PLC-Based Automatic Control System for Half-Circumferential Surfacing of Boiler Superheater Tubes
Introduction and Industry Context
This 2017 paper from Jiaxing Vocational and Technical College and Dongfang Special Steel describes the development of a PLC-based automatic control system for the half-circumferential surfacing of boiler superheater tubes. The application is the repair of superheater tubes that have suffered from high-temperature corrosion or erosion, which is a common problem in power plants. The traditional approach is manual welding, which is slow, inconsistent and dependent on the skill of the welder. The paper describes the development of an automated system that uses a Mitsubishi FX series PLC as the core controller, communicating with the welding machine and coordinating three-axis servo motors to achieve the required half-circumferential weld pattern.
For a veteran who has spent years on the shop floor, the move from manual to automated welding is always a welcome one, provided it is done correctly. The paper describes a system that is not only automated but also flexible, allowing the operator to set parameters for different tube diameters through a touchscreen interface. This flexibility is critical in a plant where tubes of various sizes may need to be repaired.
System Architecture and Control Strategy
The system is based on a Mitsubishi FX series PLC, which is a reliable and widely used controller in the industry. The architecture is as follows.
| Component | Function |
|---|---|
| Mitsubishi FX PLC | Core controller, executes the welding sequence |
| Touchscreen HMI | Operator interface for parameter setting and monitoring |
| Welding machine interface | Communication between PLC and welding power source |
| X-axis servo motor | Controls the linear travel of the welding torch |
| Y-axis servo motor | Controls the vertical position of the torch |
| Z-axis servo motor | Controls the torch height and the welding angle |
The control strategy involves coordinating the three servo motors to achieve the half-circumferential weld pattern. The tube is held stationary, and the welding torch moves around the half-circumference while simultaneously moving along the tube axis to create the required weld width. The PLC coordinates the motion of the three axes to ensure a uniform weld bead with consistent deposition.
The paper reports that the system can be programmed through the touchscreen to accommodate different tube diameters and welding requirements. This is a significant advantage over a fixed automation system, which would require mechanical adjustment for each tube size.
Practical Implementation and Results
The paper reports that the system was tested in a factory trial and achieved the following results.
| Performance Indicator | Manual Welding | Automated System |
|---|---|---|
| Welding precision | Dependent on welder skill | Consistent, high precision |
| Welding speed | Low, limited by welder fatigue | Significantly higher |
| Labour cost | High, requires skilled welder | Reduced, one operator can supervise multiple machines |
| Weld quality | Variable, prone to defects | Consistent, uniform bead geometry |
The key improvement is the consistency of the weld. A manual welder will inevitably produce a weld that varies in width and penetration along the length of the tube. The automated system, with its precise control of the three axes, produces a uniform weld that is repeatable from tube to tube. This is critical for the integrity of the repair, as a weld that is too thin in one spot may fail prematurely, while a weld that is too thick may cause distortion or burn-through.
The paper also reports that the system improves the working environment by removing the welder from the immediate vicinity of the arc. This is an important consideration, as welding fumes and arc radiation are significant health hazards.
Lessons from the Shop Floor
From my own experience, there are several factors that determine the success of an automated welding system, and this paper addresses most of them.
- Fixture design. The tube must be held securely and accurately. Any movement of the tube during welding will result in a defective weld. The paper does not describe the fixture in detail, but it is a critical element.
- Sensor feedback. The system described appears to be open-loop, relying on the servo motors to maintain the correct position. In a production environment, a closed-loop system with a welding seam tracker would be more robust, as it can compensate for variations in tube diameter or surface condition.
- Parameter optimisation. The welding parameters, such as current, voltage and travel speed, must be optimised for the specific tube material and wall thickness. The touchscreen interface allows this, but it requires a skilled engineer to determine the correct values.
- Maintenance. A servo-driven system requires regular maintenance to ensure the accuracy is maintained. This is a factor that is often overlooked but is essential for long-term reliability.
The paper describes a system that is well-suited to its intended application. It is not a fully autonomous system, but it achieves a significant improvement over manual welding in terms of consistency, speed and cost.
Concluding Remarks
This paper is a practical demonstration of how a relatively simple PLC-based control system can bring significant benefits to a repetitive welding operation. The use of a Mitsubishi FX PLC with three-axis servo control and a touchscreen interface provides a flexible and cost-effective solution for the half-circumferential surfacing of boiler superheater tubes. The results show improved weld quality, higher productivity and reduced labour costs. For a plant that is considering automating a similar operation, this paper provides a useful reference. The key lessons are the importance of a well-designed fixture, the need for accurate parameter setting, and the value of a flexible control system that can accommodate different tube sizes. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in the repair of boiler tubes or similar cylindrical components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd