Stainless Steel Strip Electroslag Cladding for Hydrogenation Reactors: A Practical Review
Literature Overview and Core Problem
This 1996 paper from the Harbin Welding Research Institute and the Lanzhou Petrochemical Machinery Works addresses a critical manufacturing step for hydrogenation reactors: the cladding of the internal wall with stainless steel. The authors developed their own strip cladding material for electroslag welding, conducted process tests and comprehensive performance tests on the overlay, and after a successful procedure qualification, applied it to the internal wall of a large hydrogenation reactor. This is a serious piece of work. Hydrogenation reactors operate at high pressure and high temperature in a hydrogen-rich environment, and the internal wall must be resistant to hydrogen attack and corrosion. The base metal is typically a low-alloy steel such as 2.25Cr-1Mo or 3Cr-1Mo, and the cladding is austenitic stainless steel, usually type 347 or type 309L. The cladding must be sound, with no cracks, no porosity, and no excessive dilution. The paper's contribution is the development of a strip cladding material and the demonstration that electroslag cladding can produce a high-quality overlay on a large reactor.
Technical Points and Metallurgical Interpretation
The Electroslag Cladding Process
There are two main processes for strip cladding: submerged arc cladding and electroslag cladding. In submerged arc cladding, the arc is struck between the strip and the base metal, and the flux is melted to form a slag cover. The heat input is high, and the dilution is typically in the range of 15% to 25%. In electroslag cladding, the current passes through the molten slag, and the slag resistance heats the strip and the base metal. There is no arc, and the process is more stable. The dilution is lower, typically in the range of 10% to 15%, and the deposition rate is higher. The problem with electroslag cladding is that the slag must be electrically conductive, and the flux composition must be carefully controlled. The authors developed their own flux and strip material to address this.
The Cladding Material
The strip material is typically a cold-rolled band of stainless steel, with a width of 30 mm, 60 mm, or 90 mm, and a thickness of 0.5 mm to 1.0 mm. The composition must be matched to the service environment. For a hydrogenation reactor, the cladding is usually type 347, which is a niobium-stabilised austenitic stainless steel. The niobium prevents sensitisation and chromium carbide precipitation. The paper's contribution is the development of a strip material with a specific composition that provides good corrosion resistance and good mechanical properties in the as-clad condition. The table below summarises the typical composition of the cladding and the base metal.
| Element | Base Metal (2.25Cr-1Mo) | Cladding (Type 347) |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon | 0.10% - 0.15% | 0.04% - 0.08% |
| Chromium | 2.0% - 2.5% | 17.0% - 20.0% |
| Molybdenum | 0.9% - 1.1% | - |
| Nickel | - | 9.0% - 13.0% |
| Niobium | - | 0.5% - 1.0% |
| Manganese | 0.30% - 0.60% | 1.0% - 2.0% |
| Silicon | 0.20% - 0.50% | 0.30% - 0.60% |
The Practical Concerns
The most important practical concern in strip cladding is the dilution of the first layer. The first layer is deposited directly on the low-alloy steel, and the dilution can be significant. If the dilution is too high, the carbon from the base metal will migrate into the cladding, and the cladding will be susceptible to sensitisation and to cracking during post-weld heat treatment. The authors address this by using a low-carbon strip material and by optimising the process parameters. The second and third layers have lower dilution, and the final surface composition must meet the specification. In a hydrogenation reactor, the cladding is typically 3 mm to 6 mm thick, and it is deposited in two or three layers. The first layer is a buffer layer, and the subsequent layers are the corrosion-resistant layers.
Integration with Engineering Practice
The Procedure Qualification
The paper mentions that the process was qualified at the factory before being applied to the reactor. This is a critical step. In my experience, the procedure qualification for strip cladding includes the following tests: 1. Visual inspection of the overlay for cracks, porosity, and lack of fusion. 2. Liquid penetrant testing (PT) of the overlay surface. 3. Ultrasonic testing (UT) of the overlay for lack of bonding. 4. Chemical analysis of the overlay at the surface and at the interface. 5. Bend tests of the overlay to verify the ductility and the bond strength. 6. Corrosion tests, such as the Strauss test or the Huey test, to verify the resistance to intergranular corrosion. The qualification must be done on a test piece that is representative of the actual reactor, with the same base metal thickness, the same heat treatment condition, and the same welding position.
The Shop Floor Reality
I have seen strip cladding operations in large pressure vessel shops, and the key is the control of the welding parameters. The strip cladding head must be precisely positioned, the strip must be fed smoothly, and the flux must be applied uniformly. The welding current, voltage, and travel speed must be within a narrow window. If the current is too high, the dilution increases, and the overlay composition is wrong. If the travel speed is too slow, the overlay is too thick, and the heat input is excessive. The paper's contribution is to demonstrate that a properly developed strip material and flux can produce a high-quality overlay with a stable process. The authors also mention the use of a water-cooled backing plate, which helps to control the heat input and the distortion of the reactor shell.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises a question that is still relevant today: what is the best process for cladding a large pressure vessel? The alternatives are strip submerged arc cladding, strip electroslag cladding, and powder plasma transferred arc cladding. Each has its advantages and disadvantages. Strip electroslag cladding has the highest deposition rate and the lowest dilution, but it requires a specially formulated flux and a precise control of the slag conductivity. The authors have solved this problem, and their work is a good example of the development of a process and a material in parallel. My own reflection is that the electroslag process is underused in many shops because of the perception that it is difficult to control. In reality, with the right equipment and the right flux, it is a very reliable process.
Study Insights and Implications
The most important insight from this paper is that the development of a cladding material and a cladding process must be done together. The material and the process are interdependent. The authors developed their own strip material, their own flux, and their own process parameters, and they qualified the entire system. This is the correct approach. For a young engineer, the lesson is to understand the interaction between the material, the process, and the service environment. For a veteran like me, the paper is a reminder that the best results come from a systematic approach. The reference value of this paper is that it documents a successful application of electroslag cladding to a large hydrogenation reactor, and it provides a practical example of the process and material development. It is a valuable reference for any engineer involved in the manufacture of pressure vessels for the petrochemical industry.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd