid excessive dilution.

Third, the process requires a qualified welding procedure and skilled operators. The step-swing-step process is more complex than conventional spiral cladding, and the operators must understand the interaction between the three motions. Training is essential.

In my view, the step-swing-step process is a significant advance in roll cladding technology. It addresses the known limitations of conventional spiral cladding and delivers measurable improvements in quality, efficiency, and service life. The paper is a valuable contribution to the field, and I would recommend it to anyone involved in roll cladding or similar cladding applications.

The key takeaway for fellow engineers is this: the deposition strategy matters as much as the welding parameters. By controlling the motion of the roll and the welding head, you can achieve a quality of deposit that is simply not possible with a conventional spiral pattern. This is a lesson that applies not just to continuous casting rolls but to any cylindrical component that requires a high-quality cladding layer.