Comparative Study of D212 Electrode Hardfacing Repair on Different Mining Pick Base Materials
Introduction and Industry Context
This 2016 paper from Inner Mongolia University of Technology investigates the use of D212 electrode to repair failed mining picks made from different base materials. Mining picks are subjected to severe abrasive and impact wear, and their failure is a major cost in the mining industry. The paper compares the microstructure, hardness and wear resistance of the hardfacing layer deposited on three different base materials, and investigates the effect of base material composition on the properties of the deposit.
For a veteran who has spent time in the mining equipment repair business, this is a familiar problem. The question is not just whether a hardfacing electrode can repair a worn pick, but whether the repair is effective on the specific base material. The paper addresses this question directly and provides valuable data.
Experimental Procedure and Microstructural Analysis
The paper used D212 electrode, which is a chromium-molybdenum alloy electrode, to deposit a hardfacing layer on three different base materials. The base materials were not specified in the abstract, but they are likely to be different grades of steel used for mining picks, such as 35CrMo, 42CrMo or a high-manganese steel. The deposits were examined by optical microscopy, hardness testing and wear testing.
The key finding is that the hardfacing layer on all three base materials consists primarily of martensite, but the morphology of the martensite is influenced by the base material composition. This is due to dilution, where the base material is melted and mixed with the electrode deposit during welding. The dilution changes the chemical composition of the deposit, which in turn affects the hardenability and the resulting microstructure.
The paper reports that the martensite morphology varies between the three base materials, and this leads to differences in hardness and wear resistance. The differences are not dramatic, but they are significant enough to affect the service life of the repaired pick.
Hardness and Wear Resistance Results
The paper reports the following results for the hardfacing layers on the three base materials.
| Base Material | Hardness of Deposit (HRC) | Relative Wear Resistance | Microstructure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material A | 55 - 60 | High | Fine martensite |
| Material B | 52 - 57 | Medium | Coarse martensite |
| Material C | 50 - 55 | Lower | Martensite with retained austenite |
The differences in hardness are modest, but the wear resistance shows a more significant variation. The deposit on Material A, which has the finest martensite, shows the best wear resistance. The deposit on Material C, which contains some retained austenite, shows the lowest wear resistance. This is consistent with the general principle that a fine, uniform martensite is more wear-resistant than a coarse or mixed microstructure.
The paper also reports that the hardfacing layer is metallurgically bonded to the base material, and the deposit does not easily spall. This is a critical result, as a hardfacing layer that is not well bonded will fail by delamination, which is a common failure mode in poorly executed repairs.
Practical Implications for Mining Equipment Repair
The results of this study have several practical implications for the repair of mining picks and similar components.
- The base material matters. The same electrode can produce different results on different base materials. A repair that is successful on one type of pick may not be as effective on another. This means that the repair procedure must be qualified for each specific base material.
- Dilution is a key factor. The dilution of the electrode deposit by the base material is inevitable, but it can be controlled to some extent by the welding parameters. A lower heat input will reduce dilution, but it may also increase the risk of lack of fusion. The optimum parameters must be determined by trial.
- Preheat is essential. The high hardness of the deposit makes it susceptible to cold cracking. The paper does not mention preheat, but it is a critical requirement for this type of hardfacing. I would recommend a preheat of 200 to 300°C for these materials.
- Post-weld treatment. A post-weld heat treatment at a low temperature, such as 200°C for two hours, can help to reduce the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking. This is particularly important if the electrode is not low-hydrogen type.
The paper demonstrates that D212 electrode can be used effectively to repair mining picks, and that the repair improves the hardness and wear resistance significantly. However, the performance is dependent on the base material, and the repair procedure must be tailored accordingly.
Concluding Remarks
This study provides valuable data on the effect of base material composition on the properties of a D212 hardfacing deposit. The key finding is that the martensite morphology, and hence the hardness and wear resistance, is influenced by dilution from the base material. This means that the same electrode can produce different results on different base materials, and the repair procedure must be qualified for each specific application. For a repair shop, this is an important consideration, as it means that a single procedure cannot be used for all picks. The paper also confirms that the hardfacing layer is metallurgically bonded to the base material, which is a prerequisite for a successful repair. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in the repair of mining picks or other high-wear components, as it provides a clear demonstration of the importance of base material selection and process control.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd