ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation and Measurement of Temperature and Stress Fields in Hot Roll Hardfacing Samples

Literature Overview and Core Content

This 2014 paper from Zhejiang Industry Polytechnic College and Zhejiang Construction Vocational College addresses the problem of cracking in hot rolls after hardfacing. The authors used ANSYS software to calculate the temperature field and stress field during the hardfacing process, considering the martensitic transformation of both the weld metal and the base material. They then performed experimental measurements of the temperature and stress fields to validate the simulation results.

The key findings are that the weld seam cools from 1600°C to below 200°C within 6 seconds, leading to martensite formation. The simulation results agree well with the measurements. The maximum tangential stress is located at the end of the weld seam, with tensile stress on the left end and compressive stress on the right end, with magnitudes of 440 MPa and 409 MPa, respectively. At the weld center, the tangential stress initially increases to a maximum of 139 MPa and then gradually decreases during subsequent cooling.

Technical Point Analysis

The rapid cooling from 1600°C to below 200°C in 6 seconds is a critical factor in the formation of martensite. This cooling rate is extremely fast, and it is the primary cause of the high residual stresses that lead to cracking. The martensitic transformation is accompanied by a volume expansion, which generates additional stresses on top of the thermal stresses from the cooling cycle.

Parameter Value Significance
Cooling time from 1600°C to below 200°C 6 seconds Extremely fast cooling, promotes martensite formation
Maximum tangential stress at weld end 440 MPa (tensile) Exceeds typical yield strength of roll materials, leading to cracking
Maximum tangential stress at weld end 409 MPa (compressive) Compressive stress on the opposite end
Maximum tangential stress at weld center 139 MPa Lower than at the ends, but still significant
Simulation vs. measurement agreement Good Validates the modeling approach

The maximum tangential stress of 440 MPa at the weld end is particularly concerning. For typical hot roll materials such as high-chromium cast iron or tool steels, the yield strength is typically in the range of 400-600 MPa. A residual stress of 440 MPa is close to the yield strength, which means that any additional service load could cause cracking.

The paper's consideration of martensitic transformation in the simulation is a key strength. Many simplified models ignore the volume change associated with phase transformation, which can lead to significant errors in the predicted stress field. The fact that the simulation results agree well with the measurements validates the importance of including this effect.

Integration with Engineering Practice

In my experience with roll hardfacing, cracking is one of the most common and costly problems. Rolls are used in hot rolling mills where they are subjected to high temperatures, cyclic loads, and abrasive wear. Hardfacing is used to extend the service life of rolls, but the hardfacing process itself can introduce cracks that lead to premature failure.

The rapid cooling rate of 6 seconds from 1600°C to below 200°C is a key factor in crack formation. This cooling rate is determined by the heat input, the preheat temperature, the roll diameter, and the ambient conditions. In practice, we can control the cooling rate by adjusting the preheat temperature, using interpass temperature control, and applying post-weld heat treatment.

The finding that the maximum stress is at the weld end is also important. This is a stress concentration location where cracks are most likely to initiate. In practice, we should pay particular attention to the weld ends, perhaps by using run-on and run-off tabs to move the stress concentration away from the actual weld joint.

Lessons Learned and Reflections

This paper demonstrates the value of numerical simulation in understanding the welding process. By simulating the temperature and stress fields, we can predict where cracks are likely to form and take preventive measures before the actual welding operation.

However, the simulation is only as good as the input data. The material properties at high temperatures, the heat transfer coefficients, and the phase transformation kinetics must be accurately known. The paper's validation against experimental measurements gives confidence in the simulation results, but the material properties used in the simulation are not fully described, which limits the reproducibility of the results.

The finding that the tangential stress at the weld center initially increases to 139 MPa and then decreases during cooling is interesting. This suggests that the stress state is not static but evolves during the cooling process. This is important because it means that the stress state at the end of welding is not the final stress state. The stress can change as the material continues to cool and as phase transformations occur.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a practical methodology for predicting and preventing cracking in roll hardfacing. The simulation approach, validated by experimental measurements, can be used to optimize welding parameters such as heat input, preheat temperature, and interpass temperature to minimize residual stresses.

The rapid cooling rate of 6 seconds is a critical parameter that must be controlled. In practice, we can use preheating to slow down the cooling rate and reduce the risk of martensite formation. However, preheating also has costs, including increased energy consumption and longer production times. The simulation can help us find the optimal preheat temperature that balances the risk of cracking with the cost of preheating.

The stress concentration at the weld end is a practical concern. In roll hardfacing, we should consider using run-on and run-off tabs to move the stress concentration away from the actual weld joint. We should also consider the use of post-weld heat treatment to relieve residual stresses.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates the value of numerical simulation in predicting temperature and stress fields during roll hardfacing, particularly when martensitic transformation is considered. The rapid cooling rate of 6 seconds from 1600°C to below 200°C is a critical factor in the formation of martensite and the development of high residual stresses. The maximum tangential stress of 440 MPa at the weld end is close to the yield strength of typical roll materials, explaining the propensity for cracking. The good agreement between simulation and measurement validates the modeling approach and provides confidence in the results. For engineers working on roll hardfacing, this paper offers a practical methodology for optimizing welding parameters to minimize residual stresses and prevent cracking, and it highlights the importance of considering phase transformations in any welding simulation.