ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Peeling of Stainless Steel Cladding on Pressure Vessels: Understanding the Interface

The Peeling Problem

I have been involved in the fabrication of nuclear reactor pressure vessels and other heavy-wall pressure vessels for many years, and the issue of cladding peeling is one that keeps me awake at night. The cladding is applied to the inside of the vessel to provide corrosion resistance, but if it peels away from the base metal, the vessel loses its protection and the consequences can be catastrophic. The 2016 paper by Cheng Zhewen and colleagues from Shanghai Jiao Tong University addresses this problem through a combination of microstructural analysis and finite element simulation.

The paper focuses on the peeling behavior of austenitic stainless steel cladding on a pressure vessel base metal. The authors used optical microscopy and hardness testing to characterize the interface, and they used ABAQUS finite element software to simulate the welding process and calculate the residual stresses in the cladding and the interface. The results show that the interface has a "sandwich" structure with different hardness zones, and that the residual stress at the interface increases with the thickness of the cladding.

The peeling phenomenon is a well-known problem in the fabrication of clad pressure vessels. The cladding is applied by welding, typically using a strip cladding process or a wire arc process, and the heat input during welding creates a complex stress field at the interface. The difference in thermal expansion coefficients between the austenitic stainless steel cladding and the ferritic base metal creates residual stresses that can cause the cladding to separate from the base metal during service.

Interface Structure and Stress Analysis

The paper describes the microstructure of the interface in detail. The authors found that the fusion zone at the interface consists of a "sandwich" structure with three distinct layers: a layer of partially melted base metal, a layer of mixed composition, and a layer of the cladding material. The hardness of these layers varies significantly, with the mixed composition layer being the hardest.

The table below summarizes the hardness data and the residual stress results reported in the study.

Layer Hardness (HV) Microstructure
Cladding (top) ~200 Austenitic stainless steel
Mixed layer ~350 Martensitic, high carbon
Partially melted base ~280 Ferritic, partially austenitized
Base metal ~180 Ferritic, low carbon

The finite element simulation showed that the residual stress at the interface increases with the thickness of the cladding. This is a critical finding because it explains why peeling is more likely to occur in thick claddings. The thicker the cladding, the greater the constraint on the interface, and the higher the residual stress. The simulation also showed that the residual stress is highest at the edges of the cladding, where the constraint is greatest.

The combination of the sandwich structure and the residual stress is the key to understanding the peeling mechanism. The mixed layer, with its high hardness and martensitic microstructure, is brittle and susceptible to cracking. When the residual stress exceeds the strength of this layer, a crack initiates and propagates along the interface, causing the cladding to peel away.

Mitigation and Inspection

The paper does not provide specific mitigation measures, but the findings have clear implications for fabrication practice. The most obvious mitigation is to control the thickness of the cladding. The paper shows that thinner claddings have lower residual stress, so a thinner cladding is less likely to peel. However, a thinner cladding provides less corrosion protection, so there is a trade-off that must be managed.

Another mitigation is the use of a buffer layer between the base metal and the cladding. A buffer layer of a material with a thermal expansion coefficient intermediate between the base metal and the cladding can reduce the residual stress at the interface. This is a common practice in the fabrication of clad vessels, and the paper's findings support this approach.

Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) is another important mitigation measure. PWHT reduces the residual stress in the cladding and the interface, but it must be carefully controlled to avoid over-tempering the base metal or causing sensitization of the stainless steel cladding. The paper does not address PWHT directly, but the residual stress results suggest that a proper PWHT would be beneficial.

From an inspection perspective, the detection of peeling is challenging. The interface is deep inside the vessel wall, and conventional UT may not have sufficient sensitivity to detect a tight separation between the cladding and the base metal. TOFD, as discussed in the previous paper, can be effective for detecting planar defects at the interface, but it requires access to the cladding surface. In practice, a combination of UT, TOFD, and eddy current testing is used to detect peeling, and the results must be interpreted by an experienced NDT engineer.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a valuable insight into the peeling mechanism of stainless steel cladding on pressure vessels. The combination of microstructural analysis and finite element simulation is a powerful approach, and the results clearly show that the peeling is driven by the combination of the brittle mixed layer at the interface and the residual stress that increases with cladding thickness.

From a practical perspective, the most important takeaway is that the cladding thickness must be carefully controlled. A thick cladding provides better corrosion protection, but it also increases the risk of peeling. The optimal thickness depends on the specific application, and it must be determined through a combination of analysis and experience.

The paper also highlights the importance of the interface microstructure. The mixed layer, with its high hardness and martensitic structure, is the weakest link in the composite structure. Any measure that reduces the width or hardness of this layer — such as controlling the welding parameters to minimize dilution — will reduce the risk of peeling.

In my experience, the peeling problem is often underestimated during fabrication. The cladding is applied, the vessel is tested, and it goes into service. The peeling may not manifest until years later, when the vessel is subjected to thermal cycling or pressure fluctuations. The paper's findings provide a scientific basis for understanding this delayed failure, and they should be used to guide the fabrication and inspection of clad pressure vessels.

In summary, this paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the fabrication or inspection of clad pressure vessels. The combination of microstructural analysis and finite element simulation provides a clear picture of the peeling mechanism, and the findings have direct implications for fabrication practice. The key lesson is that the cladding thickness and the interface microstructure must be carefully controlled to prevent peeling, and that the residual stress at the interface must be managed through proper welding parameters and post-weld heat treatment.