ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Heat Treatment of Stellite 12 Cladding on 2507 Duplex Stainless Steel: Microstructure and Hardness Evolution

Literature Overview and Technical Significance

The paper by Deng Dewei, Lu Jun, Tian Xin, et al., published in Heat Treatment of Metals (2012, Vol. 37, No. 12, pp. 51-55), investigates the effect of different heat treatment regimes on the microstructure and hardness of a Stellite 12 cobalt-based alloy cladding deposited by plasma transferred arc (PTA) on SAF2507 duplex stainless steel (DSS). The study uses optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and Vickers hardness testing.

This is a highly relevant topic for the oil and gas, chemical, and pump industries, where duplex stainless steel components are often required to have high wear resistance and corrosion resistance. Stellite 12 is a cobalt-based alloy with excellent wear resistance and good corrosion resistance, making it a natural choice for cladding on DSS substrates. However, the heat treatment of the cladding-substrate system is complex due to the different metallurgical behaviors of the two materials.

Key Findings and Metallurgical Analysis

As-Welded Condition

In the as-welded condition, the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of the 2507 DSS substrate shows a large amount of nitride precipitation. This is a well-known phenomenon in duplex stainless steels, where the high nitrogen content (typically 0.24-0.32 wt%) in the base metal can precipitate as chromium nitrides (Cr₂N) during the rapid cooling of the weld thermal cycle. The nitrides precipitate at the ferrite-austenite phase boundaries and within the ferrite grains, leading to a loss of corrosion resistance and toughness in the HAZ.

Effect of Heat Treatment at 1100°C

When the specimen is heat treated at 1100°C for 1 hour and then water quenched, the nitrides in the HAZ dissolve completely. This is because at 1100°C, the solubility of nitrogen in ferrite and austenite is higher, and the rapid cooling prevents re-precipitation. The microstructure becomes more uniform, and the HAZ is restored to a near-equilibrium duplex structure.

Effect of Air Cooling and Furnace Cooling

When the specimen is air cooled or furnace cooled after the 1100°C treatment, σ phase precipitates in the HAZ. The σ phase is an intermetallic compound (FeCrMo) that is extremely hard and brittle. It precipitates in the temperature range of 600-900°C, and its formation is promoted by slow cooling. The presence of σ phase in the HAZ is detrimental because it reduces the toughness and corrosion resistance of the material.

Hardness Changes

The hardness of the cladding layer increases slightly after heat treatment. This is attributed to the refinement of the microstructure and the precipitation of hard phases in the cladding. The hardness of the HAZ is not reported in detail, but the presence of nitrides or σ phase would be expected to increase the hardness locally, which is a sign of embrittlement.

Practical Implications for Fabrication and Service

From a practical standpoint, this study has direct implications for the fabrication and heat treatment of DSS components with Stellite cladding:

The Challenge of Post-Weld Heat Treatment

Duplex stainless steels are generally not recommended for PWHT because of the risk of σ phase precipitation. However, in some applications, PWHT is required to relieve residual stresses or to meet specific hardness requirements. The study shows that the choice of cooling rate after PWHT is critical. Water quenching is the preferred method to avoid σ phase precipitation, but this may not be practical for large components.

Alternative Approaches

If PWHT is required for a large DSS component, the following alternatives should be considered:

  1. Solution Annealing and Quenching: Heat the component to 1050-1100°C, hold for a sufficient time to dissolve all precipitates, and then quench in water. This is the standard solution annealing treatment for DSS, but it requires a large quenching facility.
  2. Localized Heat Treatment: For localized cladding areas, use induction heating or resistance heating to apply the heat treatment only to the cladding and the immediate HAZ, followed by water quenching or rapid cooling with a water mist.
  3. Avoid PWHT: If possible, design the component to avoid the need for PWHT. This can be achieved by using a welding procedure that minimizes residual stresses, such as low heat input, controlled interpass temperature, and proper weld sequence.

The Role of Nitrogen

The study highlights the role of nitrogen in the DSS HAZ. The nitride precipitation in the as-welded condition is a major concern. To minimize this, the welding procedure should be designed to reduce the heat input and the time at elevated temperature. The use of a nickel-based filler metal for the transition layer can also help by reducing the nitrogen content in the HAZ.

Process and Metallurgical Recommendations

Based on my experience with DSS components, the following recommendations are important:

  1. Welding Procedure: Use a low heat input (typically 0.5-1.5 kJ/mm) and a controlled interpass temperature (below 150°C) to minimize the time in the nitride precipitation range.
  2. Filler Metal Selection: For the transition layer, use a nickel-based filler metal (e.g., ERNiCrMo-3) to provide a buffer between the DSS and the Stellite cladding. This reduces the dilution of the DSS into the Stellite and minimizes the formation of brittle phases.
  3. Post-Weld Heat Treatment: If PWHT is unavoidable, use a solution annealing treatment at 1050-1100°C followed by rapid cooling. The cooling rate must be fast enough to avoid σ phase precipitation, typically at least 100°C/min for thin sections and faster for thick sections.
  4. NDT: After heat treatment, perform PT and UT to verify the integrity of the cladding and the HAZ. If σ phase is suspected, perform metallographic examination and hardness testing.

Concluding Reflection

This study is a valuable contribution to the understanding of the heat treatment of Stellite 12 cladding on DSS substrates. The key takeaway is that the cooling rate after heat treatment is the critical parameter. Water quenching dissolves the nitrides and prevents σ phase formation, while air cooling and furnace cooling result in σ phase precipitation, which is detrimental. For industrial applications, the challenge is to achieve the necessary cooling rate for large components. This often requires creative solutions, such as localized heat treatment or the use of specialized quenching facilities. The study underscores the importance of understanding the metallurgy of both the cladding and the substrate when designing heat treatment procedures.