Disbonding of Thick Tube Sheet Cladding: Root Cause and Prevention Measures
Literature Overview and Technical Context
The paper by Chen Xiaochang, published in Welding Technology (2009, Vol. 38, No. 12, pp. 70-71), addresses the problem of disbonding in the weld overlay cladding of thick tube sheets. The author analyzes the chemical composition and stress distribution at the interface between the base material, the transition layer, and the cladding layer, and identifies the causes of disbonding. The paper proposes specific measures for filler metal selection and process control to prevent the defect.
This is a critical issue in the fabrication of heat exchangers, pressure vessels, and reactors, where thick tube sheets are often clad with stainless steel or nickel-based alloys to provide corrosion resistance. The tube sheet is typically made of carbon steel or low alloy steel (e.g., 16Mn, 20MnMo, or 15CrMoR), and the cladding is applied by weld overlay. Disbonding at the interface is a serious defect that can lead to failure of the equipment.
Root Cause Analysis: A Veteran's Perspective
The Interface Chemistry
The disbonding occurs at the interface between the transition layer and the base metal, or between the transition layer and the cladding layer. The author's analysis of the chemical composition at the interface reveals that the primary cause is the formation of a hard, brittle zone due to the dilution of the base metal into the transition layer.
When a stainless steel or nickel-based alloy is deposited directly onto carbon steel, the dilution of iron from the base metal into the deposit can be as high as 20-30% in the first layer. This dilution reduces the chromium and nickel content of the deposit, making it susceptible to the formation of martensite. The martensite is hard and brittle, and it has a different coefficient of thermal expansion than the base metal and the cladding. During cooling after welding, the residual stresses at the interface can exceed the strength of the brittle martensite, leading to disbonding.
The Role of the Transition Layer
The transition layer is designed to mitigate the effects of dilution. It is typically a nickel-based alloy (e.g., ERNiCr-3, ERNiCrMo-3) or a high-alloy stainless steel (e.g., ER309L, ER309LMo) that can tolerate a higher dilution of iron without forming martensite. However, if the transition layer is not properly selected or if the welding parameters are not controlled, the dilution can still be excessive, and the transition layer itself can become brittle.
Stress Distribution
The stress distribution at the interface is influenced by several factors:
- Thermal Expansion Mismatch: The base metal (carbon steel) has a coefficient of thermal expansion of approximately 12 x 10⁻⁶/°C, while the cladding (stainless steel) has a coefficient of approximately 17 x 10⁻⁶/°C. This mismatch creates significant thermal stresses during cooling and during thermal cycling in service.
- Residual Stresses from Welding: The welding process introduces residual stresses due to the non-uniform heating and cooling. The magnitude of these stresses depends on the heat input, the thickness of the component, and the restraint conditions.
- Hydrogen: Hydrogen from the welding process can accumulate at the interface, leading to hydrogen-induced disbonding. This is particularly a concern when the base metal has a high carbon content or when the welding is performed in a high-humidity environment.
Prevention Measures and Process Control
The paper proposes several measures to prevent disbonding, which are consistent with my experience:
Filler Metal Selection
The selection of the transition layer filler metal is critical. The following criteria should be applied:
| Parameter | Recommendation |
|---|---|
| Transition layer filler metal | Nickel-based alloy (ERNiCr-3, ERNiCrMo-3) or high-alloy stainless steel (ER309L, ER309LMo) |
| Cladding layer filler metal | Austenitic stainless steel (ER308L, ER316L, ER347) or nickel-based alloy, depending on the service environment |
| Dilution control | The dilution of the transition layer should be limited to 15-20% maximum |
| Carbon content | The carbon content of the transition layer should be below 0.04% to avoid carbide precipitation |
Welding Process Control
The following process parameters are critical:
- Heat Input: Use a low heat input (typically 10-15 kJ/cm) to minimize the dilution and the size of the HAZ.
- Interpass Temperature: Control the interpass temperature to below 150°C to prevent excessive heat buildup.
- Welding Technique: Use a string bead technique rather than a weave bead to minimize the heat input and the dilution.
- Layer Thickness: The transition layer should be deposited in a single pass with a thickness of 2-3 mm to ensure adequate coverage of the base metal and to minimize the dilution.
Post-Weld Heat Treatment
For thick tube sheets, PWHT is often required to relieve residual stresses. However, the PWHT temperature must be carefully controlled to avoid the formation of brittle phases. For carbon steel base metal, the PWHT temperature is typically 600-650°C. For low alloy steel, it is 620-680°C. The heating and cooling rates should be controlled to avoid thermal shock.
NDT and Inspection
After cladding, the following NDT methods should be performed:
- PT: To detect surface cracks and disbonding at the cladding surface.
- UT: To detect disbonding at the interface. UT with a focused probe is particularly effective for this purpose.
- Metallographic Examination: If disbonding is suspected, perform metallographic examination of the interface to verify the presence of brittle phases or cracks.
Practical Lessons from the Shop Floor
In my experience, the most common causes of disbonding in thick tube sheets are:
- Inadequate Transition Layer: The transition layer is either too thin or the wrong filler metal is used. A thin transition layer does not provide sufficient dilution control, and the wrong filler metal may not tolerate the dilution.
- Excessive Heat Input: High heat input increases the dilution and the size of the HAZ, leading to a thicker brittle zone.
- Improper PWHT: PWHT at the wrong temperature or with the wrong heating/cooling rate can increase the residual stresses and promote disbonding.
- Hydrogen: Hydrogen from the welding process can accumulate at the interface and cause delayed disbonding. This is particularly a concern when the welding is performed in a high-humidity environment or when the electrode is not properly dried.
Concluding Reflection
This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the cladding of thick tube sheets. The key takeaway is that disbonding is a preventable defect if the correct filler metal is selected and the welding process is properly controlled. The transition layer is the critical element, and its selection and deposition must be treated with the utmost care. In my experience, the most effective way to prevent disbonding is to use a nickel-based transition layer, control the heat input, and perform PWHT at the correct temperature. The paper provides a good framework for understanding the problem and implementing the necessary controls.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd