ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Three-Body Abrasive Wear Performance of Carbon Steel Hardfacing Layers

1. Setting the Stage: Why Three-Body Wear Matters

In the field, three-body abrasive wear is one of the most common and most damaging wear mechanisms. It occurs when abrasive particles are trapped between two sliding surfaces, such as a chute and a moving conveyor belt, or a crusher plate and the material being crushed. The abrasive particles act as a third body, grinding away the surfaces and causing rapid material loss.

The research by Niu Chong and Chen Hong from Yunnan Vocational and Technical College addresses this issue by testing the three-body abrasive wear performance of three different hardfacing layers. The study is practical and directly applicable to real-world applications. It answers a question that every maintenance engineer asks: which hardfacing process produces the most wear-resistant layer?

2. Experimental Design and Test Methodology

The research tested three hardfacing layers deposited by different processes. The table below summarizes the key aspects of the experimental design.

Parameter Layer 1 Layer 2 Layer 3
Welding process Coated electrode Flux-cored wire Coated electrode
Composition Similar Similar Similar
Heat treatment As-welded and low-temp tempered As-welded and low-temp tempered As-welded and low-temp tempered
Test method Three-body abrasive wear Three-body abrasive wear Three-body abrasive wear
Load range Variable Variable Variable
Speed range Variable Variable Variable

The test method is a standard three-body abrasive wear test, where the specimen is pressed against a rotating wheel with abrasive particles fed between the surfaces. The wear loss is measured by weight loss after a fixed test duration. The test variables are the applied load and the rotational speed.

The researchers also performed low-temperature tempering on some samples to simulate the effect of post-weld heat treatment. This is an important practical consideration. Many hardfacing components are tempered to relieve residual stresses, and the effect of tempering on wear performance is a key question.

3. Effect of Load and Speed on Wear Loss

The results show a clear and consistent trend: wear loss increases with increasing load and decreases with increasing speed. This is the expected behavior for three-body abrasive wear.

The load effect is straightforward. Higher load means higher contact pressure, which means the abrasive particles are pressed harder into the surface. This increases the depth of the scratches and the rate of material removal. The relationship is not linear, but it is monotonic. The wear loss increases at a decreasing rate as the load increases, which suggests that the wear mechanism transitions from abrasive to adhesive as the load increases.

The speed effect is more interesting. Wear loss decreases with increasing speed. This is counterintuitive at first, but it has a logical explanation. At higher speeds, the abrasive particles have less time to penetrate the surface. They tend to roll rather than slide, which reduces the cutting action. At lower speeds, the particles have more time to dig in and cut, which increases the wear rate. This is a well-known phenomenon in tribology, and it has important practical implications.

4. Effect of Low-Temperature Tempering

The research shows that low-temperature tempering increases the wear loss for all three hardfacing layers. This is a significant finding. Tempering softens the hardfacing layer, which reduces its hardness and increases its wear rate.

The magnitude of the effect is important. The tempered samples show a higher wear loss than the as-welded samples, but the trend with load and speed is the same. This means that tempering does not change the wear mechanism, but it does reduce the wear resistance.

From a practical standpoint, this raises a question: should you temper hardfacing layers at all? The answer depends on the application. If the hardfacing layer is subject to impact loading, tempering may be necessary to reduce the risk of cracking. The reduced wear resistance is the price you pay for improved toughness. If the hardfacing layer is subject to pure abrasive wear, you should skip the tempering and keep the hardness as high as possible.

5. Comparison of Welding Processes

The most important practical finding is that the flux-cored wire hardfacing layer has significantly better wear resistance than the coated electrode hardfacing layer. This is true for both the as-welded and tempered conditions.

The reason for this difference is the microstructure. The flux-cored wire process produces a more uniform distribution of carbides and a finer grain structure. The coated electrode process tends to produce a coarser microstructure with larger carbides and more segregation. The finer microstructure of the flux-cored wire layer provides better wear resistance because the carbides are more evenly distributed and the matrix is more homogeneous.

This finding has direct implications for production. If you are specifying hardfacing for a high-wear application, you should prefer flux-cored wire over coated electrodes. The flux-cored wire process also offers higher deposition rates and better operator comfort, which are additional advantages.

6. Wear Mechanism Analysis

The research identifies the wear mechanism for all three hardfacing layers as a combination of micro-cutting and micro-ploughing. This is the typical mechanism for three-body abrasive wear with hard abrasive particles.

Micro-cutting occurs when the abrasive particles are sharp and the contact pressure is high. The particles cut through the surface, removing material in the form of chips. Micro-ploughing occurs when the abrasive particles are blunt or the contact pressure is low. The particles push the material aside, creating grooves without removing material. The material that is pushed aside forms ridges that can be removed by subsequent passes.

The transition between micro-cutting and micro-ploughing depends on the ratio of the abrasive particle hardness to the surface hardness. If the abrasive particles are much harder than the surface, micro-cutting dominates. If the abrasive particles are only slightly harder than the surface, micro-ploughing dominates.

7. Practical Recommendations and Lessons Learned

Based on this research, I would make the following recommendations for field applications:

  1. Use flux-cored wire hardfacing for high-wear applications. The wear resistance is significantly better than coated electrode hardfacing, and the deposition rate is higher.
  2. Avoid low-temperature tempering unless absolutely necessary. Tempering reduces wear resistance. If you must temper, use the lowest possible temperature and the shortest possible time.
  3. Operate the equipment at the highest practical speed. Higher speeds reduce wear loss, which extends the service life of the hardfacing component.
  4. Control the load to the minimum required for the application. Higher loads increase wear loss, so do not over-engineer the contact pressure.

The research also highlights the importance of understanding the wear mechanism. If you know that the wear is dominated by micro-cutting, you can specify a harder hardfacing alloy. If the wear is dominated by micro-ploughing, you can specify a tougher hardfacing alloy.

8. Conclusion

This research provides a clear and practical comparison of three-body abrasive wear performance for different hardfacing processes. The key findings are that wear loss increases with load, decreases with speed, and increases with tempering. The flux-cored wire hardfacing layer has the best wear resistance, and the wear mechanism is a combination of micro-cutting and micro-ploughing. From a practical standpoint, the most important lesson is to match the hardfacing process to the application conditions. Flux-cored wire is the preferred choice for high-wear applications, and tempering should be avoided unless it is necessary for crack resistance. This research is a valuable reference for anyone who specifies hardfacing or troubleshoots wear problems in the field.