ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Plasma Transferred Arc Cladding of VC/Tin Bronze Composite Coatings: Microstructure and Wear Performance

Literature Overview and Technical Context

The paper by Gao Huhe, Ding Tingting, Ma Shujin, et al., published in Rare Metals (2017, Vol. 41, No. 1, pp. 45-51), investigates the effect of adding 15 wt% vanadium carbide (VC) to a tin bronze coating deposited by plasma transferred arc (PTA) cladding. The study employs optical microscopy (OM), X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy with energy-dispersive spectroscopy (SEM-EDS), microhardness testing, and a sliding wear test. The Rietveld refinement method was used to analyze the structural parameters and relative content of the phases.

This is a materials science study with direct relevance to industrial applications such as bearing surfaces, guide plates, and wear-resistant components in steel mills, mining equipment, and heavy machinery. Tin bronze is a classic bearing material, but its wear resistance is limited. The addition of hard carbide particles is a common strategy to improve wear performance. The paper's focus on the metastable liquid phase separation phenomenon is particularly interesting, as it explains the formation of Fe-rich particles in the coating.

Key Technical Findings and Interpretation

Phase Composition and Metastable Liquid Phase Separation

The PTA cladding of tin bronze on a steel substrate results in a coating composed primarily of α(Cu,Sn) solid solution, Cu₁₀Sn₃ intermetallic, and α(Fe) particles. The α(Fe) particles are formed by a metastable liquid phase separation mechanism, where the iron from the substrate is diluted into the molten pool and then separates from the copper-rich liquid due to the immiscibility gap in the Cu-Fe system. The Fe-rich particles are spherical, with an average size of approximately 28.20 μm and a relative content of about 8.7%.

When 15% VC is added, the system becomes Cu-Fe-V, and the separated phase becomes α(Fe,V), which is a (Fe,V)-rich phase. The particles are still spherical but smaller, with an average size of about 4.50 μm, and the relative content increases to about 12.2%. The addition of VC also results in the presence of VC, V₂C, and SnO₂ phases in the coating.

Hardness and Wear Resistance

The wear volume of the VC-containing coating is only about 56% of that of the plain tin bronze coating, indicating a significant improvement in wear resistance. The hardness is also increased. The improvement is attributed to the presence of hard VC and V₂C particles, which act as load-bearing reinforcements, and to the refined and more uniformly distributed (Fe,V)-rich particles, which provide additional strengthening.

Practical Implications for Industrial Applications

From my perspective as someone who has specified and used hardfacing materials in steel mills and heavy equipment, this study has several practical implications:

Selection of Hardfacing Material for Bearing Surfaces

For applications like mill bearings, guide plates, and wear strips, the combination of a copper-based matrix with hard carbide particles is attractive because it provides both the conformability and low friction of bronze and the wear resistance of carbides. The PTA process is well-suited for this application because it produces a low-dilution, high-quality deposit with a fine microstructure.

Control of Dilution

The paper highlights the role of iron dilution from the substrate in the formation of the Fe-rich particles. In practice, the dilution rate must be controlled to achieve the desired microstructure. Excessive dilution will increase the iron content, leading to more Fe-rich particles and potentially reducing the corrosion resistance and toughness of the coating. The PTA process typically has a dilution rate of 5-10%, which is acceptable for this application.

The Role of VC Addition

The addition of VC serves two purposes: it provides hard particles for wear resistance, and it refines the microstructure by acting as a nucleation site for the (Fe,V)-rich phase. The reduction in particle size from 28.20 μm to 4.50 μm is significant because smaller, more uniformly distributed particles provide better wear resistance and reduce the risk of particle pull-out during sliding wear.

Wear Mechanism

In sliding wear applications, the hard particles in a softer matrix can either be beneficial or detrimental. If the particles are well-bonded to the matrix and are larger than the wear debris, they protect the matrix. If they are poorly bonded or too large, they can be pulled out and act as abrasive particles, accelerating wear. The study suggests that the VC-containing coating has a favorable microstructure, with the hard particles well-distributed and the matrix providing support.

Process Considerations for PTA Cladding

For shop floor application, the following parameters are critical:

  1. Current and Voltage: The heat input must be sufficient to melt the powder and the substrate surface, but not so high as to cause excessive dilution. Typical PTA parameters for copper-based alloys are 150-250 A, 25-35 V, with a travel speed of 100-200 mm/min.
  2. Powder Feed Rate: The powder feed rate must be matched to the current and travel speed to achieve the desired deposit thickness and composition. For a 15% VC addition, the powder feed rate must be carefully controlled to ensure uniform distribution of the VC particles.
  3. Shielding Gas: Argon is typically used as both the plasma gas and the shielding gas. The flow rate should be sufficient to protect the molten pool from oxidation, typically 10-20 L/min for the plasma gas and 15-25 L/min for the shielding gas.
  4. Preheat and Interpass Temperature: For copper-based alloys, preheating is not always necessary, but the interpass temperature should be controlled to avoid excessive heat buildup, which can cause distortion and grain growth.

Concluding Reflection

This study provides valuable insights into the metallurgy of PTA-clad bronze coatings with VC additions. The metastable liquid phase separation phenomenon is a fascinating aspect of the Cu-Fe system that has practical consequences for the microstructure and properties of the coating. The addition of VC is an effective way to improve wear resistance, and the study provides a clear explanation of the mechanism. For industrial applications, the key is to control the dilution rate and the powder feed rate to achieve the desired microstructure. This paper is a good reference for anyone involved in the selection and application of wear-resistant copper-based coatings.