ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Microstructure on Performance in Roll Hardfacing

Literature Overview and Core Content

This 2023 paper from HBIS Group Tangsteel Company's Technology Center investigates the relationship between microstructure and performance in roll hardfacing. The study uses submerged arc hardfacing technology with high chromium-molybdenum flux-cored wires to deposit hardfacing alloys on 45# steel substrates. Two different wires were compared: 420L and YD255Mo-S.

The key findings are that the 420L wire produces a hardfacing layer composed of dendritic Fe-Cr solid solution and carbides, while the YD255Mo-S wire produces a mixture of black needle-like martensite and retained austenite. The average microhardness values are 620 HV0.2 for the 420L wire and 634.6 HV0.2 for the YD255Mo-S wire, with maximum errors of 11.9% and 9.1%, respectively. The YD255Mo-S wire produces a hardfacing layer with higher average hardness and less variation.

Technical Point Analysis

The microstructure of the hardfacing layer is the primary determinant of its performance. The 420L wire produces a dendritic structure consisting of Fe-Cr solid solution and carbides. This structure is typical of high-chromium hardfacing alloys, where the carbides provide wear resistance and the solid solution provides toughness.

The YD255Mo-S wire produces a martensitic structure with retained austenite. Martensite is hard and wear-resistant but can be brittle. The presence of retained austenite provides some toughness, but too much retained austenite can reduce hardness and wear resistance.

Parameter 420L Wire YD255Mo-S Wire
Microstructure Dendritic Fe-Cr solid solution + carbides Needle-like martensite + retained austenite
Average microhardness 620 HV0.2 634.6 HV0.2
Maximum error 11.9% 9.1%
Hardness uniformity Lower Higher
Wear resistance Baseline Potentially superior

The higher average hardness of the YD255Mo-S wire hardfacing layer is due to the martensitic structure, which is inherently harder than the ferritic-carbide structure of the 420L wire. The lower variation in hardness is also significant, as it indicates a more uniform microstructure.

The presence of molybdenum in the YD255Mo-S wire is important. Molybdenum is a strong carbide former and also increases hardenability, which promotes the formation of martensite. The combination of chromium and molybdenum provides a good balance of hardness and toughness.

Integration with Engineering Practice

In my experience with roll hardfacing, the choice of welding wire is critical. The wire determines not only the hardness of the hardfacing layer but also its microstructure, which affects wear resistance, toughness, and resistance to thermal fatigue.

The paper's finding that the YD255Mo-S wire produces a more uniform hardness distribution is important for practical applications. In roll service, the hardfacing layer is subjected to cyclic loads and thermal cycling. A uniform hardness distribution ensures that the wear is uniform, which extends the service life of the roll.

The higher hardness of the YD255Mo-S wire hardfacing layer is beneficial for wear resistance, but it may also increase the risk of cracking. Martensite is brittle, and if the hardfacing layer is subjected to impact loads, it may crack. The retained austenite provides some toughness, but the amount of retained austenite must be carefully controlled.

Lessons Learned and Reflections

This paper highlights the importance of understanding the relationship between microstructure and performance. The hardness of the hardfacing layer is not the only factor that determines its performance. The microstructure, including the type, size, and distribution of phases, is equally important.

The finding that the YD255Mo-S wire produces a more uniform hardness distribution is particularly valuable. In practice, we often see hardfacing layers that have acceptable average hardness but poor uniformity, which leads to localized wear and premature failure.

The paper also highlights the importance of alloy design. The addition of molybdenum to the YD255Mo-S wire promotes the formation of martensite and increases hardenability. This is a deliberate alloy design choice to achieve a specific microstructure and hardness level.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides practical guidance for the selection of welding wires for roll hardfacing. The key takeaway is that the microstructure of the hardfacing layer determines its performance, and the choice of welding wire is the primary factor in determining the microstructure.

For applications where wear resistance is the primary concern, the YD255Mo-S wire may be preferred due to its higher hardness and more uniform hardness distribution. However, for applications where toughness is important, the 420L wire may be preferred due to its dendritic structure, which provides better toughness.

The paper also highlights the importance of controlling the welding parameters. The heat input, interpass temperature, and cooling rate all affect the microstructure of the hardfacing layer. By controlling these parameters, engineers can achieve the desired microstructure and performance.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that the microstructure of roll hardfacing layers is the primary determinant of their performance. The 420L wire produces a dendritic Fe-Cr solid solution and carbide structure with an average hardness of 620 HV0.2, while the YD255Mo-S wire produces a martensitic structure with retained austenite and an average hardness of 634.6 HV0.2. The YD255Mo-S wire produces a more uniform hardness distribution, which is beneficial for wear resistance and service life. The study emphasizes that hardness alone is not sufficient to characterize the performance of hardfacing layers; the microstructure must also be considered. For engineers working on roll hardfacing, this paper provides valuable guidance on the selection of welding wires and the importance of understanding the relationship between microstructure and performance. The findings have direct application in steel rolling mills where roll service life is a critical factor in production efficiency and cost.