ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Overlay Welding Repair of Worn Journals on Cross Shafts

Literature Overview and Technical Background

This 2011 paper from Sany Heavy Industry addresses a problem that is common across the construction equipment industry: the wear of journals on cross shafts, which are critical components in the universal joints of concrete pump trucks and other heavy machinery. The authors, Zhou Yuzhu and colleagues, report on the repair of worn journals by overlay welding, and they make a strong economic case for repair rather than replacement. For a concrete pump truck, the cross shaft is a relatively small component, but its failure can immobilise the entire machine. The cost of a new cross shaft is modest, but the cost of downtime and labour to replace it can be many times the cost of the part itself. Repair by overlay welding offers a way to extend the service life of the component without the cost and downtime of replacement.

The authors begin by noting that shaft components in general are subject to a variety of failure modes, including wear, fatigue, and fracture. In the case of concrete pump truck cross shafts, the dominant failure mode is wear on the journal surfaces. This is not surprising. The cross shaft operates in a high-load, low-speed, oscillating environment, with the journal surfaces in contact with the bearing or bushing. The combination of high contact stress and relative sliding motion produces adhesive and abrasive wear, which gradually removes material from the journal surface. Once the journal diameter is reduced beyond the allowable tolerance, the bearing clearance becomes excessive, leading to increased vibration, noise, and ultimately failure.

The authors' approach is to repair the worn journal by overlay welding, building up the worn surface with weld metal and then machining it back to the original diameter and tolerance. This is a well-established repair technique for shaft components, but it requires careful attention to a number of critical factors, including the choice of filler metal, the welding process, the heat input, and the post-weld machining and finishing operations.

Interpretation of the Repair Approach and Metallurgical Considerations

The key metallurgical challenge in repairing a worn journal is to deposit a layer of weld metal that has sufficient hardness and wear resistance to match or exceed the original material, while maintaining adequate toughness to withstand the cyclic loading that the journal experiences in service. The cross shaft is typically made from a medium-carbon alloy steel, such as 42CrMo or similar, which is hardened and tempered to achieve a good combination of strength and toughness. The overlay weld must therefore be compatible with this base material and must be able to withstand the same service conditions.

The authors do not specify the exact filler metal used in their repair, but based on my experience with similar repairs, I would expect them to use a low-alloy steel filler metal with a hardness in the range of 30 to 40 HRC after post-weld heat treatment. The filler metal must be selected to match the coefficient of thermal expansion of the base metal to minimise residual stresses, and it must have sufficient hardenability to achieve the required hardness after welding and heat treatment.

One of the critical issues in any shaft repair is the effect of the welding thermal cycle on the base metal. The welding heat input will create a heat-affected zone (HAZ) in the base metal, which can have a significant effect on its mechanical properties. In a hardened and tempered steel, the HAZ will be over-tempered, which reduces the hardness and strength of the base metal in that region. If the HAZ is on a highly stressed area of the shaft, this can lead to premature failure. The authors must therefore ensure that the welding process is controlled to minimise the width of the HAZ and that the post-weld heat treatment restores the properties of the base metal as much as possible.

Another critical issue is the residual stresses that are introduced by the welding process. The weld metal contracts as it cools, which creates tensile residual stresses in the weld and compressive residual stresses in the surrounding base metal. If the residual stresses are high enough, they can cause distortion of the shaft or even cracking. The authors must therefore ensure that the welding sequence is designed to minimise distortion and that the post-weld heat treatment is sufficient to relieve the residual stresses.

Process Parameters and Practical Considerations

Based on the authors' work and my own experience with shaft repair, I would summarise the practical process parameters for this type of repair as follows.

Parameter Recommended Range Practical Notes
Pre-weld surface preparation Machine or grind to sound metal Remove all worn, cracked, or contaminated material.
Preheating 150 to 250 °C For medium-carbon alloy steel, preheating is essential to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking.
Welding process GMAW or FCAW Both are suitable for shaft repair; GMAW with pulsed current gives better control.
Filler metal Low-alloy steel, matching base metal Typically 0.2 to 0.3 percent carbon, with alloying elements to match hardenability.
Welding current 150 to 250 A Depends on electrode diameter and deposition rate required.
Interpass temperature 200 to 300 °C Must be controlled to prevent overheating and excessive HAZ.
Post-weld heat treatment 550 to 650 °C for 1 to 2 hours Stress relief and tempering to restore toughness.
Post-weld machining Grind or turn to final diameter Must be done after heat treatment to achieve final tolerance.

One of the most important practical considerations is the welding sequence. The weld should be deposited in a balanced sequence, alternating between opposite sides of the shaft to minimise distortion. The weld should be built up in multiple passes, with each pass overlapping the previous one to ensure good fusion and to avoid lack of fusion or slag inclusions. The weld should be built up to a diameter slightly larger than the final required diameter, to allow for machining and to ensure that the final surface is entirely weld metal and not a mixture of weld metal and base metal.

Another critical practical consideration is the inspection of the repaired shaft. After welding and before machining, the shaft should be inspected by magnetic particle or dye penetrant testing to ensure that there are no cracks in the weld or the HAZ. After machining, the shaft should be checked for dimensional accuracy, surface finish, and hardness. If the hardness is not within the required range, the shaft may need to be re-heat-treated.

Integration with Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

This paper is a good example of the kind of practical repair technology that keeps construction equipment running. The authors have correctly identified that the dominant failure mode of cross shaft journals is wear, and they have proposed a repair strategy that is both technically sound and economically attractive. The repair approach is well established in the industry, but the paper serves as a useful reminder of the key factors that must be controlled to ensure a successful repair.

In my experience, the most common cause of failure in shaft repairs is inadequate preheating or interpass temperature control. If the shaft is not preheated sufficiently, the weld will cool too quickly, and the hydrogen in the weld metal will not have time to diffuse out. This leads to hydrogen-induced cracking, which can occur hours or even days after welding. The crack may not be visible on the surface, but it will propagate under the cyclic loading that the shaft experiences in service, leading to premature failure. The authors' emphasis on proper preheating and interpass temperature control is therefore well placed.

Another common cause of failure is insufficient post-weld heat treatment. If the shaft is not stress-relieved after welding, the residual stresses will remain in the shaft, and they will combine with the service stresses to cause premature fatigue failure. The post-weld heat treatment must be performed at the correct temperature and for the correct duration to ensure that the residual stresses are fully relieved and that the base metal properties are restored.

The economic case for this repair is compelling. The cost of repairing a worn cross shaft is typically 30 to 50 percent of the cost of a new one, and the repair can be completed in a fraction of the time required to obtain a replacement part. For a concrete pump truck that is out of service, the cost of downtime can be many times the cost of the repair itself, so the ability to repair the shaft quickly and reliably is of great value.

Study Insights and Conclusions

This paper is a valuable contribution to the practical literature on shaft repair by overlay welding. The authors have correctly identified the failure mode and proposed a sound repair strategy. The key technical insights are that the repair must be performed with proper preheating, interpass temperature control, and post-weld heat treatment to prevent cracking and to restore the properties of the base metal. The repair is economically attractive and technically sound when executed correctly.

For the practising engineer, the takeaway is clear: worn shaft journals can be repaired successfully by overlay welding, but only with the right filler metal, the right process parameters, and the right discipline. The repair is not a substitute for proper maintenance, but it can extend the service life of the component significantly and save considerable cost. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in the maintenance of construction equipment, and I would encourage them to develop a written repair procedure based on these principles, with specific process parameters and inspection requirements, before attempting a repair on a critical component.