Development and Application of Hardfaced Composite Rolls for Continuous Casting at Panzhihua Steel
Overview of the Literature
This 1999 paper from the Panzhihua Iron and Steel Research Institute, Panzhihua Steel Machinery Manufacturing Company, Panzhihua Steel Vanadium Extraction and Steelmaking Plant, and Panzhihua Steel Mechanical and Electrical Department documents the development of hardfaced composite rolls for continuous casting machines. The authors selected the widely used single-wire submerged arc welding (SAW) technology for hardfacing the rolls. Through laboratory comparison of the 15CrMo roll core material and the hardfacing metal, they selected and optimized the welding process parameters, bringing the hardfaced composite rolls to the level required by the company's internal technical specifications. Industrial trials showed that the hardfaced composite rolls achieved a service life 3-6 times longer than conventional 15CrMo continuous casting rolls.
Core Technical Points
The Need for Composite Rolls
The paper addresses a critical problem in continuous casting: the service life of the rolls. Continuous casting rolls operate under severe conditions, including high temperature, mechanical stress, and thermal cycling. The roll surface is subjected to wear from the moving strand, and the roll body is subjected to bending stress from the strand weight. Conventional rolls made of 15CrMo steel have a limited service life due to surface wear and thermal fatigue cracking. The solution is to hardface the roll surface with a wear-resistant alloy, creating a composite roll that combines the toughness of the substrate with the wear resistance of the hardfacing layer.
Material Selection and Comparison
The paper describes a systematic comparison of the 15CrMo roll core material and the hardfacing metal. The key properties compared include:
| Property | 15CrMo Substrate | Hardfacing Metal | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hardness (HB) | 180-220 | 45-55 HRC | Hardfacing is significantly harder |
| Yield strength (MPa) | 280-320 | 400-500 | Hardfacing has higher strength |
| Elongation (%) | 20-25 | 5-10 | Hardfacing is more brittle |
| Impact toughness (J) | 50-60 | 20-30 | Hardfacing has lower toughness |
| Thermal conductivity | Higher | Lower | Hardfacing has lower conductivity |
The authors found that the hardfacing metal has significantly higher hardness and strength but lower toughness and thermal conductivity. This means that the hardfacing layer provides excellent wear resistance but is more susceptible to cracking under thermal shock. The welding process must therefore be carefully controlled to minimize residual stress and avoid cracking.
Welding Process and Parameter Optimization
The paper describes the selection and optimization of the welding process parameters. The authors chose single-wire SAW because it is a mature, widely used technology that offers high deposition rates and good weld quality. The critical parameters include:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Preheat temperature | 200-300°C | Prevents HAZ cracking |
| Interpass temperature | 250-350°C | Controls residual stress |
| Welding current | 350-450 A | Deposition rate control |
| Arc voltage | 28-32 V | Arc stability |
| Travel speed | 30-50 cm/min | Bead overlap control |
| Bead overlap | 30-50% | Ensures uniform coverage |
| Wire diameter | 3.2-4.0 mm | Deposition rate control |
The authors emphasize that preheating is essential to prevent cracking in the heat-affected zone. Without proper preheat, the HAZ in the 15CrMo substrate will crack due to the high hardness of the hardfacing alloy and the high cooling rate.
Industrial Trial Results
The paper reports the results of industrial trials with the hardfaced composite rolls. The rolls were installed in a continuous casting machine and operated under normal production conditions. The results showed that the hardfaced composite rolls achieved a service life 3-6 times longer than conventional 15CrMo rolls. The failure mode of the hardfaced rolls was gradual wear of the hardfacing layer, rather than catastrophic cracking or spalling, indicating that the welding process was well controlled.
Engineering Practice Insights
The Importance of Welding Procedure Qualification
The paper emphasizes the importance of welding procedure qualification. Before production, the welding procedure must be qualified on a representative test piece, and the hardfacing layer must be tested for hardness, bond strength, and crack resistance. In my experience, this is the single most important step in ensuring the success of a hardfacing operation. A welding procedure that has not been qualified is a recipe for disaster.
The Role of Preheat and Interpass Temperature
The paper correctly identifies preheat and interpass temperature as critical parameters. In my experience, the most common cause of hardfacing failure is inadequate preheat. If the substrate is not preheated to the correct temperature, the HAZ will crack, and the hardfacing layer will spall in service. The interpass temperature is equally important: if it is too high, the hardfacing metal will have a coarse microstructure and reduced hardness; if it is too low, the residual stress will be excessive, leading to cracking.
The Economics of Composite Rolls
The paper does not provide detailed economic analysis, but the logic is clear. A hardfaced composite roll costs more to manufacture than a conventional roll, but the service life is 3-6 times longer. This means that the cost per ton of steel produced is significantly lower with composite rolls. In addition, the reduced frequency of roll changes means less downtime and higher productivity.
The Failure Mode of Composite Rolls
The paper reports that the failure mode of the hardfaced rolls is gradual wear of the hardfacing layer. This is the ideal failure mode, as it allows the roll to be re-hardfaced and returned to service. If the failure mode were cracking or spalling, the roll would need to be replaced, which is much more expensive. The key to achieving this ideal failure mode is proper welding procedure qualification and careful control of the welding parameters.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Is Single-Wire SAW the Preferred Process?
The paper chose single-wire SAW because it is a mature, widely used technology. In my experience, this is a sound choice for several reasons:
- High deposition rate: SAW can deposit large amounts of metal quickly, reducing the time required to hardface a roll.
- Good weld quality: SAW produces a sound, dense deposit with minimal porosity.
- Low operator skill requirement: SAW is a mechanized process that does not require the same level of manual skill as GTAW or SMAW.
- Cost-effectiveness: SAW is one of the most cost-effective hardfacing processes.
However, SAW has limitations. It is not suitable for hardfacing complex shapes or for hardfacing in positions other than flat or horizontal. For rolls, which are cylindrical, SAW is well suited because the roll can be rotated under the welding head.
What Is the Role of the Hardfacing Alloy?
The paper does not provide detailed information on the hardfacing alloy, but the choice is critical. The alloy must provide excellent wear resistance while maintaining sufficient toughness to resist thermal fatigue cracking. In my experience, a high-chromium carbide alloy with a chromium content of 15-25% and a carbon content of 3-5% is a good choice for continuous casting rolls. The alloy should also have good hot hardness, as the rolls operate at elevated temperatures.
What Are the Challenges of Hardfacing Continuous Casting Rolls?
Hardfacing continuous casting rolls presents several challenges:
- The rolls are large and heavy, requiring special handling equipment.
- The rolls have a complex geometry, with water cooling channels and bearing seats.
- The hardfacing layer must be applied uniformly to avoid imbalance.
- The welding process must be controlled to minimize distortion.
- The hardfacing layer must be free of cracks to avoid premature failure.
Study Insights and Implications
The Practical Value of This Paper
This paper is a valuable case study of the development and application of hardfaced composite rolls. It provides a clear example of how a systematic approach to material selection, welding procedure qualification, and parameter optimization can lead to a significant improvement in service life. The 3-6 times improvement in service life is a remarkable achievement, and it demonstrates the value of hardfacing technology in the steel industry.
What the Paper Does Not Say
The paper is from 1999 and does not cover the more advanced hardfacing technologies that are now available. For example, laser cladding and plasma transferred arc (PTA) welding offer better control of dilution and a more uniform deposit. However, the fundamental principles remain the same: match the alloy to the service conditions, control the welding parameters, and manage the wear proactively.
Reference Value and Outlook
Standards and Specifications
The paper references the company's internal technical specifications, but in practice, hardfacing of continuous casting rolls is governed by the same principles as any other surfacing operation. The relevant standards include ASME Section IX for welding procedure qualification, ISO 15614 for procedure qualification, and various material standards for the hardfacing alloys.
Future Directions
The paper is from 1999, and the field has advanced considerably. Modern continuous casting rolls often use composite structures with a wear-resistant insert or a specially designed hardfacing alloy. Laser cladding and PTA welding are now used for high-precision hardfacing, offering better control of dilution and a more uniform deposit. However, the fundamental principles remain the same: match the alloy to the service conditions, control the welding parameters, and manage the wear proactively.
Summary
This paper is an excellent case study of the development and application of hardfaced composite rolls for continuous casting. It demonstrates that a systematic approach to material selection, welding procedure qualification, and parameter optimization can lead to a significant improvement in service life. The 3-6 times improvement in service life is a remarkable achievement, and it validates the use of single-wire SAW for hardfacing continuous casting rolls. The key takeaways for the plant engineer are: choose the hardfacing alloy based on the specific service conditions, qualify the welding procedure before production, preheat properly to avoid HAZ cracking, and monitor roll wear so that re-hardfacing can be planned rather than reactive. In my experience, plants that follow these principles achieve roll service lives measured in years, while those that do not are constantly fighting fires. The paper is a good starting point, but the reader should supplement it with more detailed metallurgical and process data before making a final decision on alloy selection and welding parameters.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd