ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Welding Consumables on Wear Resistance of Chromium Carbide Composite Hardfacing Plates

Literature Overview and Core Content

This 2014 paper from Tianjin Jinghua Petrochemical Co., Ltd. investigates the effect of welding consumables on the wear resistance of chromium carbide composite hardfacing plates. The study compares iron-based chromium carbide wires with iron-based chromium carbide plus boron wires, examining how the addition of boron affects the microstructure and wear performance of the hardfacing layer.

The paper addresses a practical industrial problem: sliding wear causes severe equipment component loss in industrial processing applications. Hardfacing plates are a well-known, economical, and practical wear-resistant material. The study's key findings are that the wear resistance of the hardfacing layer depends primarily on the volume fraction of carbides, surface hardness, and alloy composition. The boron carbide formed in the austenitic matrix increases the surface hardness of the hardfacing layer, and the fine boron carbide particles provide more nucleation sites for chromium carbide, increasing the number and volume fraction of chromium carbide grains, resulting in superior wear resistance compared to conventional chromium carbide composite hardfacing plates.

Technical Point Analysis

The study found a positive linear relationship between wear resistance and carbide volume fraction, but no strong correlation between wear resistance and surface hardness. This is a critical finding because it challenges the common assumption that harder materials are always more wear-resistant. The wear resistance also increases linearly with carbon content, and the optimal w(Cr)/w(C) ratio for forming the maximum amount of carbides is 4.1.

Parameter Conventional Chromium Carbide Boron-Added Chromium Carbide
Microstructure Austenite matrix with chromium carbide Austenite matrix with chromium carbide and boron carbide
Carbide nucleation sites Limited Increased due to fine boron carbide particles
Carbide volume fraction Baseline Higher
Surface hardness Baseline Higher
Wear resistance Baseline Superior
Optimal w(Cr)/w(C) ratio Not specified 4.1

The role of boron is particularly interesting from a metallurgical perspective. Boron is a strong carbide former and also acts as a grain refiner. The fine boron carbide particles provide nucleation sites for chromium carbide, which leads to a finer and more uniform distribution of carbides in the matrix. This is beneficial because a finer carbide distribution provides better resistance to abrasive wear, as the hard particles are more evenly distributed and less likely to be pulled out of the matrix.

Integration with Engineering Practice

In my experience with wear-resistant components in mining, cement, and steel processing, the choice of hardfacing consumable is critical. The paper's finding that wear resistance correlates more strongly with carbide volume fraction than with surface hardness is a valuable insight for engineers who are selecting hardfacing materials based on hardness specifications alone.

This is a common mistake in industry. Many specifications for wear-resistant components are written in terms of minimum hardness, but hardness alone does not guarantee good wear performance. The microstructure, particularly the type, size, and distribution of carbides, is equally important. The study shows that adding boron to the welding wire can improve wear resistance without necessarily increasing hardness proportionally.

The optimal w(Cr)/w(C) ratio of 4.1 is a practical guideline for alloy design. If the ratio is too high, there may be insufficient carbon to form carbides, resulting in a matrix that is too soft. If the ratio is too low, there may be excess carbon that forms brittle carbides at the grain boundaries, reducing toughness. The ratio of 4.1 represents a balance between these two extremes.

Lessons Learned and Reflections

The paper's finding that wear resistance is not strongly correlated with surface hardness is a reminder that we must look beyond simple hardness measurements when evaluating wear-resistant materials. In the field, I have seen components that met hardness specifications but failed prematurely due to poor carbide distribution or insufficient carbide volume fraction.

The addition of boron to the welding wire is a cost-effective way to improve wear resistance. Boron is relatively inexpensive and can be added in small amounts to achieve significant improvements in carbide formation and distribution. This is particularly important for large hardfacing plates where the cost of the consumable is a significant portion of the total component cost.

However, the addition of boron must be carefully controlled. Too much boron can lead to the formation of brittle phases that reduce the toughness of the hardfacing layer. The paper does not discuss the upper limit of boron addition, which would be an important consideration for practical applications.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides valuable guidance for the selection of welding consumables for wear-resistant hardfacing applications. The key takeaway is that the wear resistance of hardfacing layers is primarily determined by the microstructure, particularly the volume fraction and distribution of carbides, rather than by surface hardness alone.

For engineers designing hardfacing overlays, the optimal w(Cr)/w(C) ratio of 4.1 provides a starting point for alloy design. The addition of boron is a promising approach for improving wear resistance, but the boron content must be optimized to balance hardness and toughness.

The study also highlights the importance of understanding the relationship between alloy composition, microstructure, and properties. This is a fundamental principle in materials science that is often overlooked in practical applications where hardness is used as a proxy for wear resistance.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that the choice of welding consumable has a significant impact on the wear resistance of chromium carbide composite hardfacing plates. The addition of boron to the welding wire improves wear resistance by increasing the volume fraction of carbides through enhanced nucleation, even though the correlation between surface hardness and wear resistance is weak. The optimal w(Cr)/w(C) ratio of 4.1 provides a practical guideline for alloy design. For engineers working on wear-resistant components, this study emphasizes the importance of microstructure control over simple hardness specifications, and it offers a cost-effective approach to improving wear performance through boron addition. The findings have direct application in industries where sliding wear is a major cause of equipment failure, such as mining, cement, and steel processing.