ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Preheating on Cracking in Pinch Roll Hardfacing

Literature Overview and Core Content

This 2006 paper from Xi'an Aeronautical Vocational College and Shaanxi Pressing Equipment Factory investigates the effect of preheating methods on eliminating cold cracks and hot cracks in pinch roll hardfacing. The paper addresses a common industrial problem: pinch rolls used in steel rolling mills often crack during hardfacing due to the combination of hardened microstructures, hydrogen presence, and welding stresses.

The paper distinguishes between two types of cracks: cold cracks, which are caused by hardened microstructures and hydrogen, and hot cracks, which are caused by the presence of a liquid film and welding stresses. The authors conducted experiments to study the effect of preheating on both types of cracks, providing both practical and theoretical insights.

Technical Point Analysis

Cold cracks in hardfacing are primarily caused by the formation of hardened microstructures, such as martensite, in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and the weld metal. When the hardfacing material has a high carbon equivalent, the cooling rate after welding can be fast enough to form martensite, which is hard and brittle. Hydrogen, which can come from moisture in the flux, the base material, or the atmosphere, diffuses into the weld metal and HAZ and can cause hydrogen-induced cracking.

Hot cracks, on the other hand, are caused by the presence of a liquid film during solidification. This liquid film, which is enriched in low-melting-point elements such as sulfur, phosphorus, and some alloying elements, forms at the grain boundaries and is weak. When welding stresses are applied, the liquid film cannot accommodate the strain, and cracks form.

Crack Type Primary Cause Contributing Factors Preheating Effect
Cold crack Martensite formation, hydrogen High carbon equivalent, fast cooling, moisture Slows cooling, reduces martensite, allows hydrogen to diffuse out
Hot crack Liquid film at grain boundaries Low-melting-point elements, welding stress Reduces welding stress, but may not eliminate liquid film

Preheating affects cold cracks primarily by slowing down the cooling rate. When the base material is preheated, the temperature gradient between the weld metal and the base material is reduced, which slows the cooling rate. This allows the austenite to transform to softer microstructures such as bainite or ferrite instead of martensite. Preheating also allows hydrogen to diffuse out of the weld metal and HAZ before the material cools to a temperature where hydrogen-induced cracking can occur.

The effect of preheating on hot cracks is more complex. Preheating reduces the welding stress by reducing the temperature gradient and the resulting thermal stresses. However, preheating does not eliminate the liquid film itself. If the liquid film is present, hot cracks can still form, although the reduced stress may make them less likely.

Integration with Engineering Practice

In my experience with roll hardfacing, preheating is one of the most important process parameters. The paper's finding that preheating can eliminate both cold cracks and hot cracks is consistent with my experience, but the practical implementation requires careful consideration.

The preheat temperature must be chosen based on the carbon equivalent of the base material and the hardfacing material. For high-carbon steels and tool steels, higher preheat temperatures are required. However, excessive preheating can lead to other problems, such as increased distortion, reduced hardness in the HAZ, and increased energy consumption.

In practice, preheating is typically done using induction heating, resistance heating, or gas torches. The preheat temperature should be measured at a distance from the weld joint to ensure that the entire component is heated uniformly. The preheat temperature should be maintained during the welding process, and the interpass temperature should be controlled to prevent excessive heat buildup.

Lessons Learned and Reflections

This paper highlights the importance of understanding the root cause of cracking before selecting a preventive measure. Cold cracks and hot cracks have different mechanisms and require different countermeasures. Simply increasing the preheat temperature may not solve a hot crack problem if the liquid film is still present.

The paper also emphasizes the role of hydrogen in cold cracking. Hydrogen can come from multiple sources, including moisture in the flux, moisture on the base material, and hydrogen in the base material itself. Preheating helps by allowing hydrogen to diffuse out, but it is also important to control the hydrogen source. This means using dry flux, cleaning the base material, and using low-hydrogen welding processes.

The theoretical analysis in the paper is valuable because it explains why preheating works. By understanding the mechanisms of cold cracking and hot cracking, engineers can make informed decisions about preheat temperature and other process parameters.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides practical guidance for preventing cracking in pinch roll hardfacing. The key takeaway is that preheating is an effective method for eliminating both cold cracks and hot cracks, but the preheat temperature must be carefully selected based on the material and the welding process.

For cold cracks, the preheat temperature should be high enough to prevent martensite formation and to allow hydrogen to diffuse out. For hot cracks, the preheat temperature should be high enough to reduce welding stress, but the primary prevention is to control the composition of the hardfacing material to minimize the formation of low-melting-point liquid films.

The paper also highlights the importance of controlling the hydrogen content. In practice, this means using low-hydrogen welding consumables, drying the flux, and cleaning the base material before welding.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that preheating is an effective method for eliminating both cold cracks and hot cracks in pinch roll hardfacing. Cold cracks, caused by martensite formation and hydrogen, are prevented by slowing the cooling rate and allowing hydrogen to diffuse out. Hot cracks, caused by liquid films and welding stress, are prevented by reducing the welding stress, although the liquid film itself must be controlled through material composition. The paper's practical and theoretical analysis provides valuable guidance for engineers working on roll hardfacing. The key insight is that the preheat temperature must be carefully selected based on the material and the welding process, and that hydrogen control is essential for preventing cold cracks. For engineers in the field, this paper reinforces the importance of preheating as a fundamental process parameter in roll hardfacing and provides a clear framework for understanding and preventing different types of cracks.