Microstructure and Properties of Hardfacing Deposited Metal on 45 Steel
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper by Xie Jun et al. from Xihua University and Sichuan Atlantic Welding Materials Co., published in the Journal of Xihua University in 2006, examines the microstructure and properties of hardfacing deposits on 45 steel using two different electrodes: CHR172 and CHR132. The authors analyzed the microstructure of the weld metal and the heat-affected zone (HAZ), and measured the microhardness of the deposits.
The results are straightforward. The microstructure and microhardness of the deposited metal depend on both the electrode type and the welding parameters. The CHR172 electrode produced a deposit with better hardness than the CHR132 electrode. This is a simple, practical result that directly addresses the question of electrode selection for hardfacing on medium carbon steel.
Technical Interpretation and Process Analysis
The 45 steel substrate is a medium carbon steel with a carbon content of approximately 0.45%. It is a common material for shafts, gears, and rolls, and it is often hardfaced to improve wear resistance. The challenge with hardfacing on medium carbon steel is the heat-affected zone — the carbon content is high enough that the HAZ can transform to martensite, which is hard and brittle.
The CHR172 and CHR132 electrodes are both chromium-based hardfacing electrodes, but they differ in alloy content. CHR172 is likely a higher-alloy electrode that produces a deposit with more carbides and higher hardness. The paper's finding that CHR172 produces a harder deposit is consistent with this expectation.
The welding parameters are important because they control the dilution of the deposit with the substrate. Higher heat input increases dilution, which reduces the alloy content of the deposit and lowers its hardness. Lower heat input reduces dilution, which increases the alloy content and hardness, but also increases the risk of cracking in the HAZ.
Engineering Practice Integration and Lessons Learned
This paper addresses a practical question that every maintenance welder faces: which electrode should I use for hardfacing this shaft? The answer from this paper is clear: CHR172 is the better choice for hardness. However, the paper does not address the other critical factor — the weldability of the substrate.
In my experience, hardfacing on 45 steel requires careful preheat and post-weld treatment to prevent HAZ cracking. The HAZ of 45 steel can transform to martensite, which is hard and brittle. If the preheat is insufficient, the HAZ will crack, and the hardfacing will spall. The paper does not discuss preheat or post-weld treatment, which is a gap in the research.
The practical implication is that electrode selection is only part of the equation. The welding procedure — preheat, interpass temperature, and post-weld treatment — is equally important. A plant that selects the right electrode but uses the wrong procedure will still experience failures.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper compares two electrodes, but it does not provide the chemical composition of the deposits. This is a significant gap, because the hardness difference between the two electrodes is likely due to differences in alloy content, and knowing the composition would allow a more informed selection.
The paper also does not address the wear resistance of the deposits. Hardness is a useful indicator, but it is not the same as wear resistance. A deposit with high hardness but low toughness may have poor wear resistance under impact conditions. The paper would be more valuable if it included wear testing.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a useful contribution because it provides a direct comparison of two commercially available hardfacing electrodes on a common substrate. The finding that CHR172 produces a harder deposit than CHR132 is a practical result that can be applied immediately on the shop floor.
The practical takeaway is that electrode selection matters, but it is not the only factor. The welding procedure, including preheat and post-weld treatment, is equally important for achieving a sound, durable hardfacing on medium carbon steel. A plant that focuses only on electrode selection will not achieve the best results.
The reference value of this work is in its demonstration that electrode selection has a measurable effect on deposit hardness. The outlook is that we will see more research on the effect of welding parameters on hardfacing quality, and that the industry will continue to refine its hardfacing procedures to achieve the best balance of hardness, toughness, and crack resistance. For our industry, where hardfacing is used on a wide range of components, this is a direction that will pay dividends in reduced downtime and lower maintenance costs.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd