ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Overlay Welding of Brake Hubs for Oil Drilling Rig Drawworks

Literature Overview and Core Problem

This paper from the 2005 issue of Welding addresses a practical manufacturing headache that I have seen more times than I care to remember: the traditional fabrication route for a large, safety-critical component is so long and so prone to cracking that the shop floor treats it as a necessary evil. The brake hub of a drilling rig drawworks is exactly that kind of component. The authors describe the conventional process route as casting → normalizing → rough machining → riveting/welding → stress relief → quenching and tempering → rough machining → welding the water chamber → machining → surface hardening → assembly. Each step adds cost, adds handling, and adds risk. The casting blank is heavy, the machining allowance is generous, and the material is cast medium-carbon alloy steel 35CrMo, which has notoriously poor weldability. When you try to weld the attachment parts — the connecting plate and the cooling water chamber, both in Q235A — onto this rigid cast structure, you are asking for trouble. The high structural rigidity combined with the dissimilar material joint means that any slight mistake in preheat, interpass temperature, or post-weld cooling will produce a crack that can take the whole hub out of service.

Technical Interpretation: Why the Traditional Route Fails

The fundamental issue here is that the traditional route treats the brake hub as a casting that happens to need some welding, rather than as a weldment that needs to be designed and processed as one. Let me break down the metallurgical and mechanical problems.

Weldability of 35CrMo

35CrMo is a chromium-molybdenum medium-carbon alloy steel. Its carbon equivalent is high, and its hardenability is significant. When you weld it, the heat-affected zone (HAZ) will transform to martensite if the cooling rate is too fast, and that martensite is hard, brittle, and susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking. The paper correctly notes that preheating and post-weld holding are often required, which adds cycle time and makes the shop floor schedule unpredictable.

Property 35CrMo (Cast) Q235A (Wrought)
Carbon content, % 0.32–0.40 ≤0.20
Carbon equivalent, CE ~0.65–0.75 ~0.35
Weldability Poor, requires preheat and PWHT Good
Structural rigidity High (cast section) Low (plate)

The Dissimilar Material Joint

Welding Q235A to cast 35CrMo creates a joint where the carbon content jumps from about 0.20% to over 0.35% across the fusion line. This carbon gradient drives carbon migration during welding and during any subsequent heat treatment. The result is a soft, decarburized zone on the Q235A side and a hard, carburized zone on the 35CrMo side. The hard zone is prone to cold cracking, and the soft zone reduces the joint's load-carrying capacity. Add the high restraint of the cast hub, and you have a recipe for transverse cracking right along the fusion line.

Engineering Practice: The Overlay Welding Alternative

The paper's contribution is to propose an alternative route that replaces the cast hub with a fabricated weldment, using overlay welding to build up the brake surface. I have seen this approach work in practice, and it addresses several problems at once.

The New Process Route

The proposed route is essentially: fabricate the hub body from rolled plate or forgings, weld the connecting plate and water chamber using proper joint design and preheat, then apply overlay welding on the brake drum surface to achieve the required wear resistance and hardness. This eliminates the heavy casting, reduces the machining allowance, shortens the manufacturing cycle, and removes the most troublesome dissimilar material joint because the base material is now a weldable structural steel.

Key Process Parameters

From my experience with similar overlay applications on brake drums and sheave wheels, the following parameters are critical.

Parameter Recommended Range Notes
Preheat temperature 150–250 °C Depends on base material thickness and CE
Interpass temperature 200–300 °C Must be controlled to avoid overheating
Welding process SAW or FCAW SAW for large area, FCAW for positional
Electrode/wire Low-hydrogen type E7018 or equivalent for the buffer layer
Post-weld heat treatment 600–650 °C, 2 h Stress relief, slow cool to 300 °C
Overlay hardness 35–45 HRC For brake surface, may need surface hardening

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that every production manager should ask: why are we casting a component that could be fabricated more cheaply and more reliably? The answer, of course, is that the casting route was established decades ago when fabrication technology was less advanced. But the industry has moved on. Overlay welding, combined with modern NDT, can produce a brake hub that is lighter, cheaper, and more reliable than the cast version.

I have seen the failure mode described in this paper on more than one occasion. A brake hub cracks during the water chamber welding, the shop tries to repair it with a small electrode and a lot of hope, and the crack propagates through the hub during the first heavy braking cycle. The result is a scrapped component and a delayed rig. The overlay welding route, with proper preheat control and a low-hydrogen consumable, eliminates that failure mode at the source.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of how a manufacturing process improvement can have a direct impact on safety and cost. The traditional route is not just expensive; it is risky. Every weld on a rigid cast structure is a potential crack initiation site. By moving to a fabricated design with overlay welding, the manufacturer gains control over the material, the joint design, and the welding process. The result is a component that is easier to inspect, easier to repair, and more predictable in service.

For engineers in the oilfield equipment business, the lesson is clear: do not accept a manufacturing route just because it has always been done that way. Question the material selection, question the joint design, and question the welding process. The brake hub is a safety-critical component, and it deserves the same engineering attention as the drill pipe or the casing string.